Breathe

by Sonder

Published March 13, 2015

12+ Violence

In Short Stories

The first time I broke the law, I swore never to do it again.

The second time I broke the law, I realized that it deserved to be shattered.

The third time I broke the law, I started burning things.


“Name?”

“Wyatt Ashton.”

“Age?”

“Nineteen.”

“Cause for imprisonment?”

“Doing what’s right.”

Agent Maria stops shuffling my file papers and glances up at me, icy blue eyes flashing a warning. Her dark hair is pulled back tightly from her forehead, allowing me to clearly view the small tattoo of the letter “o” neatly carved into her right temple. The marking tells me everything I need to know about her. Maria does not care about me. Maria is not sympathetic.

No matter how much the government insists otherwise, Maria is not my friend.

She slowly stretches her heavily padded shoulders, drawing her powerful arms over her head. Her bulletproof vest rustles loudly under the flourescent lights. I blink when I realize what she’s doing. The movement’s subtle, but I get the message. For a moment, I briefly glimpse the weaponry slung at her hip and across her chest. She’s threatening me.

Some friend. Ha.

Her voice is smooth and emotionless, and her frosty eyes are unblinking. I notice that one of her arms has a metallic sheen to it, and I wonder how many android upgrades she has partaken in.

“It does not say here that you were arrested for ‘doing what is right’,” she sniffs, tapping the papers on the table between us. I sigh and twist my sore wrists in the handcuffs behind my back. How long have I been in this chair?

I only woke up a few minutes ago, and unfortunately, my filter is not at its best.

Maria drones on. “In fact, you were arrested for counts that are often considered far from ‘right’. It says here that ‘Wyatt Ashton came before court to plead guilty to several counts of robbery and receipt of stolen goods, three counts of assault, and multiple counts of arson.’ Shall I go on?”

“No, ma’am,” I drawl sarcastically. I loll my head back casually and try to get a better look at the room around me.

There’s one reflective wall, probably a one-way window for observers. Cinder block walls everywhere else, and a camera tucked in the corner behind my head, recording my every move. Metal door, metal chair, metal handcuffs. No escape, no assistance. Bummer.

Maria’s voice increases in volume by the tiniest fraction.

“Please look at me, Mr. Ashton.”

I smirk as I slowly straighten, rolling my shoulders forward to try and shake out the stiffness.

“So demanding, mm?”

I pull my head up just in time to be punched in the jaw.

And at the metallic clang at the collision of bone on machinery, I immediately realize that my theory about her android arm is correct.

My neck snaps back as I hear, rather than feel, a tooth break loose. Knives shoot up my spine as my back slams into the metal chair bolted to the floor. The pain in my jaw is relatively slow to come on, but soon it hits my mouth and skull full-force. Clamping my mouth closed over the low cry threatening to come out, my tongue probes frantically in my mouth until I find the broken fragment of one of my canines. I wince as I touch the sharp remains stuck in my gums.

With a low groan, I lift my head to glance across the table to see Maria calmly shuffling her papers again. I nearly bite my tongue as the jagged pain lances through my cranium. Blood slowly trickles down my chin and stains my stark white prison uniform.

“You will respect your superiors,” Maria instructs coolly, not even bothering to look at me.

I grimace and fight to pull my head up through the pain, scolding myself for not believing she’d follow through with her threats. Maria is a Pure, for heaven’s sake. She isn’t going to take any disrespect from a CO2 like me.

“You don’t need another mark against you, Ashton. You’re balancing on the edge as it is. You’re this close to--”

I cough violently and spit out a tooth fragment. A spray of blood spatters the pristine steel table and some of Maria’s papers. Maria snaps a bemused look at me. Repressing a bitter smile at her disgust, I focus on what she had said. I struggle to speak through the pain.

“Close to what?”

Maria flashes a cold smile, although her eyes remain emotionless.

“Execution, of course.”

My heart plummets and cracks on the floor. I can’t breathe. I can’t think.

I’m just Wyatt, a teenager from Alabama. They couldn’t possibly kill me. I must have heard her wrong.

But I know I didn’t. To Maria, to the Pure government, I am nothing. I’m simply a CO2, not a citizen, no rights. I have little doubt in my mind about it. They’re going to kill me.

I’m going to die, and no one will remember me.

Maria drones on, her thin lips twitching in obvious enjoyment.

“Wyatt, please. You should have expected this much, surely. With the record you have, and with your inferior kind--”

“CO2s are not inferior.” I snap without thinking, then recoil, cursing myself.

