I realize that during all this time I have not said a word.
I open my mouth to speak but am soon interrupted.
“I’m sorry to disrupt everyone’s, most intriguing, conversation, but are we going to get to the matter of things yet or not?” I look away from the stranger and face the person who spoke. He seems nothing but bored, judging everyone with small, narrow eyes. I can’t make out his age… He doesn’t appear to be older than my parents, yet his eyes are completely drained of colour, something which only happens to victims of Scorpio, or, very rarely, if you make it past the age of 60.
Silence continues to fill the air around us.
“No? Nothing? Really? What are we going to do with her?” He raises his voice, a frigid tone that sends shivers up and down my arms.
“I’m thinking, Agro.” The young man at the head of the table says.
“Well, we can’t read your thoughts now can we? It would rather help if you spoke them out loud.” Lou snaps back.
“Hmm. It would be rather helpful if we had a telepathy machine now wouldn’t-” I look over at the person who said this. He is dead serious, not kidding. His voice is so calm and peaceful against Lou’s battling cries I almost have the urge to laugh.
“Shut up Noah.” She snarls at him, reminding me of a hungry beast.
There is only one more person I have not yet noticed at this bizarre table.
A woman, with black, lucid hair cropped up to her shoulders and a diamond-faced shape sits hidden behind the man who apparently is named Agro. She is so slender and tiny behind his masculine build that I hadn’t noticed her before. Now that I she comes out of his shadow to speak, I feel my body go suddenly still. My eyes unblinking, shock numbing my muscles.
I have also seen her before.
Before Sky’s incident. Something that had completely escaped from my thoughts. The woman. The mysterious woman who was talking to my mother. The woman who ignited my parent’s fight during the night. The woman who warned my mother to be careful about our changing world. What is she doing here?
I keep my eyes fixed on her, but she refuses to face my way.
“Kole, why don’t we simply have a discussion and decide what to do with her?” She says in a still, soothing voice.
“You mean how to get rid of her.” Lou retorts back.
I roll my eyes. I don’t think I’m scared of her anymore.
I realize the blurry fog that covered my eyesight up until a few minutes ago has cleared, the sedation suddenly losing its effect.
The leader, Kole, finally opens his mouth to speak.
“Right. Ember, isn’t it?” He looks at me, “See that door behind me? Go through it and we’ll come and call you when we’re ready.” I think he’s about to offer a smile, but then he changes his mind and just points to the door.
I hear Lou behind me making some type of protests on how I shouldn’t be left alone. As if I could back-flip out of a window, I laugh to myself.
As I go through the door, which looks more like a metallic vault, I remember there aren’t even any windows for me to back-flip out of. Before I have time to process, I feel my breathing grow heavy. I feel my heart run faster and pound against my rib cage as if wanting to get free of its cage. I am far, deep underground, I remind myself. Sweat starts dripping down my forehead. I don’t like closed spaces. I never have. I have to restrain myself from letting the screams escape from the corners of my mouth. I clench my teeth together and my hands are held in tight fists on my sides. Something salty gets into my mouth. Blood. My lip starts stinging. I must have bit it.
Distract yourself, I think, Get your mind on something else. Before my head starts spinning and growing dizzy as I feel it just might, I start walking around. I realize this room is even darker than the one we were just in. All around me I feel surrounded by a tribe of dancing spirits. These oil lanterns give off the strangest of shadows. This room is so tiny it would be considered a storage room in normal houses, although I highly doubt this… refuge can be compared to the cube houses we all live in.
In front of me is an old book shelf, and I think it’s made of wood, which is unusual though because the Authority forbids the cutting down of trees and production of any wooden materials. What is this place?
“The dust on these books is unbelievable isn’t it?”
I don’t have any time to jump at the sound of his voice since the dust he blew of the top of one of the books got into my throat, making me cough.
It’s the older man, Noah.
He looks at me, offering an unrequited smile. I keep glaring at him. I finally exhale, about to speak, but stop. I continue trying to talk for about a minute, not sure from where to start. All he does is flick the pages of the old book in his hands.
“Take your time.” He says.
I count to ten and start again.
“Why are you here?” I finally hear words come out of my mouth.
“Why am I here with you or why are we here here?” he keeps flicking the pages, never looking at me.
“Both.”
“Okay, well, as you may have guessed the people in there don’t really care about my input, I’m considered the weirdo of the group,” He laughs. “Which is big considering the group itself.”
