Cian was in two neatly placed pieces. Around him, the trees danced frantically, the clouds kept moving, and the grass swung side to side. The world had failed to notice this loss of a life, this immense tragedy that had befallen the nameless club.
Alice stayed still. She was still on her knees, with her back hunched, but now she stared at the pieces of the boy- the friend- she once called Cian. Her heart was beating in time with the trees and the grass, as if the island had it’s own pulse and her body was learning to mimic it.
The smell of the freshly dead beast was the first to hit her. She pushed herself off the ground with the heels of her hands. She became lightheaded the second she stood upright. The blood rushing to her head kept her heart beating fast, kept her breathing heavy, kept the adrenaline in her veins, but to her this was good, She’d need to confidence.
The bark had peeled from the branches on impact. The beast was slowly sliding down pale-gold spears, leaving black trails in it’s wake. Alice took it upon herself to investigate the corpse. Anything to keep her mind of her massacred friend, and the dark feeling in the back of her mind, on the tip of her tongue, that was saying it was her fault.
She soon became frustrated with her investigation. The beast was heavy and she couldn't summon the strength to slide it back up the branches. After much effort, she found that she couldn't pull the branches out of the ground either.
She collapsed, frustrated and confused. How did the branches get there? she asked herself silently.. She was pondering all the possibilities- how Cian could have thrown the branches, how they could have fallen from a tree at the right time- when she felt a tickling up her back. Certain that it was a bug, she smacked at her lower back until she was sure that it was dead. But then she felt it recoil.
She leaped to her feet immediately. She scanned over the area where she was sitting, hoping to find a snake or something rational, but saw nothing. Just the field of green where she had been sitting. The tide had come up farther since she had last bothered to check on it, and she was ankle deep in sea water.
She pranced out of the water and cursed softly under her breath. The tide kept coming and going, coming and going. Alice was hypnotized by the waves, and daydreamed until the water hit her shoes again. “Ohh fuck off!” she shouted at the water, kicking up a storm with her feet.
The ground underneath her feet rippled. Grass began to shoot up. It formed a wall, and slowly rippled, carrying away the oncoming tide.
****
Cian was alone. He couldn't feel half his body. There was a metallic taste in his mouth, and his ears were ringing non-stop. He opened his eyes, but could see nothing but complete darkness, with two hovering orbs of green light floating overhead.
He couldn't remember where he was, or what he was supposed to be doing.
After a time, he could hear a voice to his left. He turned his head to see who it was, and was suddenly reminded that he was in almost complete darkness. The voice was switching between an assertive and a breathless voice. Cian hated that. He hated people who couldn't keep a handle on themselves.
***
Cian looked so peaceful. His eyes were shut like curtains, and were free from the clenching and releasing that dreaming brings. His lips were a pale pink, and slightly parted. A whispering position. “What’s your secret, Cian?” Alice choked out through harsh breaths. She was sitting with her legs crossed, and cradling his head in her arms. “C’mon. You can tell me. Best friends don’t keep secrets. That’s right. You’re my best friend, Cian. We’re best friends, so you can’t be mad at me, okay?” Little droplets were hitting his face. Alice checked to see if it was raining before she realised she was crying.
She had put him back together rather crudely. Alice had to keep his back between her knees to keep him from falling apart again. The jagged edges of his body said that he had been torn, not sliced. One part of his body was much larger than the other, with one only consisting of a leg and a chunk of his lower body.
“Do you want to hear my secret, Cian.” she choked on her own words. “It’s my fault you died.” she began to cry stronger, but calmed herself so she could add “But we’re best friends, so you you can’t be mad, okay? You remember that promise, right?”
****
Cian had made no such promise. He was still floating in the dark space. Alice’s voice had become clearer over time. He heard her tears, and her blubbering and her promises. but he couldn't find it in him to care. He had searched deep into his roots- into the pit of his stomach but her emotional distress failed to move him. He didn't really feel anything anymore.
“Hello.” a high voice said. The sound seemed to come from nowhere, and everywhere. Cian opened his eyes to see another boy floating over him. “Hello.” he said again.
