What does Zionism mean to you?
In 1920, my paternal grandfather was smuggled to Israel on the back of a fish truck from Iraq and moved straight to the Old City. In 1950, my paternal grandmother came to Israel, also from Iraq, escaping persecution, and moved into a tent in Rechasim. They didn’t speak a word of Hebrew, their clothes had an air of Arabian nostalgia to them, and were ideologically lacking in all things Israeli. But they were Jews, and they had arrived home.
As a native-born sabra, my father, after four years of army service, left the country. He met my mother, a second-generation American, who would like to stay that way thank-you-very-much. I grew up hearing “Israel is a land that eats its inhabitants,” “I served enough time in the army for the entire family,” and “You were so lucky you were born in America.” Ironically enough I would always be a daughter of Zion. Unless my father changes his first name…then I would only be one in the figurative sense.
From the time I was born, I spent every summer in Israel at my Savta’s house. To her dismay, I’ve learned that there really is more to Israel than her town, Beitar Illit—though I hadn’t seen it at the time. Our last family trip occurred in the summer of 2000. The slew of events that immediately followed that trip; 9/11, the Second Intifada and terrorists on planes and buses was enough reason for my parents to switch our next vacation destination to Florida. Despite all of its “Sunshine State”-glory, I just never had the same connection to it as I do to Israel.
When I was fourteen, I joined a Jewish youth group to stay connected to my heritage while in a public school. When I heard they were running a trip to Israel, I immediately asked my parents if I could go and they said yes, provided that I would finance it myself. I raised the money and joined the trip; this strengthened my love of Israel and inspired me to find ways to fund my future Israel-related experiences. It was the first time I really saw Israel and came back to America feeling like it was indeed my country. When I was fifteen, I decided I wanted to be involved in Israel advocacy. I got my start by getting involved in AIPAC and the Write On for Israel program, where I learned about Israel’s history, current events and got to visit for an intensive, on-the-ground look at the issues. All was dandy; I was an advocate and was perfectly happy doing so in the comforts of America; moving to Israel never crossing my mind, though.
As I became more religiously involved, I decided I wanted to study in a seminary in Israel after high school. After my parents refused, I raised all of the money myself and told them I was going. That summer, a friend and colleague had just returned from a year of yeshiva study with plans of moving to Israel and joining the army. It was the first time a friend of mine had decided to do that and I did not understand. “Why move to Israel and join their army? We get the benefit of free security from here and can visit whenever we like. Yes we’re Jewish, but America is our country,” I maintained. We sat next to each other in the office that summer working and discussing moving to Israel. We discussed Maimonides, Nachmonides, and Herzl…and I came out that summer knowing I would make aliya.
In my year in seminary I got to experience a taste of what living in Israel was like. I lived with Israelis, spoke Hebrew, waited in lines, held women’s babies on buses and got invited to strangers’ houses for Shabbat. I visited the holy cities, both the places mentioned in the bible and new cities established with biblical names. I danced and sang in the streets of Jerusalem with my people and raised money and collected toys for families during Pillar of Defense. I was beginning to understand what it meant to be a Jewish country. With our efforts concentrated together, we are advancing ourselves as Jews without fear of being kicked out. For two thousand years, we survived, and prospered under the auspices of foreign rulers. Now we are sovereign, and are building a state based on our values. We are no longer surviving--we are now living. I have recently decided to defer making aliya until after college so that I can give back to the organizations that gave to me throughout high school. That journey very much requires me to be engaged with Zionism, and so I hope I will be able to do that with you.
Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Hey there,
I am an orthodox Jew, and consider myself a Zionist despite the fact that I can't see myself making aliya for quite a while. It is great to see that you are so vocal and passionate regarding your love for Israel.
As this is a writing website, I will try to give you a piece of advice that is invaluable when writing essays like these.
Know your audience:
You are writing an application essay. Presumably to some Zionist Organization. Already by the topic of your essay, it is clear what they want to see: your passion for Israel.
As it stands your essay is decent in that it shows what you have done to demonstrate your love for Israel. However it is not as good as it could be, because you have made a mistake which is extremely common in essays like this. You have written an essay focused on yourself instead of on Israel. You are trying to demonstrate your love for a country by focusing on what you have sacrificed for her.
Here's an analogy.
You have been asked to write a love poem to your beloved, and your poem looks like this:
My love, I have given you my heart
a thousand times
in winters snow and summer's rain,
and fall's ruthless winds
and spring's enormous waves
And were there tornadoes and hurricanes,
I'd give it yet again.
Compare that to:
I crossed the ocean to see your smile
and wept while you were away
for your heart is white as winter's snow,
your mind as sharp as steel
and when I see you sleep at night
I feel our love is real
The difference between these two poems that I quickly sketched up, is that while the former focuses on the author, the second focuses on the beloved. Elizabeth Browning in her poem How Do I Love Thee, understands this only too well. She realizes that by enumerating the perfections of her lover, she truly expresses her love.
If you want to truly express your love for Israel and show what it truly means to you, spend more time speaking about Israel and less time speaking about yourself.
All the best of luck to you my friend. v'shuvu banim lig'vulam.
I really enjoy the era that you set this story in. I think you can expand a lot on this, and I suggest that you do! I encourage you to re-read through it to fix minor grammatical errors and a few sentence flow issues. Maybe that's just my opinion. Anyways, keep up the good work! And as always, good luck to you and your writing!
very nice.
I would love to visit my linage country but Turkey isnt at the best of relations as of right now. My father would go to the Mediterranean sea every summer until he was 12. though i am ridiculously white and missing my heritage I wish to learn.
i loved the fact that you wrote this. though it is an essay, it was more of a bio and a look into the eyes of the life of the Jewish people that most don't know because they are A-holes and are to self adsorbed in their own lives and religion to see through the eyes of someone else with a different view. sometime i think the whole world has autism.
very nice. it made me think and ponder and that is what essays are ment to do... thank for posting this.