-
Re: A joyful Sakrant
Hi. From where I’m from Sakrant is an annual kite festival, and this piece seems to be, in a nutshell, about two talking kites who get philosophical and talk about ...
Jan 18, 2016 -
Re: The Great Grimsby [2/2]
Woo! I like the ending. The whole carnation thing. The second part seems slimmer, like it feels like you got right into the action. So Chrys and Miles are frandz ...
Jan 15, 2016 -
Re: The Great Grimsby [1/2]
Hi pomp. I wasted the last half-hour trying to figure what this trope is called at TVTropes. I didn’t. So I’m just gonna go with “shady-object-gets-locals-intrigued-and-slightly-annoyed”. This
Jan 15, 2016 -
Re: Post-perpetual
yo. The second line’s ok. The “and” before “chatter” gets the confusion going. You could just reword it to prevent further head scratching. You could, ’cause it doesn’t look like ...
Jan 6, 2016 -
Re: Solaria - Limerence
I have a general distaste toward immigrant fiction and all the clichés it comes with (the generational awkwardness, the poorly executed broken English, the foreign phrases and curses in italics). ...
Aug 10, 2015 -
Re: Solaria - Catalyst
I have by now given up trying to “get the emotions” right in my stories. When in doubt, I don’t give much effort to have my characters be surprised or ...
Aug 5, 2015 -
Re: Solaria - Arrival
I used to play a drinking game. I don’t know if I can call it a drinking game since it wasn’t alcohol I drank, but it went something like this: ...
Aug 1, 2015 -
Re: Solaria - Exchange
In Murakami’s “A Wild Sheep Chase”—I keep going back to him not because you have a certain affinity for him, trust me—the nameless narrator devotes an entire chapter talking about ...
Jul 30, 2015 -
Re: I'm sorry that I lied to both you and me
Hey there. I want to start by saying I actually like this a lot. It's raw, and sports a kind of angsty sensibility that makes it interesting. I love the ...
Feb 22, 2015 -
Re: Witch Land Chapter 2
Hey there. I like how you tried to put horror elements into this. It could work. I'm actually, as a reader, immensely interested to know more about Lauren. I like ...
Feb 22, 2015 -
Re: Witch Land Chapter 1
Hey there. Writing an epistolary novel has both its ups and downs. You can do without a lot of descriptions that you don't want to give and even, at times, ...
Feb 22, 2015 -
Re: Immortal Devotion
Hi Urba. Nice seeing a Bengali here. So this was originally written in Bengali. Did you translate it only to get criticism or do you plan on working on the ...
Feb 5, 2015 -
Re: B**** and Bunnies
Hi Redbox. Usually I like reading "Teen" stories even if they seem very predictable. Your main problem here is that you most probably rushed this. There are words missing and ...
Feb 5, 2015 -
Re: Slowly Drowning
Hi David. You have a nice story here, even though I have some issues with it. You do not give a lot of descriptions of the settings, and that could ...
Feb 5, 2015 -
Re: Rosie and I
Yo. With a little work, this could be a really interesting story. When I started reading it,I really hoped that the characters would have at least a little bit of ...
Jan 12, 2015
