Author's
Note: I know I've said this about the last two chapters, but this is my
favorite chapter yet. I loved getting to write this personal moment
between Cass and Aspen, and I loved how it was building the way for
future Caspen interactions. There's also a little something else that
happens in this chapter that I'm particularly proud of, but I won't say
what it is to avoid spoiling it for you guys. <3
As
a little aside, I completely forgot to include Cass taking off her
backpack and putting it behind her on the bed in the previous chapter.
Since it would be awkward to suddenly throw that in now, let's all just
pretend that she did that when she first sat down.
Words: 1,277
Last Lines: Then she was gone from the room, her footsteps echoing out in the
hallway. Cass knew that the need for the clothes wasn't that desperate -
Lira just wanted an escape from the awkwardness of seeing a stranger
cry.
And Cass, who didn't want a stranger to see her cry, was perfectly fine with being left with Aspen.
It was only when Lira's footsteps faded that Aspen started talking to her again, whispering in quiet, hushed tones that everything was going to be alright. Cass didn't argue. She just let Aspen holding her gently, rubbing her hands up and down her back much in the way that her mom had done to comfort her when she was little. It took several more minutes, but the sobs that shook her body were reduced to sniffles and stray teardrops rolling down her flushed cheeks.
That was when Aspen let go.
Cass wanted to continue to cling to her, but she let Aspen pull back from the embrace. "Where do you keep your tissues?" Aspen gently asked, leaning over towards Cass' backpack. Her hand hovered over the front pouch; it was a lucky guess.
Cass hiccuped and bit back another wave of tears. "I never told you I had them."
Aspen gave her a small smile.
"You're always prepared," she said, "and that seems like the type of thing you'd be smart enough to pack."
She tried her best to return the smile, but it faltered as soon as her gaze landed on the silver locket hanging about her best friend's chest - a painful reminder of the differences between how this world treated Aspen and her. Her lips quivered. Aspen's magic was a gift. Hers was a curse. It was the same with their lockets. And then she thought of the times they had spent together in school. Everyone loved Aspen. They loved her confidence, her beauty, her personality - everything about Aspen Lovelace was incredible, and everyone knew that.
But Aspen was the only one who had bothered to pay attention to Cass in a long time. She didn't have a plethora of lunch tables to sit at before Aspen; she'd just pick whichever one had a few open seats on the end. She had never been invited to parties before Aspen, and part of her had always suspected that the only reason she had been invited now was because Aspen had gone right to the party-throwers and asked that Cass be invited as well. Clubs never vied for her membership, and she didn't have half as many followers as Aspen did on her social media.
Aspen was everything she couldn't be.
Just for a moment, Cass found herself wishing more than ever that she could be like her.
There was a sudden flash of warmth - a familiar, beautiful warmth that made her heart give an excited flutter when the feeling registered. Aspen, who had finished digging through the front pouch of the backpack and pulled out the small pack of tissues, leapt back in surprise. The tissue pack went tumbling from her hands, but she didn't even make a move to catch it before it silently hit the wooden floor. She was staring at the space between the two of them with wide, wide eyes.
"Look," she whispered.
Cass did as requested.
What appeared to be moving shadows had burst out from the sheets all around Cass, forming a perfect little circle. None of them went too high, but the sight of them was enough to send Cass into a frenzied panic. This had to be the magic that Lira had been referring to. She stared at the tendrils eagerly licking the air around of them. The darkness suddenly shot up. Cass cried out. Aspen did, too, and both of them stumbled back from the wild magic.
But Cass couldn't escape from the circle - when she tried backing up, she only ended up bumping into the wall of darkness that had shot up behind her.
Aspen hesitantly raised her hand. Cass opened her mouth to protest what she knew Aspen was planning on doing - it was too wild, too cursed, too likely to hurt her - but Aspen was already reaching out towards the darkness. Cass hoped with all of her might that it wouldn't harm her best friend, even though she knew thinking so was pointless. She closed her eyes. She didn't want to see what would happen.
Then a giggle left Aspen's lips.