“Hullo.” Cian responded. He hadn't realised he could talk.
“Do you know where you are?” the boy’s eyes were locked on to his.
“No. I don’t.” the boy said nothing. “Do you know where I am?” Cian said after a while.
“No. I’m not sure where your place is. But it’s close to mine, so I was sent to welcome you.”
“Welcome me to where?”
“You can call it whatever you wish. Heaven, Hell, Jahannam, whatever. Just know that it is a place we go after death.”
Cian sat up and crossed his legs. The boy mimicked his movements, so they were sitting across from each other. “Is God here?” Cian asked. The boy laughed.
“No. There are many Gods, and yes, there is a God that reigns over this world, but God is not here. His job is much different than what most people think he does. I’m sorry, but I can’t tell you anything more about God.” the boy looked to his feet.
“Says who?” Cian looked the boy in the eyes. He was dead, and he knew it. He wanted some answers. He wanted to feel a fire in his stomach, but couldn't.
“God. Well the god of this place. The God of this world, anyway. You’re the God of this place.” the boy gestured around the black space, then pointed up. “See that orb of light up there? That’s my place. I am God there. I control what happens. There is a small, neutral space between my place and yours. Do you understand?”
“Yes. Kind of. So I can do anything I want here?”
“Yes, in theory. But you have to leave soon, so I wouldn't start anything.”
“Why do I have to leave?”
“I’m not allowed say. Living beings aren't allowed know. You’re still alive, Cian. I can’t tell you why, but you no longer breath, and your heart does not beat anymore, but you mind is on the material plane, so you cannot know why. There was an” he paused for a moment “Incident last time. Something to do with a cult. Human emotions can’t handle this kind of stuff.” Cian flinched.
“About that.” he began “Why don’t I feel anything in here? I mean, I want to be sad and angry that I’m dead. I want to be shocked and surprised at all this new information, but I can’t. It’s like someone switched me off with the light-switch. Will it always be like this?”
“No.” the boy responded with a bank face. “Emotions do not exist here, but they can. This is your place. You are a God here. This place is devoid of everything. It is not dark, there is just no light. There is nothing here. Including you. At the moment you are nothing. A force. A concept. It’s your job to create this world from scratch, and do with it as you please. This is how worlds are created, Cian.”
“But I have to go soon?”
“Yes. I have to go, too. I’m the only reason you're still here. Once I leave, you’ll go back to your body. It’ll hurt- be prepared.
“I will.” they both stood up. “What’s your name?” Cian asked.
“They call me Lucy.” the boy said.
“I thought you were a boy?” Cian said, still not able to experience shock.
“I am neither. I am a force, like you.” Lucy disappeared after that. In his place, a little orb of light appeared. It grew and grew until it sucked Cian in whole. He was moving fast through a tunnel, with a small light at the end. It grew and grew until he was spat out into the world. The first thing he saw was the face of a friend named Alice.
***
Hannah had been pulling Poppy along for ten minutes. She was happy that they were on grass, as most of Poppy’s body was being dragged across the ground. Stray sticks and stones were still cutting her, but at least they weren't on a gravel road.
Hannah’s arms were wrapped around one of Poppy’s legs in an awkward way the resembled a pretzel. She had to be careful not to touch her with her hands.
She was still aware of the person. He was following them so softly, so patiently, He would wait until they were away, or Hannah had to stop to move something. He’d then jump from branch to branch anytime she made a noise. If Hannah sighed, there’d be a rustle. If a bird sang, a rustle. But she was always aware.
On the mainland, Hannah’s parents had suffered a massive break in. The things that go bump in the night went bump in the living room, and her mother had gone to check. They were nice enough to call an ambulance, after they were miles away, of course. Unfortunately she could not be saved. ‘There’s nothing we can do.’ the ambulance man had said. From then on, her and her father had to adapt to a panicked life. Nights of worry had made them light sleepers. Fear had taught them to analyze every creak the old house made and decide if it was footsteps or not; Fear had taught her to take every sound that flew by her ear, no matter how small, and risk assess, find patterns. Two creeks in the hall could be foot steps. Ten minutes of branches shaking meant company.
