-
Re: Raining Mirrors: Prologue
Hey Andy! Man, I should have reviewed this long ago. I've been meaning to critique something of yours for ages, but everything in your portfolio already had, like, a gazillion ...
Jan 11, 2008 -
Re: Chapter 2: Bloody Battles
Hi there, OverEasy. :) The first thing I noticed was that this chapter is very short. Dangerously short. I know that some novels (in you are indeed hoping to publish ...
Jan 11, 2008 -
Re: Olivia
Oh, phooey. Everyone's already reviewed...:/ Still - even though all the mistakes have been pointed out, why don't I say what I liked and why? It probably won't be very ...
Jan 10, 2008 -
Re: Through the Still Night-Prologue
Warm blood on cold skin. A kunai driven deep into an opponent’s chest. The hoot of an owl. And a full moon. I also often use the technique of listing ...
Jan 10, 2008 -
Re: Gone
TheForgottenAuthor -- This is good, in a simple kind of way. You rhyme well and the grammar is good, but it isn't my kind of poetry. I like poems that ...
Jan 9, 2008 -
Re: My story
kinzygirl223 -- This is okay. The grammatical/sentence structuring errors kind of ruin it; I bet it would be better than 'okay' if you fixed those up. There are some other ...
Jan 9, 2008 -
Re: My Crazy Depression
First off, this is WAY too short. It isn't a haiku, so there's no justification for the length - or lack of - and I think it ended too abruptly. ...
Jan 7, 2008 -
Re: read me like a book
Echo to Suzanne on everything she said - talk normally, and read more poetry. (And I think its 'Amelia' not 'Amilia' but I don't know.) Anyways. This is lacking in ...
Jan 7, 2008 -
Re: The Shadows Bind Me
Echo to Floydian up there. This definitely needs more imagery, and it is kind of navel-gazing. There's no feeling in it - you are just repeating and listing things like ...
Jan 4, 2008 -
Re: Cravings
There should be a forum entitled, 'Cliched poetry' or 'Navel-Gazing'. The poor 'Lyric poetry' forum is clogged with poems about unrequited love and vampires. Hmm... nothing really stuck out for ...
Jan 4, 2008 -
Re: deleted
Sureal already pointed out the nit-picky things, but here are my opinions/advice: Spacing: Please, organize this into paragraphs. Emotion: This piece has no emotion in it - I assume that ...
Jan 3, 2008 -
Re: Pre Chapter 1
Hey Derek! Sota was sitting on his bed studying. This is a rathe anemic opening line. -_- I agree with Errant that you should never start with the main character's ...
Jan 3, 2008 -
Re: question
*shaming the name of SPEW, sorry * SPEW? What's that? Any ways. This is really short - nothing to critique - but it does seem interesting. You should definitely continue ...
Jan 3, 2008 -
Re: Poem Deleted
Yeah, ditto. The first two lines are really cliched, but the rhyming is very good. The only thing that bothered me was that you seem to have written this poem ...
Jan 3, 2008 -
Re: For my grandmother
arch angel -- This is your, what, fourth submission today? Please, no more than one per day or else you shall suffer the wrath of the mods. Heck, I shouldn't ...
Jan 2, 2008