"You're tickling me, Cassie," she said as another giggle broke free.
Cass hesitantly opened her eyes.
The darkness around where Aspen had reached her hand out had parted away. There was enough space for her hand to be untouched, but little strands had branched off and were currently brushing against the bare skin of Aspen's hand. Cass took a shaky breath. The darkness began to recede into the sheets behind her. When she noticed the change, she took another. The darkness became smaller on her right and left. She took a third deep breath. Now the darkness before her was becoming less chaotic, sinking like its brethren back into the safety of the sheets.
Aspen looked up at her as the darkness - and the warmth - faded.
"I love your magic," she said, her voice filled with awe. The tissues lay forgotten on the floor.
Cass shook her head. "You can't. It's-It's not good." A fresh batch of tears began to roll down her cheeks, accompanied by the darkness rearing its ugly head once more. The sight of the darkness was all that she needed to be sent into another downwards spiral. "It's going to make me turn out just like that king and-and then you're going to be even more scared of me and leave me all-all alone and I don't want to be alone again, Aspen!"
Aspen furrowed her brow. "What are you talking about?"
She sniffled.
"You-you're scared of me," she said. The darkness grew, as if it was in agreement with what Cass was saying. "You got scared when I knew Aldonius, and when I said that I recognized Rey."
The silence that followed her accusation was heavy and uncomfortable. Aspen just stared at her and the darkness, her expression impossible to read no matter how hard Cass tried. Cass let out a sob and buried her face into her hands; she should have never mentioned it. Now that she had, Aspen would be unable to skirt around how her true feelings towards the changes that Cass had undergone since they got together that morning.
She heard Aspen take a deep breath.
"I'm not going to lie," she finally said. "I'm definitely a little freaked out right now."
Cass sobbed even harder.
"And I might have been a tiny bit scared when I heard what you said earlier," she continued, her voice remaining at the same quiet level. "But I'm not scared of you, Cassie, and I'm never going to leave you."
She lowered her hands and looked up at Aspen.
Her best friend had slipped off of the bag and was in the middle of grabbing onto the tissues. Straightening, she held out the small pack out to Cass. "You're my best friend, Cassandra Hughes. If being your best friend means dealing déjà vu, magical lockets and supposedly cursed magic, then I'll just learn to get over my fear." She grinned at her. And even though it didn't fully reach Aspen's eyes, Cass found relief washing over her in waves. The darkness receded back into the bed. Just hearing those words was enough to quell her fears.
Cass took her tissues out of Aspen's hands.
"And I meant what I said earlier," Aspen added. She hopped back onto the bed and looked her in the eyes. "Your magic really is beautiful. I know Lira says that it's dangerous, but it doesn't feel that way. It felts warm and safe, like a nice big blanket being wrapped around me on a cold winter night. It felt like you."
End of chapter
Continue to next chapter The Three Lockets [Chapter 5.4]Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Hello again!!



I liked that we got to see Cass's magic and that it wasn't as bad as she feared it would be. Now I'm curious about what your favorite part was because there were a lot of sweet moments in this segment
I liked how you drew the comparisons about each girl's type of magic to who they are in real life. Not that Cass is a dark person, but almost like she has this inner darkness or sadness because she's lonely and struggled to make friends whereas Aspen has this inner lightness or joy because every seems to gravitate to her and she's never had much struggle in her life.
As I was reading this segment though, I was thinking that I hope Cass develops some confidence as the story progresses and that she really embraces this darkness magic and becomes this b.a. chick with her dark magic who takes names and shows no mercy :p (seems a little out of character for her but you never know...)
I also love how supportive Aspen was in this scene and how well she validates Cass without pitying her or belittling her. I'm glad their little mini fight is over because they don't need to fight.
Overall, I didn't really have any qualms with this segment. It was a sweet little scene and I'm very curious to see how this magic develops and exactly how this contrast with light and dark magic will evolve and what exactly the girls will need to do now that they're and they have this magic. Hopefully in the next chapter we'll get more info about why the girls are here, what they need to do, and why. I need some fresh conflict and stakes
Let me know if you have any questions or if you'd like feedback about something I didn't mention! Until next time
Thank you so much for your review!