I start to think he forgot about the second question when he finally raises his head at me, his tiny spectacles laying on the tip of his nose. “Why are we here, in this strange underground refuge? I don’t think I’m really supposed to tell you yet, but if they get mad at me you can just say ‘Oh you know, Noah’s just the crazy old man, he didn’t know what he was saying’ because that’s what they think anyways.” He chuckles to himself.
Part of me wants to smile. He is like a weight leaving your shoulders, he already made me forget about my small claustrophobic attack.
“So this is our secret meeting place. Think of us as secret, ultra hidden spies who no one knows about.”
I can’t say his answer really helped me place the pieces together, but I don’t ask again.
“You know what this place is anyways?” He asks me.
He doesn’t wait for an answer. Instead, he goes to the end of the book he is holding and lets a crumpled up, almost brown piece of paper slip out and hands it to me. I notice his arms are very shaky, and his veins slither through them like blue snakes. I wonder if he has Scorpio. The paper feels rough, like sandpaper, I assume it must be very old.
Inside it is a drawing.
It’s nothing like the geometric scribbles I always draw though. I’ve never seen this type before. It’s like a plan of this place, this underground retreat. There is a symbol on the top left corner: a yellow circle with three black triangles.
“What does this mean?” I ask him.
“This,” He answers, “This place, is called a Fallout Shelter. It was built during the Last Age, more than a century ago. The Last Age, you’ve studied that, I believe. The wars. These refuges were built everywhere, specifically built to protect the civilians from those minor nuclear bombs.”
A lot of questions form in my mind and I try to get them out.
“How do you know this? Why didn’t they ever teach us? Why haven’t I ever come across one before?”
He chuckles.
“I like you.” He smiles at me while I continue staring at him incredulously. “Well, firstly, I’ve read it in all these books which lay before you.” He starts running his hand against the spines of the books on the shelf as if they were sacred and a single touch brought knowledge into his brain. “These aren’t the books you’re used to, Ember. The Authority doesn’t know about this place. They think all of the Shelters have been destroyed.”
I don’t immediately understand how the two things he said relate to each other but soon enough it hits me, The Authority doesn’t know about this place. I repeat in my head. That means that these books in front of me are…
No.
It can’t be.
Banned Books.
These are the Banned Books. These are the books that the Authority does not know of. These are the books which might actually come from our past, not the books the Authority provides for us, written by Members.
It takes a large part of me to grab hold of that rope in the back of my mind and pull me back in before spiralling in between these pages and never wanting to leave this room. This small and narrow room, I remind myself. I can’t dive into these words, I need to find out more.
“Banned Books.” I whisper.
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Me again, Writer Girl

I like Noah. He seems like a gruff and interesting character, willing to answer questions but knowing that he is looked down on despite his potential. In fact, I like him more than I'm liking Skylar the moment. I guess Skylar is in a rather difficult position but he's trying to fight for Ember's side anyways. Nice introduction of a new character here
What? This is something we've never heard, and you brush over it all too quickly. Why does it happen? For victims of Scorpio I could understand, but why when you get passed the age of sixty? You've got me interested in knowing this...
Isn't that what they've supposedly been doing this whole time? Maybe change this to: why don't we have a little discussion in private to decide... etc. That way we can immediately understand they want Ember gone for the time being, and it doesn't seem like she's pointing out what they've already done.
The claustrophobic attack seemed really sudden. Maybe build up to it gradually a bit more... mention how her hands start to sweat and she suddenly feel the darkness pressing on her like never before. Then go on to explain how her heart was racing and she felt like she couldn't breathe, and so on. Mentioning the small physical reactions and thoughts before the attack can help pace it better.
Commas should never be used in replacement to small words. So it should be: don't really care about my input and I'm considered the... etc. Also, again I'm wondering why. Maybe Noah could go on to explain this weird thing he did once, but it makes perfect sense to him, And he doesn't get why the others see him as weird an have dismissed him ever since or something.
Hmm... from the way Ember keeps saying 'the' it makes it seem like she new these books existed before. But she doesn't know about this organization and she was a complete follower of her society before. So she probably has never heard of them. So maybe don't say the Banned Books but just say: I never knew these existed before. Books that even the authority is unaware of or something!
Eeee, one more part and then I'm all caught up with the story! I have to go read it
Deanie x
Hi!
Actually, what I mean is that the Authority has forbidden almost all books from the past, and replaced them with books written by them. So that's what I mean when I say 'Banned". I'll add that in somewhere.
)
I'll go look at that claustrophobic attack again, maybe look up online some symptoms as well.
