“What are we going to do with her?”
“She’s a spy!”
“I knew we weren’t safe here…”
Muffled voices awake me. The immediate blackness again from covers my eyes and it scares me. Why can’t I see anything? I feel my hands brushing themselves against a rough fabric where my face lies, so I know they have put something, a bag, to cover it. Or to cover what my eyes should be seeing.
“She’s awake!” someone whispers.
“How did she even find us?”
“Whatever. I say we kill her.”
Panic strikes me. They are talking about me. Kill me. I’m the one who snuck into a place I shouldn’t have entered. I’m the one who followed him here.
Him.
Sky.
What is he doing here? Why isn’t he freeing me?
I try looking at myself from outside my fabric. The same gray clothes, black bag covering my face… There is no way he could recognize me.
I start shouting, frantically needing to see where I am. Who is talking. What they’re doing.
“Sky?! Sky where are you?!”
It’s only a few seconds later that I realize the sound coming from my mouth is not what I’m hearing in my mind. They have also covered my mouth, making it impossible for me to speak. I feel my chest moving up and down heavily, and I try to break free from the chair I’m tied to. Fear drains in on me. I am trapped.
“Give her a shot to make her sleep! Come on!”
I agitate myself even more, banging my knee against a table, sending a sharp sting of agony rushing through my veins.
“Why don’t we just talk to her, I’m sure we could reason… Make her see like us, maybe just let her go and leave it all behind us…?” a sweet suggesting voice suddenly fills me with calmness, but it doesn’t last long.
“Shut up!” Everybody seems to shout at the voice.
“I swear, why did we even let him into this group?”
“I thought we agreed to kill all trespassers, what are we waiting for?!”
“Kill, kill.” I really do hope they would stop saying that word, “Okay then, Lou, since you’re so eager to take lives away, tell us how exactly you would proceed in this?” I don’t think I want to hear this girl’s answer.
“Well, my mother used to kill rabbits holding them by their ankles and hitting them with a large blow to the head…”
I feel myself swallow hard, my throat remaining dry. She was obviously not finished, but the man who had asked her how she would kill me interrupted her, clearly not having been affected by her comment as I have.
“Okay then, there is still one thing I’m just not quite sure about… I hope you could shed light on it for me. Where, I ask, would we find a giant in order to hold her arms and legs apart?”
I can hear the girl Lou starting to stammer a good comeback but I don’t get to hear what she’s come up with since someone else saying, “No, seriously, if we were to get rid of her, I would suggest enclosing her in one of our narrow storage rooms. And, according to my calculations, it would probably take about 36 hours for the oxygen to run out…”
“Come on, if you consider the height and area of the storage room you would be smart enough to know that it would take her approximately 4 days to die. It’s basic knowledge.”
“Oh really? What about the weight of the prisoner?”
“The weight?!”
After that people start bellowing and arguing about my weight, whether I’m 55kg or “What the hell are you saying? She’s maximum 52!” and I don’t know anymore whether I’m scared, confused or even just the slightest amused at the scene. I prefer my ‘kidnappers’ to fight about my weight rather than ways to kill me. I don’t know from where it’s coming from, but part of me wants to laugh, almost all fear suddenly drained away. I realize the people on the other side haven’t the slightest clue of what to do, just like me.
“Everybody shut up!” It’s the stern voice that shuts off all the amusement in my mind. “God, we just need to figure out what to do okay?” He pauses for a second. “And no more talk about killing for goodness sake, we’re not like them.”
I can slightly hear some annoyed mumbling, probably from the most eager to kill me, Lou, “And no more talk of killing for goodness sake…” she repeats, in a high pitch, mimicking her leader.
The silence doesn’t last long. Soon enough, they are all back to disputing and shouting about their various ways to confront me. Confront me. As if I’m some kind of danger?
“Make her think this is a dream!”
“She’ll return here to find out, you idiot, then we’ll be back where we are now.”
The leader, I’ve now recognized is sitting on my left, lets out a long sigh and I imagine him burying his head in his arms.
I stop trying to make out what they’re saying. Instead, I listen for voices, trying to concentrate on his familiar, melodic voice.
To my surprise, there is one voice I do recognize, but it’s not his. It can’t be his. It’s too rough. Husky, reminds me of an edge of a cliff. One side beautiful and full of nature and the other rocky and jagged, a vast emptiness beneath.
But Sky’s is higher, always sounds like he is thinking of something other than what he is saying, his thoughts always one step ahead. Distracted yet spirited like the melody of a bird. It sounds like…
“We certainly can’t let her go now.”
Sounds like that.
I move up and down, trying anything to let him see through the black cloth and into the friend he’s grown up with all his life.
But there is no use.
“That’s it. Hand me the anaesthetic.”
My mind activates its engine. There has to be a way for him to realize who I am.
And then I know.