Hannah was getting pissed. She’d passed fear by a long time ago- when the trees that they moved passed started repeating. But she trudged on. Not for her own sake, but for Poppy’s. Every thought that came into Hannah’s mind, every chance of escape, every perfect hiding place was always lost in the haze of sympathy in her mind. She’s just a girl! she thought. She’s been passed out the entire time. I’d have a hope of getting back, but not her. She doesn't know the turns we took. Every step was for Poppy.
But the steps were getting slower. Hannah knew it, the pursuer knew it. So she did the only sensible thing she could think of. She stopped, and took a big yawn. She heard a rustle, a small distance away. Another yawn, another rustle, this time closer. Their chaser had become cocky, and Hannah planned to use that to any advantage she could think of. This time, she looked into the sky, half closed her eyes, and fake-coughed. Branches shook overhead.
Not losing a moment, Hannah ran to the trunk of the tree. She slapped her hands on the sides of it and watched.
After a moment, the bark under her fingers changed color. It became darker and softer. The color spread through the trunk within moments. The trunk collapsed loudly. The only sound was branches shaking overhead, then the branches of the next tree shaking, then a loud thud on the other side of it.
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Woah! OMG, this just got even better than it was before. Mind=blown! Here's your chapter three review.


*Levitates off of the ground with laptop.* *sips magic coffee*
You know the drill. I'm gonna talk about all the good stuff first, and then offer some constructive criticism. I guess you've figured it out by now, but if not, let me tell you that I think this novel is amazing, so the two portions of this review are gonna be a little bit disproportional.
Now then, the good stuff!
*Unicorn re-enters* *shouts* "CHAPTER THREE REVIEW! COMMENCE!"
So, in chapter one, you laid out the basics for all of your characters, symbols, and settings. In chapter two, you took all of those things and expanded on them, purging them of every last bit of their mundanity and innocence and replacing that with ultra-violent action and awesomery. In this chapter, you've regressed a bit from the shocking events and excitable narrative style and gone back to developing your characters and symbols a little bit more. One of the symbols I don't think I've touched on just yet is that of the tides. It seems like whenever shit is about to go down, the tides are "licking" someone's feet...I mean that in the most unsuggestive way possible. You haven't really gone back to the symbol of the statue head thing in the lake, but the whole scene with Cian and Lucy does touch back upon this whole theme about religion and what exactly it means to be a "God." As a matter of fact, that brings me to my next point.
The scenes between Cian and Lucy and alternatively the scene between he and Alice at kind of the same time are straight-up masterpieces. I absolutely love how you've created this really cool alternative dimension to which death is the doorway. Like I have said in my previous reviews, I thought that Cian dying was nothing short of hilarious. Bringing him back made it so that you could play with that whole afterlife dynamic, but you managed to do it in such a way that you didn't diminish the sheer hilarity and shock value of his death in chapter two. I just love the way you've further developed his character here too. In chapters one and two, he just seemed like that random innocent and really nice kid. That caricature of him was actually part of what made his departure from worldly being that much more entertaining. From this chapter, the audience can infer that there's much more to him than that. Not only does he exhibit more genuine concern for his own well-being here, but he also grapples with this whole idea of emotions and what exactly it means to be alive. It seems like you've used the character of Cian to explore an entire dichotomy of theories about exactly that. Some questions that you've placed in the minds of your audience are ones like "Is life really life without feelings and friends?", "Do emotions make us alive?, "If not, what does?, and so many others that are just far too many to list at the moment. It's always great when a writer can offer commentary about something greater with their writing and you've done that very well here.
The next thing I'm going to praise you for is the development of Alice's character. She goes from being nervously compliant and hoping that the other kids will like here in chapter one to...watching a dude die and confronting the horrors of death in chapter two. Here, she's coping with the sense of guilt and trying to sort out her own emotions about what's just happened. I saw her failure to get an adequate read on the creature as a metaphor for her failure to come to grips with her own feelings and to figure out what she really wants out of herself and her friends. Due to Cian's (lol), she's been forced to confront those very lofty questions quite early in the story. This is great because it sets up a very definite framework Alice and her character arc as it unfolds in the rest of the novel. Although there are a few main characters here, I see her as the novel's protagonist, so her further development was at the forefront of my list of things to look for as I read this chapter. Great job there, buddy!