Looking back, I'm also really curious because I honestly have no idea what I meant in the author's note. Guess that's what happens when you write something half-asleep??
Accidental symbolism at its finest. xD
That last part might be a bit of a stretch, but you'll definitely see Cass develop into someone who's more comfortable with herself!
Thanks again for your review!
You're so welcome!
!!!
Like, okay. I know I haven't reviewed the last installment yet
because I want me those Green Room reviewsbut like??? it was already good enough when Aspen was like, "Uh, what's the big deal about dark magic? It's just another kind of magic like the rest of us have got," but then in this! chapter! When she's like "Heh heh, your magic is tickling me!" and then here when she's like, "!!! I love it???" It just makes me so happy, especially in light of her relationship with Cassie and how worried Cassie has been because she's been feeling like even Aspen doesn't understand her now.And Aspen holding Cass while she cried? My ship is sailing although admittedly I had no doubt it would be but still.
And I think your heartfelt conversation in this chapter was handled really well? Like it could've gone on a lot longer, but you kept it to the essentials: Cass thinks Aspen's afraid of her and is scared of being alone again; Aspen is freaked out right now but loves Cassie too much to leave when things get a little scary.
Also???????
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
And that's all I have to say about that.
I really appreciate the way you've set up the dark magic as something people in Rey are scared of because of associations with Kartiel and the Dark Mage but something not inherently bad. It's very realistic for something to take on the feeling of being evil because of its use by bad people, and I like the fact that you acknowledge--at least so far--that it's not actually bad itself; it can just be used badly.
It's a little funny that Cass is so immediately sure that her magic is a curse. Like, she doesn't really know anything about it. But she's very insecure, and, let's face it, stories in the real world do tend to have darkness or dark magic as this inherently evil thing. Plus I think it's interesting that when Aspen is like "pffft no it's not a curse," Cass thinks about the fact that Lira's clearly afraid of it and knows more about magic than either of them - it's a good point. However, I do feel like this is a point where Cass could start to get on readers' nerves for being so downcast and negative. Honestly I think I preferred her crying and backing away from her power in fear to the negative thoughts and words. I don't know if it's just because it was more open and could be addressed or if it's because it made me feel more sympathy for her or what. And obviously you could overcorrect and go too far with having her cry all the time
side-eyes my own charactersbut I think such open displays of sadness and panic worked really well in this chapter.Thank you so much for your review! <3 I apologize for taking so long to reply to it.
Same here! A lot of Cass's social problems come from things that I've felt in the past (and then a little bit more than that) so it's been fun writing her feeling that way, but I just really wanted her to understand that Aspen is there for her.
I still can't go over how I thought I was going to make this book subtly gay back at the very beginning, and then promptly threw that plan out the window once I started writing the novel.
I mean, hey, I cry all the time, so it's gotta be realistic for someone. xD But I really do love having characters be honest with their emotions! (And I'm not just talking about in my own stories, because I absolutely adore how emotionally raw your book is.)
oh my gOD WHAT A BOOD
Hiya, Saen! Just dropping in for another quick review.
Small Comments
Aww, this was cute. I like that Cass's uber-prepared backpack keeps resurfacing in the story; it's a funny little motif.
No need for this. Again, don't explain everything. The reader can figure out what the locket signifies.
I don't get why she's suddenly so sure about this. She's only got Lira's word to go on. She's not used her magic yet, and nor has she seen anybody else use darkness magic, so I'd expect her to be more uneasy than absolutely 100% certain that hers is terrible and Aspen's is perfect.
Has there actually been a point in the narrative where people treated Aspen's locket as a blessing? There's been negative reactions to Cass's, but people mostly seem to ignore or not register Aspen's. So I didn't really get what she was saying here.
