Crisis in Orbit

by pettybage

Published August 2, 2011

In small stuff

I've taken this down, as I'm starting to query agents and publishers with this attempt at a more ambitious project. Wish me luck.

Comments & reviews · 4
User avatar
shadowraiki
Review
shadowraiki wrote a review Review · Aug 9, 2011

All the terminology set a pace that left me wanting more. I could imagine all of this happening above earth. Even in the beginning when there was no action, I was intrigued. Though there were a few things I noticed:

“Wait,” Kelly’s voice replied, “I’m getting some data,


“Excellent!” rang out Tal’s excited voice, "I’ve just started my livefeed half a minute ago!

Those were just two small grammar things I noticed. As for the story:

What?” asked Hannah, suddenly alert. She didn’t like the sound of that ‘uh-oh’.

“Captain, you smell something?” asked Kelly’s voice.

“I think I do,” said Wilson. “You think maybe it’s leaking?”



They can smell inside of their suits? I'm not so sure that works when you're hooked up to an oxygen tank. Or am I mistaken? Also, there are times when I think you use 'he' instead of 'she' and that creates some confusion. Overall, I am interested in what happened next.

User avatar
pettybage
Comment
pettybage commented Comment · Aug 2, 2011

Thanks, Nate,
polish, yes, absolutely. Dialogues, also various mini-inconsistencies, like the tourist's livefeed suddenly becoming a recording, etc. But he'll have to stay a space tourist on a space walk, at the price of some disbelief suspension credits, because such are the needs of the plot and to them I shall catereth.
Glad the visuals made an impact. Had to watch a few documentaries and slideshows to get the feel, hopefully will sharpen them further when editing time comes.

User avatar
Nate
Review
Nate wrote a review Review · Aug 2, 2011

Good chapter. I especially like how you opened it. Paragraphs like:

And it all moved, at a visible speed. Groups of more or less straight, elongated super-clouds, like enormous strands of cotton, swum at a seemingly moderate pace in direction opposite of the space station’s flight. The lack of speed was deceptive. The space station was in fact hurtling at an orbital velocity of over seventeen thousand miles an hour. At this speed, the sun rises every ninety minutes.

Serve to convey the imagery very well of the entire scene.

However, it still needs polish especially in the area of dialogue. The problem is that the dialogue doesn't sound like these guys are professionals. While I would expect banter and the like while in the safe confines of the space station, I wouldn't expect it on a spacewalk. Also, why would they allow a space tourist on a spacewalk? Spacewalks are incredibly dangerous operations that require literally thousands of hours of training. Maybe in a hundred years we'll figure out how to make spacewalks routine and safe, but for the near future, only professionals would be allowed on one.

In any case, here's a good example where the dialogue needs work:
“Dr. Campbell, is there an emergency? The Inquiry’s computer has broken contact and no one is answering the radio.”

Space control would know immediately if there's an emergency. Instead, it should be something like, "Dr. Campbell, we've just received signs of an explosion. Can you confirm?"

Overall, though, I felt this was a solid chapter. It's interesting, has a good opening, and ends well.



"Peace sells, but who's buying?"
— Megadeth