Maria grins and spreads her hands in mock sympathy, one of her knuckles smeared with my blood.

“No one who breathes carbon dioxide instead of oxygen can be human. Your kind is a disease. You’re an invasive species. Weeds.

I flinch at the slur, something I’ve heard far too often on the streets. A Weed. A CO2 breather. A plant. Far from normal oxygen-breathers. Those who are pure.

Not human.

I’m breathing too hard, the adrenaline in my veins completely useless in my bound state. I can feel the familiar rage welling up in my chest.

“I committed those crimes to protect people,” I snarl, the metallic taste of blood still sharp in my mouth. Maria leans forward and folds her hands under her chin, an arrogant smile still on her lips.

My filter fails me, my voice growing louder as I remember all the things I have done to try and fix something, anything, and for what? For this government agent to smile at me like I’m a stupid dog in need of a kick.

“I used to think that the law was meant to protect people. I used to think that it didn’t matter that some kids had ‘o’s’ on their temples and I had a messy ‘W’ along my wrist. I used to believe that people had moral obligations, not self-centered ambitions. I used to think that all men had rights, and that I was counted among them.”

I pause to swallow, scowling at the ache in my jaw. Maria’s smile had faded slightly, like she hadn’t expected me to be so eloquent. To be educated. To be so passionate.

“Well, the first time my mom was fired by a Pure when they found out what kind of air she breathed, that was when I knew I’d never think of the law the same way again. When my friend abandoned me because I thrived on a different element, I knew it was the beginning of the end. I swore that I would fight for equality. I swore that I would bring justice!”

I’m almost screaming now, my heart racing in my chest. Maria is no longer smiling. Her icy blue eyes are locked onto my own as I work myself up further. How dare she be unresponsive? She represented all the oppression I had fought so hard against. These were my people. This was my life!

“I burned down a neighborhood to get your attention! Are you listening now, Pure? How long are you going to fight us? How many are you going to kill?”

Maria shoots a glance at the reflective wall behind me, a flash of something like fear sparking in her eyes. Her hand inches up to a gun holster on her chest.

My voice drops to an intense whisper. If everything else I’ve said is forgotten, I want her to hear this.

“You were right about us, Agent Maria. No matter how many CO2s you get rid of, more of us will take their place. No matter how many you kill, there will always be more to fight. We will not be silenced. We will not be denied.”

Maria draws her weapon out and points it at my forehead, frosty eyes narrowed in determination. I’m shaking, the pain and anger in my skull roaring into a wildfire.

“We are Weeds. Because we will keep growing back.

Maria stares at me over the barrel of the gun, no emotions evident in her features. I lift my chin and glare defiantly back, my chest heaving from my rant.

Silence stretches between us. A sliver of hope worms its way into my mind. Did I actually convince her?

When she finally speaks, her voice is softer than before.

“Wyatt Ashton. You are different than other Weeds I’ve met.”

Before I can respond, the radio in her ear crackles loudly.

“Agent, you are clear to take the shot.”

Any wisp of emotion I may have seen in Maria’s eyes is wiped away, and her robotic index finger tightens on the trigger. My heart deflates. She's just like the others, after all.

“Roger that.”

I take a deep breath of carbon dioxide.

And then I stop breathing altogether.

Comments & reviews · 7
User avatar
Firestarter
Review
Firestarter wrote a review Review · Mar 13, 2015

Hi Nightcrawler,


“Name?”

“Wyatt Ashton.”

“Age?”

“Nineteen.”

“Cause for imprisonment?”

“Doing what’s right.”


This was a poor way to start a story. I have no idea who is speaking, I have no context, and I don't care because of that. You have some invisible talking heads going at it.

Agent Maria stops shuffling my file papers and glances up at me, icy blue eyes flashing a warning.


This is cliche. Everyone in stories always have icy/piercing/startling blue eyes. Why? Why is it important we know Agent Maria's eye colour?

She slowly stretches her heavily padded shoulders, drawing her powerful arms over her head. Her bulletproof vest rustles loudly under the flourescent lights.


Avoid adverbs like "slowly" and "heavily" and "loudly". Improve your verbs rather than relying on adverbs to do all your talking for you.

Do bulletproof vests really rustle? This felt like a weird detail.

I blink when I realize what she’s doing.


Cut this. We don't need the minutiae of every body motion your character is doing.

She’s threatening me.


This is a bad sentence and you should cut it. One things writers do is overwrite. You are spelling it out for the reader, rather than letting the reader make their own guesses from the text. The preceding paragraph already quite obviously shows that Maria is making a threat. No need to outright state it.

