User avatar

Gadi.

  • Poetry » Lyrical, General Re: I hate life

    I just realized something too: Directness leads to cliche. This poem tells us a lot. "I hate life." So...what? That's what all the emo people say when they cut themselves. ...

    Sep 21, 2007
  • Poetry » Dramatic, General Re: Look Inside

    Wow. Short. Suggestions: This poem has no potential, but you've done great with it! I like how you create this chain of actions: You touch my lips, my lips kiss ...

    Sep 20, 2007
  • Poetry » Dramatic, General Re: Monochrome

    Mmmm.... This seemed like a sophisticated poem at first read, but during the second read it all collapsed. I think this has been done before--darkness is light, death is life, ...

    Sep 20, 2007
  • Short Story » General, General Re: Rock. Paper. Scissors.

    NICE! This is really good. I have to say I am impressed. I am wowed. The way you told us the HEART portion, it is info-dump, but there is no ...

    Sep 20, 2007
  • Short Story » General, General Re: Casualty of War

    Mmmmmmmm.... Interesting.... Mmmmm... I am kind of slit in half right now. There are so many places where this story could've went wrong, but in the end there were only ...

    Sep 20, 2007
  • Short Story » General, General Re: trying my hand at the short story...

    Here are my thoughts on this: It seemed like an excellent writing stlye, voice, tone....beautiful writing strageties, really. I felt like I was reading a poem. The problem(s) have to ...

    Sep 20, 2007
  • Poetry » Other, General Re: Hope Springs Eternal

    "September eleventh: when nightmarish sounds Echoed throughout our globe. " Why do you tell us that the sounds were nightmarish? SHOW us! "Though the future's uncertain, veiled in doubt, Hope ...

    Sep 19, 2007
  • Poetry » Other, General Re: Untitled

    Wow. I like this. It's not amazing, but it's one of the better poems on here. I loved how you wrote that the "flames licked the stones" (or something like ...

    Sep 19, 2007
  • Poetry » Lyrical, General Re: My True Love

    It's going to be hard critiquing this. The only bad thing about this is...CLICHE!!!!!!!!!!!!! ARGH! People like WRITING cliches, but they hate READING cliches. Guess which one I am going ...

    Sep 19, 2007
  • Poetry » Dramatic, General Re: Brandy Alexander

    I like it! The first two sentences were confusing, but after I understood that the entire meaning of the poem was the Anne Frank "I want to live even after ...

    Sep 19, 2007
  • Poetry » Dramatic, General Re: Worth It?

    My favorite stanza from this was "to sit and stare at the girl of your dreams but thats just it, dreams. Thump Thump. " It's ironic and funny. Otherwise, the ...

    Sep 19, 2007
  • Poetry » Dramatic, General Re: when we wake, we forget what we have dreamed.

    The beginning is excellent. I like the fog metaphore...but I hated the last two lines of stanza one! They seemed so passe, and incredibly unrhymthic, especially "as a wounded ghost" ...

    Sep 19, 2007
  • Lyrics » General, General Re: Rushed Relationships

    I agree--the beginning is kinda rocky, and there are some parts that just zap the whole song (like "So don't let them Call you an angel. Because then You are ...

    Sep 19, 2007
  • Poetry » Dramatic, General Re: Worrying

    I think all the people above already said everything, but here are a few minor suggestions: "With confusion..." Completely agree with Clau. Way too tell-not-show. "Straight backed against the chair." ...

    Sep 19, 2007
  • Poetry » Lyrical, General Re: The valley

    The first stanza has several problems. As I walk to the valley of death… {Why the three dots?} It is a site to behold. {This is telling us. Plus, delete ...

    Sep 18, 2007


Every first draft is perfect, because all a first draft has to do is exist.
— Jane Smiley