Preface: This is a personal essay I am writing for admissions to university. According to my guidance counselor, and earlier essays I posted on YWS, are not suitable for the purposes of an admissions essay. In this essay I really wanted who I am to come out, and I hope it did. Additionally, it is around 750 words and it should be around 500; any suggestions to cut it down are appreciated. Of course, all constructive criticism is welcome. Happy reading.
How a homosexual man changed my life
“My name is Becca,” I sheepishly said, still slightly nervous about what I was joining.
“Hi Becca!” the club enthusiastically welcomed me.
“I’m a junior, a Cancer, I would put chocolate on just about anything, and I’m here because I want to learn to be more open about other people’s differences.” I took a deep exhale of relief and smiled; this couldn’t be that hard. After I finished my turn at the go-around questions I fell into the human cushion that consisted of my two gay best friends, my bi-sexual friend, and another female friend who was there as a straight ally.
My presence there that October afternoon was solely based upon the friendship that had formed between Todd and me.
Todd was one year my senior and fate brought us together on the bus ride home from the January Math regents. Statistically, in a school of over 3000 students, with no courses shared and no extra-curricular activities shared, it is pure luck that we met and a super natural occurrence that we became best friends let alone friends at all. To this day we wonder “how on earth did the Jewish yeshiva girl become so close to the racy gay boy?”
We started off as acquaintances; Todd helping a freshman navigate the system of classes and teachers and school politics. After a mutual friend had arranged a hangout, we realized we had compatible personalities; we were both witty, enjoyed the same flavor of humor, and not afraid to debate and discuss controversial ideas. We became closer and were able to share our problems and successes. We had mutual respect and an understanding for each other unlike with any of our other friends. Todd taught me to work things out pragmatically, to not give miniscule tasks the merit of worry, to step out of my self imposed boundaries, and to accept people for who they are.
At the end of my sophomore year, the friend I had known so warmly told me he was gay. I had never really known anyone who was gay before; I only knew of the social stigma associated with it. I sat in my room pondering and realized that it did not matter. So what if he liked other boys? He was the same person who had been there for me, who had made me laugh during the darkest of days, and who had so much admired my own personal choices as I dressed and acted differently from my peers.
Todd had opened my eyes to an entire world that up until that point I completely misunderstood. I now saw what it was like to get bullied merely based upon your sexual preference, something atrocious, and yet I could empathize, having been subject to anti-Semitic remarks. Besides taking me to different cultural venues across NYC and exposing me to different foods, people, and cultures, by simply being my friend Todd has enabled me to be more open minded and accept everyone for who they are.
There are two things I am absolutely sure of. You never know the influence you can have on one person, and how one good deed leads to another. It is safe to say, that had I not been introduced to homosexuality by someone who I personally knew and considered a good hearted human being, there is no way I would be as pro-active as I am. I would not have explained to my peers that saying “that’s so gay” is offensive, supported the NY Same-Sex Marriage Bill, nor would I have joined the Gay-Straight Alliance, a club I had been apprehensive about since I began high school due in part to the homophobia in my surrounding environments. The relationship I have with Todd has helped us see each other’s worlds in an entirely new light. I know that Todd now understands and has a new respect for many Jewish practices and looks at Israeli politics more objectively than he had before, because he listened to my beliefs and was able to formulate his own opinions. I also learned that in order to be a good person you need to see beyond what you believe and acknowledge the beliefs and practices of others as equally legitimate. By surrounding myself with people who have different beliefs than I do, I have been able to open my mind to new concepts, ideas, and people and truly be able to think for myself, and learn from everybody.
Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
I can understand why this may not be "appropriate" for a college entry essay. Because it's such a controversial topic, you're making this decision personal. While that can be beneficial if all goes well, it's a huge risk.
The one thing I might change is your brief introduction of yourself -- specifically, capitalizing Cancer. For a second I thought you were saying you had cancer, ha. From what I can find, zodiac signs should always be capitalized.
Anyway, good for you for getting more involved in the LGBT community! I really enjoyed this essay. Sure, I'm a bit biased, but you make several good points about how it really doesn't matter. I love the comparison between homophobia and anti-Semitism, because it really ties everything together. (On a side note, I'm sorry you experienced anti-Semitic remarks!)
I approve of your essay, anyway.
Great job! Good luck if you decide to use this for your application. It's risky, but you're being honest about yourself. And hey, maybe you don't want to go to a school that won't accept you for who you are.
Hey Becca! Before I do anything else, I'm just going to go through and correct some simple things. Since this is a university admissions essay, the grammar, spelling, and punctuation should be absolutely impeccable
So, now that those minor typos are out of the way ...
I think this is a great college application essay and definitely a great topic. It might be beneficial, however, to think about whether the school(s) you're applying to is/are liberal or conservative. A liberal school would probably be happy with this essay, but a school which looks down upon homosexuality probably wouldn't like it too much. But, hey, you never know. My brother applied to Colombia University with an essay about the Boston Red Sox. We all doubted that a snotty Ivy League school in the heartland of Yankee Territory would accept a kid with that essay, but he got in!
Some other things:
This could be offensive to some homosexuals. I think, since you're writing about how a homosexual man changed your life (for the better), and since this is a college application essay, it would be best to avoid all stereotypes, even ones that are neither good nor bad. I mean, you could technically be a straight guy who likes skinny jeans, Lady Gaga, and fashion. It may not be common, I don't know. I just think you'd be safer without this sentence.
It may just be me, but I couldn't really follow this sentence. Revise, perhaps?
Some things I liked:
The beginning. It's great when you start a whole long philosophical essay with an encounter that happened on an average day. The beginning of the essay really put the whole thing into perspective. People remember the stars and ends of things, and the university will surely remember this in a positive light.
This is a very important point and I'm glad you hit upon it. A person's sexuality does not define their character. Getting the world to recognize this is the first step towards ending homophobia.
I like this sentence a lot. It has a great personal flare and it shows that you two are comfortable laughing at yourselves. I don't think anyone will be offended by this sentence because you're referring to yourself and your best friend. Very nice.
Overall, good job! I can't really say where you should cut down on anything because I don't like to just throw away people's work. I think that might have to be something for you to decide on your own. Good luck on getting into the university!
-Abigail
Hey Becca! A quick question... is there a prompt associated with this essay? I would love to help get you into college, but they can be strict about being on topic, and I just want to make sure you're on the right track.