*Unicorn comes back in, holding a blue umbrella.* *shouts* "TIME FOR CONSTRUCTIVE CRITICISM AGAIN! BRACE YOURSELF!" *bracing* *stretches*
As much as I love everything about all of the chapters of this novel that I've read so far, I think that I would be remiss if I didn't tell you that I think you should go back and scan this one over again. Once again, all of your thematic and narrative elements here are looking amazing, but I think it would do you quite well just to go back and fix some sentences and words up. Spelling and grammar are pretty solid as always, but a few tweaks here and there would be worth your while.
Also, something I was wanting more of in this chapter was further development of Poppy and Hannah. I realize that you're probably planning on saving some of that for the following chapters, and that's great. But I still think that, with as much development as you gave Alice and Cian, that you could've expanded on them a little bit more. Specifically I mean for Poppy, because you have actually provided some pretty good context for Hannah with the break-in and everything. I'm not gonna harp on it too much though, because I sense that more Poppy development will be coming around the corner.
Great job again! I'm pushing through this four-chapter reviewing spree with all of my might. I apologize if this review seemed like it came so long after my last one. I've been listening to Bohemian Rhapsody the whole time I've been writing it, so I've been jamming out/crying excitedly while trying to type.
Now then, on to chapter 4!
^_^ Thank you so much! But I think you read into it a bit much with Alice's feelings of blame, because she actually is responsible.
Lol. yeah. i do that...
Hello HT!
A little bit things I would like to tell here. I really love your writing style. The way you give descriptions of the characters in the story and the background atmosphere was very impressive for me. It looks a bit poetic to me. It is also easy to understand, not too heavy to imagine.
Really like this part!
But some, it feels like there is a vacancy in the space you provide. Once in a while it looked rather less impact on my feeling when reading it. The tone was as flat. You seems like just telling what you see, which seems to limit the imagination of the reader. I guess you would like to put some exciting moment to the story so that it can triggers a variety of sense (feelings) to the reader. I found this website that I think very interesting to read. I hope this can help you
http://www.storyjumper.com/main/starter
Keep writing!
Thank you so much Dream! This is so helpful! (I get lazy towards the ends of chapters, but since it's coming through I'll have to work harder!). That link is really helpful, too! Thank you again! ^_^
Thank you so much Dream! This is so helpful! (I get lazy towards the ends of chapters, but since it's coming through I'll have to work harder!). That link is really helpful, too! Thank you again! ^_^
Hey there Hightop!
You were right - this is where it gets confusing. But confusing in a good way. It hasn't been confusing enough to turn me off from reading, but instead intriguing enough for me to continue reading and want an explanation. One thing I know for certain is that it isn't easy at all to keep that balance, because it can easily be tipped on either side. But you've handled it perfectly so I have to give it to you there. I can't wait to see the moment when Alice recognizes her powers and maybe can control it? And Poppy with her disappearing and reappearing if she wakes up. I don't know what Hannah's power is yet, maybe she has one, maybe she doesn't. I guess I have to wait and see xD The concept of Lucy and the death-world was in an interesting one. On the other hand...
MORE IMPORTANTLY MY CIAN IS NOT DEAD. YESSS
*ahem* Back to the review. I can't wait to get to know more about Cian's power... that is somehow keeping him alive. Ooh this will definitely be interesting, and you have a lot of explaining to do!
Hm, repetition of still here? I would cut the one in the second sentence because it isn't necessary at all.
