Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Hi JCK,
sorry I didn't get to this sooner.
the repetition of this poem does have the effect you want it to have. It should have made a lasting impact on your last line because of the sudden switch of words and connotation, but it didn't. The lines in themselves are too weak and sap out all the potential impact from the repetition. You have a couple others that are stronger then this from what I've skimmed.
Suggestion to make the impact you needed:
Note that there's no sense of flow whatsoever. It's choppy and the idea ends at the period as does the flow, there's no sense of continuous flowing of words. The content doesn't have to be related but you have to transition it. It's like filling a glass with water from the tap, leave the tap open until it's full - don't turn it off every couple of increments of the glass. What's the point in doing so? You have to hook your reader and not stop-start, because that's the easiest way to lose their attention. So make some transitions if you want to use this kind of unsubtle repetition.
Another suggestion would be to use repetition differently. Repeating the same start of a sentence 10x and then have a different start for the 12th is amateur and of course it has poetic qualities due to the sounds - that's because it's constantly the same sound. Expand your ideas and use the repetition with sounds or specific words or sentence structure, as a reader I don't enjoy having "I laughed" spat in my ear over and over.
To maintain a rambling sort of tone with this specific poem - I suggest the former. But do make those transitions, this is unbearably dull to read otherwise.
Best of luck,
Kamas
First off, I like the word incendium. But what does it mean? It would've been nice if it was actually in the poem so we could get a gyst of its definition. But anyway, the poem was pretty good. I'm not a fan of repetitive stuff like this, but you get credit for the fact that I wasn't too bothered by that in this case. All in all, a solid poem.
Keep writing,
StoryWeaver
Sounds interesting....but what does Incendium mean? I know it is made up, but could you explain the meaning in a PM for me? The poem is very layered and realistic. It is a bit weird that a realistic poem has a made-up name for it's title. Think about that. It is good, but does it fit in with the theme of the poem? I can sense abandonment. It is almost like this is about The Holocaust. It probably isn't, but I can just imagine it. This is harsh and brutal yet so honest and beautiful. Either that or the end of the world. Loved the content- just needs a more appropriate title. Even if it is made-up, it still needs to relate to the context. Overall, fab-u-lous!