I'll also fix those few nitpicks.
About Noah, I think in the last part of the chapter Sky explains why he thinks he's weird so tell me if you think that maybe it's better to mention it here
Hmm I think I'm going to have to explain the Banned Books a bit better, I tend to do that a lot: take for granted that everyone knows what I'm talking about when it's actually all in my imagination... oops!
Oh! The Scorpio thing! I mention it the first time in the second chapter when she's at school, so actually again, I should add exactly what it is. It's a disease which basically makes you grow old in a few days, a week, and then kills you. (...there's something to it hint hint
thanks again!
Hello there, thegirlwhowrites. I, a bold Knight of the Green Room, am here to review you on this fine Review Day. I hope you don't mind.
I should also note that I haven't read any of the previous parts (at least, I don't think I have), so if I bring up something already addressed earlier in the story, feel free to disregard it.
With that said, rawrafied has already gone through the grammar a fair bit, so I'm just going to mention that there are quite a few redundant sentences, especially dialogue tags. What I mean by that is you have quite a few spots where you describe a character's actions/thoughts, and then have them say those things aloud, or vice versa. Cutting down on these redundancies would streamline your prose, which makes reading easier.
Another thing that would help is incorporating some more physical descriptions, especially of the characters. Right now, there is pretty much no description of the other characters, and their dialogue isn't distinct enough to distinguish which character is which. I thought Lou was the "he" being referred to in the earlier paragraphs since she wasn't described when she first spoke. With that said, what descriptions are present are clumped all together, which reads like an infodump. Instead of going dialogue, description, dialogue, it would work better if you incorporated the physical descriptions into the characters' actions, so that it reads more like dialogue, action + description, dialogue. The placement of the description is also important, and in some places, it interrupts the flow of the dialogue.
For example:
The description at the end of Noah's line delays Lou's interruption, so that it seems like she interrupts long after Noah has trailed off. It makes more sense to describe Noah's voice after the "Hmm." instead of at the point Lou cuts him off.
If you can iron out these structural issues, the flow of this chapter would be much stronger for it.
Thank you!
) the reason why I don't have many descriptions in this piece is because my narrator has her vision covered.

I really appreciate your comment and will deifinitely keep it in mind while writing. Just one thing though: (which now I realize I didn't really mention in this bit of the chapter since it's in the previous one
Hey there, thegirlwhowrites! GreenLight24 here with a review for you in this magnificent March review day!

First of all, I'd just like to let you know that I have not read any of the other chapters of this novel, so I'm not going to be reviewing based on plot details, etc. Rather, I'll be focusing on this chapter as a stand-alone piece.
My favorite thing about this chapter is the way in which it is narrated. I can tell that you've out a lot of thought into the narrative voice of your main character and developing them as a personality. Sometimes, first person novels can get a little bit boring if the narrator is a flat character, but I don't think that is the case here. You seem to have fashioned a main character who has some personality and who the reader can really brine invested in over the course of your story. One of the hardest hints to do when writing a novel is to keel your reader engaged with the text, especially when it comes to action/adventure novels. I can tell from reading only this chapter that this novel is nowhere even remotely close to being boring. Good job of keeping things fresh ad exciting.
The only bit of constructive criticism I have for you is that you go the extra mile and step up your descriptive elements. Right now, the narrative ones are pure awesomeness, but I think you could make this chapter even better than it already is.
I hope this short review was helpful for you and happy review day! Always remember, always keep writing!
thank you that was so nice!
Within just the first few sentences, you've done a great job of getting the character's voice to be reflect appropriately for first person dialogue.
Nice start. Because it can be excluded, put commas around 'during all this time'.Here are some corrections/suggestions:
'Open' is present tense and 'interrupted' is past, therefore there is tense agreement. There's tense switches through out this piece.
The ellipsis seem unnecessary here. However, if you're to employ them, you need to either lowercase 'he' or do the ellipsis as '... .' since you have it as two sentences.
Major run on sentence.
Liked the quoted part. However, the period after 'Argo' should be a comma.
Again, comma instead of period.
Period of hyphen. Also, you used the en dash here, which is used to make a compound word out of two words. You should employ an em dash here, which is used for interruption.
Remove 'I'.
I'm gonna stop right here. Hope this was helpful. Happy Review Day~~~! ^_^
thank you so much! It really was helpful, I'll make the changes now!
wow. How much have u written? Working on a novel myself: about 110k words so far. About half done
Oh cool I'm only on 21k and basically the beginning....
By the way I love your profile picture!