"Alexander Grant! How many times I've wished to see your face..." Mr. Collins smiled at me, pausing to meticulously clean his glasses then propped them up on his nose. "You've grown, boy." He said this quietly, then gave me an affectionate hug. He smelled of pine needles, like he always had and I breathed it in with relish. He looked the exact same as he did when he used to teach me in Year 8 science; ruffled brown hair that had a few grey hints to it, blue eyes that seemed to reflect whatever he was looking at, grubby brown suit and scuffed boat shoes.
I could have described what he'd be wearing today with my eyes closed.
He held me at arms length and gestured towards a desk at the back of the room. "Sit, we have much to discuss." He paused then added "Would you like a glass of something?" "Just water, thank you." I said slinging my back into an empty chair and sliding into the seat. "Ah, I've missed your immaculate manners." Mr. Collins chuckled, his voice low and husky as he padded out of the classroom.
To tell you the truth I didn't want to be here, I thought that being in this room would bring back the memories. I flinched at the word, but the wall stays solid. I know I have to be here, I need to be here to confront what happened, to let go off all the weight. I run a hand through my hair and take a deep breath, looking down. As I looked down at the hard wood of the desk, I noticed two initials on it.
CG
I was weeping before I knew it, the tears run thick and fast as the memories flood in. I tried to block it out but the wall was crumbling; fast. My hands were grasping the desk, my knuckles as white as a ghosts. Flashes of me sitting out our dining room table, not saying a word, just sitting there in silence, for days. Too caught up in the torture in my head that I didn't want to face the real world. Flashes of Callum's thin face, sitting right next to me, scribbling in his notebook while Mr. Collins spoke to the class. That awful moment when he gave a loud grunt and clutches his chest and spasms. The ambulance had come and loaded him up, they had his number, as they had all people with serious heart conditions, but they where too late.
My twin was gone. My twin, my twin, my twin. The sentence circles in my head like an excited puppy. My twin, my twin, my twin.
And I'm back to the dark tunnels in my head, the tunnels that bring memories, so many memories. They torture me, teasing me by saying that I could have saved him. I'm crying now, crying almost as much as when I sit at our house and watch as we all sink into depression. Watch as the photo of Callum seems to frown at me, blaming me for his heart attach. Watch as everything deteriorates.
"Alex?" Mr. Collins said quietly in my ear, his was voice anxious. I lifted my hands from my tear stained face and turned to look at him. "Oh, Alex." He murmured, pulling up a chair and rubbing my back with a calloused hand. "Where have you been?" He asked softly, his hand grasped my own. "I don't know, sir." I murmured, my voice hoarse and soft.
"Alex, look up." Mr. Collins said. I look up tentatively, hesitantly folding my hands in my lap like a prep. "I-I'm sorry for that." Mr Collins shakes his head. "You've nothing to be sorry for." He looked at me, but he found no response so he continued. "Your therapist tells me that your improving." I shrugged my shoulders. "Please, Alex. I know it's been tough with Callum-"
"Don't you dare say his name." I say, looking down at the floor. "It's been hard on all of us, but we need you to focus." He fished something out of his pocket and showed it to me. "Cal left this for you." It was a small silver locket. I took it carefully, as if I did it any harder it might shatter. This was the locket that had always been around Callum's neck, and no one knew what was in side. I'd always thought it was a photo of mum, but as I looked in side I gasped.
It was a picture of me and him, laughing like we'd won the lottery and wearing cordial smiles and grubby shirts. I remembered that day. We had been at the park and me and Mum had brought big bottles of cordial and loads of chips and we had had a sort of mini picnic on the rough turf. I remember how happy I'd felt to have Callum next to me. I remember that feeling, one of pure happiness, one so bubbly and certain that I'd felt like we'd spend our whole lives like this. Fresh tears spiked my eyes as I realized that I'd never wrap my arm around Callum's shoulder and laugh at the world. But I had to move on.
I fastened the chain around my neck and closed it carefully, placing it delicately on my neck. It was as if a blossom of happiness was growing inside my belly, spreading it's way through my veins and growing and growing. I felt more alive than I'd ever felt since Cal's funeral and it was all crystal clear to me now.