I bend my neck down, moving my chin close to the rounded collar of my shirt. Unable to use my hands I manage to pull down the top of my shirt just enough to feel the shape of my collarbone brushing against my chin.
I feel a sharp sting of a needle starting to enter the skin of my arm, letting go of any hope I had that Sky had understood what I was trying to show him.
“Stop!” my drooping eyes open wide. Silence falls in the room and all I can hear is his confused whisper, stuttering my name. “Ember?”
I hear a chair scraping against the soiled floor and trembling legs running towards me. I feel his hands, as rough as sandpaper, and the chewed nails grazing for a second against my neck as he unties the fabric loose from my head.
The last thing I see are his amber eyes growing brighter as he slaps me hard on the cheek to try and get me back to them.
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Hi Writer Girl!
So this is the end of chapter four... it was interesting. I guess we learn that her captors aren't the smartest people in the world... kind of bickering and amusing. They kind of remind me of the Seven Dwarfs from Snow White xD I love it! I also love how her way to save herself was to make Skylar recognize her... and she works in this chapter to do this in the only way she knows how.
When I read this I was like: whoa what?! It makes it seem like she was trying to have x-ray vision and see through the bag! It took me a while before I understand what you meant. Maybe try something like: I tried to see myself as they did.
It would be simpler to word this as: I don't know whether I'm scared any more. Small things like word order can greatly improve the fluidity of a story
I think this should be: I prefer my kidnappers fighting about my weight... No 'to' is necessary here.
When Skylar slaps her across the face I was super shocked for a moment! I didn't understand that the drug was taking its toll and she was being put to sleep. You did tell us she was pricked, which I do note, but it would help if you also demonstrated some drowsy feelings she had other than just her eye drooping. It would make the slap a little less sudden
I was wondering though, why even bother? The drug was going to take affect sooner or later and it's best without pain right? Now you know she's Ember put her to sleep and then when she wakes up question her. That's what makes more sense to me...
I'm looking forwards to putting names and voices to faces from this chapter. And seeing what this underground group of people are up to... and why Skylar never invited Ember before!
Deanie x
I just wanted to tell you that your comments are making me so inspired to continue, thank you!
How the story comes across to the reader is one of the most important things so I'm happy that you tell me when it's confusing or you don't understand so I'll try to change those things.
You'll find out soon!
Hi! Here to review!
I really enjoyed this story, and I'm actually going to go and read the other parts! Maybe another review!
This was very well-written, and had a lot of detail despite the fact that the character could not see. Even when a sense is taken away from a character it is important to make up for it in some way, much like you did. Otherwise, the reader can get lost and confused, and become distracted from the plot.
One critique I have is:
"The leader I’ve now recognized is sitting on my left, lets out a long sigh and I imagine him burying his head in his arms."
There should be a comma after 'The leader'. That clause is describing the person in further detail and needs to be separated from the noun. If not the rest of the sentence sounds a bit off.
I did like how you explained the voices so that the reader could imagine it well. It wasn't too wordy, and you made a nice metaphor to exemplify what you wanted it to sound like. It can be hard to explain the character's point of view, and you did a superb job at it.
I also liked how you made it easy for the reader to distinguish each and every voice. Although the character does not know what's going on, the reader should be well-informed, in order to keep them reading, and so they don't become tiresome trying to figure out what is going on.
I truly enjoyed this chapter, and I'm hoping to read more! As always keep writing and have a nice day!
Thank you so much! I'm happy you enjoyed it and hope you like the rest!
It would not be right if I did not review your book in its entirety! However, I will stick to what I find in the Green Room today. If you want the rest of the novel reviewed, just drop me a post in my review for food thread!

Alright, more great pieces from you, but let's pick out again my nitty tool.
...The immediate blackness again covers my eyes and it scares me...
What is the immediate blackness. I can't find it in the previous chapter parts. YOu need to describe this darkness! Perhaps the MC's emotion at the same time?
...“How did she even find us?”
“I say we kill her.”...
This is a quick change of subject. Even though it's great when you want something fast paced, I think there should be more dialogue before person number two advocates killing off the MC. Right now Mister Two sounds anxious, but not rational. Is that supposed to be? Shouldn't he be dismissing Person One's curiosity?
...“Give her a syringe to make her sleep!”...
A better dialogue would be: Give her a shot to make her sleep! Agree with that?
...“Shut up!” everybody seems to shout at the voice....
Everybody needs to be capitalized. (No pun intended!)
All other mistakes are of the same form!
I really like how you express the MC's fear and confusion. It is really good.
Keep Writing!
Thanks again!
Yeah, what I meant with the 'immediate blackness' was the fact that they had tied a bag around her head but maybe that isn't clear... I'll go back and see
I am living for next chapter! Plz continue. Biggest fan <3
Aw really?
Thank you so much, it means a lot :*