Overall Thoughts
This was a touching chapter. I can see why you were so keen to write it, because it's lovely to get a slower and more heartfelt moment between Cass and Aspen amid all of the revelations of the previous chapters. My favourite bit had to be when Cass's magic burst out and Aspen said it was tickling her - I love how trusting and unafraid Aspen is. It's a bit concerning that Cass doesn't seem able to control her magic though, because she obviously wasn't intending to create that ring of shadows. That could get her into trouble at some point.
Perhaps my biggest problem with the chapter - and I hate to say this - is that Cass is starting to grate on me. I feel like she's always moping, and not necessarily for a legitimate reason. She presumes so much knowledge about darkness magic being terrible, and just assumes she's going to become as corrupted as Kartiel (who she knows absolutely nothing about), and she assumes that her locket is evil and Aspen's is a blessing, and assumes that Aspen is better than her in every possible way, and that Aspen is afraid of her and going to abandon her. And like. I get it. She's an anxious person. I get that. But it just gets very tiresome after a while to see her worrying about and presuming things that make no sense for her to presume. If she was more self-aware about how irrational some of her worries were, maybe she'd be more sympathetic, but it's starting to feel like Cass is too passive for a protagonist - she's not really made any weighty decisions yet, just been swept along with the plot. I want to like her, and I know I could like her with a few minor changes, but you lay it on a bit too thick with the whole comparing-herself-to-Aspen-woe-is-me passages. It comes across like you're trying to drag sympathy out of me.
Still, the ending of this chapter has given me hope, because it feels like you've wrapped up some of Cass's insecurities with a view to moving past them. I wonder how things are going to progress from here. If Aspen is adamant that Cass's magic is beautiful and safe, and Lira is adamant that it's dangerous, I can't help feeling that they're going to come to blows at some point. Something to figure out, I suppose, is where Cass fits in in this debate. Is she going to believe Aspen and find pride in her magic? Is she going to suppress it to appease Lira, and perhaps because she doesn't want to forfeit Lira's guidance in this mysterious world? Or is she going to take a different perspective? I think that's what we need to know, because it's definitely time for Cass to stop reacting and start acting.
I do like that I can't predict where the story is headed, I must admit. There's nothing worse than when you can tell how everything is going to unfold. I think you just need to nail Cass's character, then I'll feel a bit more stable as a reader. I really like that the shy, anxious girl is taking centre stage in this story, with her outgoing and bubbly friend as a sidekick - it subverts the norms. But Cass still needs to be a decisive character in some form. The story has to come from her.
Sorry if this was a really harsh review. I always seem to be more brutal than I mean to be in these critiques, especially considering that I love the story. Maybe that's why I'm so harsh - because I know the novel has the potential to be really special. But bear in mind that I super enjoyed seeing Cass's magic for the first time and I liked how gentle Aspen was with Cass at the beginning of the chapter. I can't wait to see these kids fall for each other properly. ^.^
Keep writing!
~Pan
I apologize for taking so long to reply to this, but thank you so, so much for your review!
I didn't think of that! Cass tends to rely a lot on what other people tell her, but I could have a scene in the next draft that shows someone with darkness magic doing something bad to help add onto that fear, or show that Cass tends to follow what other people say.
There hasn't been a specific moment yet, so I probably should make that section more clear in the next draft! The big thing I wanted Cass to reference is what you were saying about Aspen's locket - no one's had a negative reaction to her locket, so Cass thinks of it as it being a "blessing". Which is something I really should focus more on, considering that Cass has been "invisible" for her entire life and, for the first time, actually wants to be like that instead.
I'm crossing my fingers that I can resolve that issue you mentioned earlier in the next draft by having this moment happen sooner, since it's definitely been frustrating having to wait for Cass to have that important conversation with Aspen. (It's probably gone on as long as it has because my pacing's been shot when I'm trying to figure out how to write good chunks for lms.)
And I do promise that Cass is going to get a lot of character development further on! It'll just take some time, because Plot.
I also promise that you'll be seeing that soon! I just need to have a single scene to throw some more important info at her, and then Cass will be making one of her first big decisions.
You and me both!
Thanks again! Your review was super helpful.