Some friend. Ha.


Remove the "Ha", it's juvenile.

Her voice is smooth and emotionless, and her frosty eyes are unblinking. I notice that one of her arms has a metallic sheen to it, and I wonder how many android upgrades she has partaken in.


This is a really awkward paragraph.

First, your describing her voice when she is not talking. I don't understand why you are describing her voice paragraphs after she has spoken.

Second, why do we need a description of what her eyes are doing again?

"Partaken" is a really awkward and archaic word to use in this story, especially when contrasted to your use of "Ha". Reword that finale sentence, because it is reads really strangely.

“It does not say here that you were arrested for ‘doing what is right’,” she sniffs, tapping the papers on the table between us. I sigh and twist my sore wrists in the handcuffs behind my back. How long have I been in this chair?


You've just painted the picture of someone who's a bit of a bad-ass, with weapons and a metallic arm, who does not blink, and she speaks like this? It doesn't sound like real dialogue at all, and specially doesn't fit right with the characterisation of Agent Maria.

Get rid of "she sniffs." Just say "she said". When you use things like "she sniffs" you throw the reader out of the story completely. How can a person sniff a speech anyway? Sniff refers to smell.

I only woke up a few minutes ago, and unfortunately, my filter is not at its best.

This information is late in coming. The ordering of this story is very bizarre. You refer to a voice long after someone has spoken, and the narrator of this story is very slow to realise they have only just woken up.

Also, cut "unfortunately", the sentence does not need it. Another weak adverb. Your story is drowning in them.

“No, ma’am,” I drawl sarcastically. I loll my head back casually and try to get a better look at the room around me.


More adverbs. Your story is a long list of adverbs, and they are are ruining it. "She drawls" is another poor example of distracting dialogue tags, too.

Okay, I'm going to pull out of nick-picking now, or I will sound like a broken record.

A list of things you need to correct:

-Cut your adverbs. Use stronger verbs and more active sentences.
- Keep your dialogue tags simple, Stick to "she said".
- Your world building is poor. The story is too short and I have no idea why this person is being killed, and why it even matters. The only way your story makes any sense to the reader is when you dump some exposition in the middle to explain the CO2 breather stuff. Otherwise, it has no emotional impact.
- The dialogue is bad. It's a bit silly, and Agent Maria sounds weak. You give Wyatt the ability to just say whatever she wants, and Agent Maria just let's her talk for some reason. Why wouldn't she just kill Wyatt when she's mouthing off? Just so Wyatt can sound cool? It doesn't make sense. I think you need to work on your dialogue extensively.
- The conflict is dull. Wyatt is killed. Okay. Why should I care? I don't know Wyatt. I wasn't given a chance to see whether her death mattered. Who are the Weeds? Why does the government hate them? Why is this happening? None of the answers for this are in the story, and therefore I didn't enjoy your story.

Apologies, this is a particularly harsh review. But this needs some serious work because it has some really serious shortcomings. This is a rough first draft and it needs a lot of rewriting. If it makes you feel better, everyone's first drafts are usually this bad. You just need to look at this story now and think about some of the things I've said and try and rewrite this idea so it has some emotional impact.
Jack

Sonder replied · Mar 13, 2015

Aye aye Captain. Thanks for the review.

Story behind this is, I wrote it in about, oh, an hour? I personally felt that it was very undeveloped and don't particularly like it, but I was entering it for a competition with a time limit. I apologize for cliches and general stupidity on my part.

I agree, that review was pretty harsh. It felt quite condescending, but I can handle it. I hope to improve as a writer, so thanks for the points.

~Night

I apologise if it sounded condescending, that was not my intention.

It did read as a rough first draft, and is definitely underdeveloped. The idea is not bad, though, per se, and I'm sure a second draft would be much better, so let me know if you make any edits, as I'd be happy to take another look.

Good luck with future writing!

Sonder replied · Mar 13, 2015

Thanks for understanding. :)

User avatar
TheElderOne
Review
TheElderOne wrote a review Review · Mar 13, 2015

Another fantastic, thought-evoking piece.

You keep the reader guessing about who the narrator is, and then when the big reveal comes, the narrator is easily sympathized with. The buildup is good, and the ending fits in with the story and shows just how ruthless the O's are.

Now my duty to find one error to help you with. Somewhere... somewhere. Erm, found one: it's 'coolly' instead of 'cooly', but I have a feeling you missed the second 'l' by accident. Aaaand that's about I can comment on.

Anyway, keep writing!

