-
Re: Greg
This has a lot of potential, but as it stands it's lacking emotion. You're halfway there - if you add to this piece and go into more detail then I ...
Apr 11, 2008 -
Re: Sitting in a sea full of people
I really liked the idea behind this but a few things let your poem down slightly. They are talking Not to me Doesn't run very smoothly and doesn't make sense. ...
Apr 10, 2008 -
Re: Unloved- Prologue (edited)
This was very intriguing and yes, I suppose I did like it. The blade pierced into my chest shedding a thousand crimson tear drops onto the ground. Strong start. I ...
Apr 9, 2008 -
Re: Beyond
Hi there. Well, both versions were written beautifully - you have a good way of capturing the feel and emotions of the moment and transporting the reader there. I preferred ...
Apr 9, 2008 -
Re: Just Friends
This is very short and I think that with the idea that you've got you may be better off writing a prose piece for it instead. What I would suggest ...
Apr 8, 2008 -
Re: The 1st Day
Hi and welcome to YWS. We do ask that you critique two pieces before you post your own and keep to the 2:1 ratio. I liked the twist at the ...
Apr 8, 2008 -
Re: The Heart of Life
Hi Mark. This was a beautiful piece; very poetic. I loved the last two lines. I also found very little at fault with this piece. and rewards those who dance ...
Apr 8, 2008 -
Re: The Genius and the Madman
I have to agree with Krupp. This is a very interesting way of revealing characteristics. A sort of Jekyll and Hyde. I liked the narrative a lot. I think that ...
Apr 8, 2008 -
Re: Heat Struck Memories
Hey Jess! I liked this and I liked how the story turned out to be about racism - on some level. I knew that it was hot but who knew ...
Apr 8, 2008 -
Re: Stars #1
Hi and welcome to YWS! I enjoyed the style of your writing, the narrative was your strong point. Pierre twitched his long fingers, anxiously his eyes never leaving the bulging ...
Apr 8, 2008 -
Re: Wuthering Heights
I finished this book yesterday. It's not one of my favourite classics; I prefer Rebecca. Having said that it is much better than Jane Eyre, which I detested. I found ...
Apr 8, 2008 -
Re: To Be invisible
This was very thought provoking and there was a lot of emotion behind it. I know the topic that the poem refers to as I watched a Bob Geldof documentary ...
Apr 7, 2008 -
Re: Oh Baby, How could you?
There was something about this that made me want to read it all, yet made me feel like it was lacking something. Punctuation was a big problem in this as ...
Apr 7, 2008 -
Re: tempest #1
Hiya! This was good, it shows that it could lead somewhere and I like your style. However there were several spelling mistakes so I suggest you use a spell checker ...
Apr 7, 2008 -
Re: Finally Home- ch.1&2
Hi, welcome to the site. First of all, we like to keep the crit to post ratio at 2-1 here so please don't post any more until you have critiqued ...
Apr 7, 2008
