Here I stand,
beneath the strong oak trees.
Listening quietly,
to the gentle breeze.
.
Here I stand,
in the lush green field.
Watching patiently,
natures secrets revealed.
.
Here I stand,
near the pale blue lake.
Upon my tongue,
the salty sand grains betake.
.
Here I stand,
between the rosemary bushes.
It’s alluring smell,
My minds peace it increases.
.
Here I stand,
with the roe deers fawn.
Softly stroking
its soft fur predawn.
.
Here I stand.
In this lush meadow.
The pale water on the sand.
Rosemary bushes home to the sparrow.
While the deer roam the land.
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Hi, Myers here, and please bear with me for this review, it might look harsh.
they sort of look incomplete without each other, and that is what I'd do. To explain further, the whole poem looks like one part of a conditional sentence to me, you know, "If I ........, I'd have.....", and the poem is missing the " I'd have...." part of the sentence. I appreciate your beautiful sense of imagination, the imagery you are trying to create here is also quite beautiful. My advice would be to review other people's work as much as you can to learn new things. Keep on the good work.
First thing, the repetition of "Here I stand" is kinda annoying to me, but you may disagree. "Here I stand" would have looked better, if you had used it in the first and the last stanza only. The word "Here" must be accompanied with "Where", just bluffing
This is a great visual poem, but I feel like it would be better if you didn't squeeze it into a rhyme scheme. Stanzas three and four seem rougher than the rest, with four not rhyming at all and betake standing out strangely in the rest of the poem.
I like the callbacks to the previous settings in the last stanza, but I feel like you should call back to *all* of them, and the punctuation of the stanza throws off the flow. Also, with the pattern of punctuation you have established with commas followed by periods, I feel like there is a comma missing after line three of stanza five.
Very good use of imagery!
This is a great visual poem, but I feel like it would be better if you didn't squeeze it into a rhyme scheme. Stanzas three and four seem rougher than the rest, with four not rhyming at all and betake standing out strangely in the rest of the poem.
I like the callbacks to the previous settings in the last stanza, but I feel like you should call back to *all* of them, and the punctuation of the stanza throws off the flow. Also, with the pattern of punctuation you have established with commas followed by periods, I feel like there is a comma missing after line three of stanza five.
1. What I liked
I loved the way it was written the style if you will.
2. Flow and & Adjectives
The line it's alluring smell doesn't sound quite right some how. It stands by it's self. Also betake doesn't match the rest of the poem
3. Overall & Encouragement
Good job! This flows better then many of the poems I have seen on here. Great job!
Greetings, adelaide!
I haven't reviewed poetry in a while, so just bear with me a little.
I thought that this whole thing could be one sentence. It might be better for the flow, since it's sort of read like one sentence.
Again with the one sentence thing, but maybe this is just your style. Just something to consider is all! Natures should have an apostrophe, and maybe on that last line you might want to add a little something else. Like, "Waiting for [nature's secrets] to be [revealed]". "Nature's secrets revealed" is really just a piece of a sentence, and in that form it doesn't go so well with the "Waiting patiently" bit. You could also shift the sentence so that "patiently" is the last word of the first sentence, and the last line is it's own sentence.
I had to look up betake. It seems like an old word with a weird way of using it, and I really don't think it fits here! The phrasing of the last two lines is sort of weird as well, with the tongue first and then the taste, when a person would normally say, "The taste of ___ on my tongue". Rhymes can make things tricky, but don't sacrifice how the rest of the stanza sounds just for the rhyme! If you can't make the second rhyme fit, you could always try playing around with the first one. For example, you could make that second line, "near the lake of pale blue", and then you'd have to rhyme with that "oo" sound instead, which could be easier.
You definitely need a rhyme here! If you're going to have a consistent rhyme scheme, then the only place you should drop it would maybe be for a concluding stanza which is different from all the rest. Again, you could adjust the second line to be "bushes of rosemary" to rhyme with a different last word. Or you could change it altogether, like saying the "bushes of rose" or "bushes in rows" and have the last line be "my mind's peace grows", which is pretty much the same! Just a small note, but its doesn't need an apostrophe, and mind's does.
Deers here is possessive, so it needs and apostrophe as well.
You've mentioned both deer and rosemary before -- do you mean to repeat them here? I feel like it's a little bit redundant at this moment, and might be more powerful if you either picked another image or if you repeated all the other things (i.e., the oak trees, the lake). Well you do sort of have the lake, but it's not as obvious. Just something to think about here. It's also a little bit choppy because of each line being an individual sentence, so maybe you could play around with punctuation a bit.
Overall, I thought your poem needed more of a point or a purpose. I'm totally guilty of not doing this in my own poetry, but it would be really good to have one. While your imagery is really nice, it doesn't really have a conclusion or even a beginning because it's only description. I liked the part about increasing the mind's peace, so maybe that would be your point -- in that case, you could drop little hints about peacefulness, and in the end make more of a statement about it. Or about living wild or loving animals or whatever it is you want.
Nice poem! I like the imagery and repetition. Feel free to take or ignore my suggestions as you like.
-Q