Sonder replied · Mar 13, 2015

Thanks yet again, Elder! And thanks for catching the typo. :)

theobliviousoracle commented Comment · Mar 13, 2015

Short. To the point. Awesome.
You could have elaborated a few things more but short stories are better short.
So, conclusion: G R E A T

Sonder replied · Mar 13, 2015

Thank you!

User avatar
Que
Review
Que wrote a review Review · Mar 13, 2015

Hi there! I really loved this short story and only saw a few errors.

In terms of plot, I would like to know more about the CO2s because it said they were an invasive species. Is that just to continue comparing them to weeds or are they actually a new species? Are they humans that have (epically) adapted? It's a very interesting concept.

There were just a few little grammar things I found. "I flinch at the slur, something I’ve heard far too often..." I wasn't sure what you meant by slur, and thought that calling it a slang term would work better, but you probably had a good reason for using slur.

"I nearly bite my tongue as the jagged pain lances through my cranium." Here, you had just used jagged 2 sentences back so I advise changing it. Maybe use spiked or sharp or crushing (you can just choose your own word).

Ahh I'm being really picky but I just wanted to say great job on this piece, I really enjoyed it!

-Falc-

Sonder replied · Mar 13, 2015

Thanks so much! The basics are that I wanted to show that what you breathe is as trivial as your skin color; it doesn't matter. In this futuristic world, I had the idea that at some point, we genetically engineered some people to breathe CO2 because we had killed off many forests and needed more oxygen in the atmosphere. Therefore, the Weeds are the minority and the Pures feel superior over them.

I'd like to make this a novel sometime. What do you think?

Que replied · Mar 13, 2015

I think that would be great! Unfortunately, I also feel like that's would actually happen in real life :/ .
If you have more ideas to expand with, I think you should. :)

Sonder replied · Mar 13, 2015

Thanks! I'd like to. :)

User avatar
Gravity
Review
Gravity wrote a review Review · Mar 13, 2015

Heya! Gravity here to do a short review (mainly because this piece was so awesome, there's not much to correct)

Okay so your spelling and grammar were great. I loved your plot structure, your description, your imagery and your character development. You took care of all the major elements of a story beautifully, and I applaud you for that.

The only thing I didn't particularly like was how slow you were to inform the reader of what was going on. I'm not sure if this short is one in a series of many but at first I was very confused about the setting. Meaning the time period and what kind of society it was. So I think you could maybe bring the major conflict into the picture a little sooner? Then the reader won't be so confused.

Also, you probably get this a lot, but have you thought of turning this into a novel? It's a very interesting concept. Anyhow, if you decide to elaborate on this plot, please let me know. I'd be very interested to read and review it.

XOXO,
Gravity

Sonder replied · Mar 13, 2015

Hey Gravity! Thanks for the review. :)

Well, I've had this idea for a while. I had a dream about it and it's been the matter of executing it properly that's been holding me back. I'd love to make it a novel, and I have all the main ideas sorted out here. The basics are that I wanted to show that what you breathe is as trivial as your skin color; it doesn't matter. In this futuristic world, I had the idea that at some point, we genetically engineered some people to breathe CO2 because we had killed off many forests and needed more oxygen in the atmosphere. Therefore, the Weeds are the minority and the Pures feel superior over them.

It's encouraging to me that people like this and are curious. I'll definitely think about expanding it. :)

User avatar
CuriosityCat
Comment
CuriosityCat commented Comment · Mar 13, 2015

OHMIGOSH. That was without question the most beautiful thing I have ever read. YOU ARE A FREAKING GENIUS!!!
One question, though: How is breathing CO2 a bad thing? I would have thought that converting CO2 to oxygen would be really useful. Has humanity had a turning point? Is there now an overload of oxygen in the atmosphere? I'd like to know more about that.
Anyway, I'm gonna not mark this as a review, because this story is so perfect I can't really critique it. <3 <3 <3
~Cat

Sonder replied · Mar 13, 2015

Thanks! I made it a bad thing because that's what's so ridiculous about humanity judging by skin color. It has nothing to do with the person. I also had the idea that at some point, we genetically engineered some people to breathe CO2 because we had killed off many forests and needed more oxygen in the atmosphere. Therefore, the Weeds are the minority and the Pures feel superior over them. :)

Thanks again!

Ah, thank you. That makes more sense. :P

Random avatar
Anmol Comment
Anmol commented Comment · Mar 13, 2015

Is it weird to ship it?

Sonder replied · Mar 13, 2015

XD You do you, I suppose.



huh. didn't realize santa was a batman fan-
— Mageheart