Also, I thought all these characters were children? Have you changed their ages to teenagers? If so, maybe you should mention this... or if there has been a change of time between the Godtrust chapter and what is happening now, then let me know! Because I would find it peculiar for any children who are about six or seven to be using some of the language that Alice uses at one point in this chapter. Also, I doubt they would be thinking and acting the way these kids are doing now! Alice would be in far more tears, Hannah would probably be crying instead of wondering how she can save her friend... so maybe you need to rethink age here. It could be making an unrealistic block on the story? Or perhaps you are well aware of this and I missing something, hm. Correct me if I am xD
What?! Alice's friend has just died and probably by her hand for all she knows, and she is daydreaming? That seems completely out of place, because I know anyone would find it hard to lose focus when they believe they just committed some form of murder, especially accidently to someone they actually like. So. Maybe not ready for daydreaming yet? It seemed out of place.
I have to say, there was a brilliant description here at the beginning of the chapter, where you mention that the world is still going on for other people, despite the tragic death Cian had faced. It was beautiful description, really. When you write like that I fall in love with your style :')
I was surprised that Alice felt no disgust at seeing Cian's body in bits. I mean, it can't have been a clean cut through him, could it? If it is abnormally so, then maybe mention this somewhere along the lines, that he seemed to be shaped in perfect blocks, except Alice just couldn't put them together, no matter what. Or if it is a messy death like I think it should be, please, don't refrain from going into detail? Torn muscles, oozing blood and a pale face? We want to know it all! But seeing as Alice is a child still (if she is, in this review I will go with what I know, which is her being a child) then I would want to see some of the disgust reflecting on her and what she does. I for one would be petrified... so let us know how she feels!
Remember, this is a question, albeit it a rhetorical one seeing as she isn't expecting a response from a dead person. So make sure this has a question mark!
On that note, I have to say I looooved that scene <3 It was perfect! You managed to show Alice's desperation and utter sadness at the same time. We can see it in the way that she has pieced the body back together again, and how she is pleading with him to not be mad at her, because she didn't mean it and they are friends! And the fact that she keeps repeating it, and to a dead body as well really tugged at my heart strings and showed the desperation perfectly. Between that scene and the first paragraph, this definitely makes it my favourite chapter yet!
I have a few things to say about this single part! First things first, I think you mean 'breathe' here instead of 'breath'. You probably know the difference but I will explain anyways because it's something many YWSers confuse and it might not have just been a typo. To breathe is the action of breathing. A breath is the thing you take in when you are completing the action of breathing! There
Also, I think you mean "but your mind" here instead of what is there. And lastly, there should be a form of punctuation before the closing speech marks from the quote I made. I would strongly suggest an ellipsis (which is basically just ...) so that it seems like he is trailing off and hesitating before mentioning that it is an incident. Which suggests Lucy is hiding details about the incident for his reasons. Which I do believe you want to show.
Right, I better sign off now! I have no more criticism and I enjoyed this so much ^.^ Keep up this fab writing, as always. I can't wait to have this pursuer revealed, whoever it is!
Deanie x
Thank you so much Deanie! Extremely helpful as always! I did change the ages, but I thought I told everyone. Hmm must have not. >.> At the moment, Hannah is 16 and the others are 14. Again, thank you! ^_^
Thank you so much Deanie! Extremely helpful as always! I did change the ages, but I thought I told everyone. Hmm must have not. >.> At the moment, Hannah is 16 and the others are 14. Again, thank you! ^_^
Hello! Finally convinced myself to review, so here I am!
Nitpicks
[spoiler]
1. I think that ze comma in question iz to be a period.
2. Is the to in need to suppose to be the?
You don't need the apostrophe in it's
that resembled
It'd be nice to have two creaks in the hall[spoiler]
Yay! Cian is still somewhat alive. Though when he wakes up, he is going to be in a world of pain. Honestly, how is he going to move? In short pieces? Perhaps his body heals back together so he can walk.
How in the world is Alive alive then? I'm assuming she somehow killed the monster, but if she did, how? Is it her special power? (Like Poppy's is to 'teleport' when she hiccups) If it is, Alice's power would be pretty epic.
Hannah has to carry Poppy, but no touchy! I wonder who that figure is. I guess it's a good thing that Hannah can hear things like that, even if her mom had to die in order for her to gain that skill.
Keep writing!
-lost
Thank you so much lost! ^_^ ALL your questions will be answered in the next chapter!
Thank you so much lost! ^_^ ALL your questions will be answered in the next chapter!