Cal would have wanted me to be happy, Cal would have wanted me to be alive. And I realized that I should be grateful to be alive, I should be grateful that I don't have a heart condition, I should be grateful that I can live and breathe the air. Mr. Collins was looking at me, waiting for a response. I looked into his eyes that had always seemed so mysterious and understood, that he cared about me, and he'd cared about Cal.
I ran a hand through my hair and smiled at him. I grabbed my bag and slowly stood up. I knew where I had to go now, and I was excited. As I opened the classroom door I threw one last glance back to Mr. Collins.
"Sir, thank you."
"What for?"
"Everything"
Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
EPIC! I loved this. I felt sadness. I felt happiness. I felt love. By just reading this short story. I know your going to be an awesome writer. No you ARE an awesome writer. I couldn't write anything as beautiful as this. You have a true talent. Never give up. That is my one advise. Never ever let anyone tell this talent is nothing. It is truly something. Keep writing!
From,
Buddy886551
Hi! reviewy reviewy time!
right from the start I can already tell you have great characters developed, and not only that but a great relationship dynamic. The dialogue is really good at conveying who each one of them is personally, but also how they interact with the other.
It's not a major point, but I think this little section sounds a bit awkward so if there's anyway to rephrase the second sentence to start it with something else that'd clear it right up.
These are just some examples, but I wanted to mention the switching of tenses. I know, it gets hard, it happens to me too. Just try to watch switching back and forth from past to present. If not in the first stage, it 's something easily weeded out when editing.
Because he's remembering, this should be past tense.
I get what is trying to be conveyed here, but I think there may be a better comparison just because even using the word "excited" kind of breaks the emotion I think we're supposed to feel, and that's something that should continue throughout this traumatic reenactment.
I'm pretty sure this is supposed to be switched around to "his voice was..."
This part confuses me slightly. Does he mean where has he been in his head? Or am I supposed to take it literally like when has he been since his brother died? I could use a little explanation or some kind of lead in for clarification.
I'm pretty sure this dialogue is supposed to be for two different people, but there is no indication of a switch before the second dialogue starts so it'd be great to insert one there so readers know before hand.
Maybe this could work better?
I think this might flow a little better, so it doesn't have to say "my neck" twice like that.
This is a really good story overall. Everything I pointed out is minor compared to how well you developed the plot and the characters and the relationships. You even managed to give the readers a sense of who Callum was and what he cared about, even though at this point he was already dead. Good job, you're a good writer. And this, my friend, is a good piece.
Hi. I'm gonna start by saying that this was a very beautifully written piece. It was sad yet the beauty was portrayed through the never ending love of Alex for his twin brother. I liked how you didn't just start off by telling us that they were twins or that something tragic had happened in his life. Even though in the description you mentioned about his sad memories so I was expecting a very sad start, something depressing.
However, when I first started reading, the beauty had already begun to show an I was mesmerized in the story so much that I forgot what the description said. The dialogues were enough to portray a deeper relationship between the student and teacher. I noticed that near the end you mentioned that the.teacher cares about Alex and his brother. Even if you hadn't mentioned that, it was so evident already.
Now coming to the descriptions which were amazing. You picked exactly the right words for this. How you described was of a very professional level, enough to get me teary eyed. The part where the sudden word memory triggers his own memories to surface. And that part, what I liked most, the one thing that amplified the hurt he was and had experienced, it was that Alex was completely helpless. That one word had thrown knives at him from every direction and he couldn't stop thinking about his past.
At that time, even though I had no idea what had happened, I could still feel his pain so clearly. Your choice of words was perfect, as I said before. The recalling part especially seemed to get me more and more engrossed in the story that I couldn't stop myself from feeling sad. It was way too intense, the atmosphere.
One thing that I was disappointed by was the length of this story. You left it at a cliff hanger. I had been wanting to read about what was on his mind and where he intended to go at the end. Because when the story ended it was like I had just been snapped out of a trance. Your words leave a heavy impact on the reader so I hope you keep writing like this. Keep it up! =]
Wow, thanks for the awesome review!
Hey, HT here for a review.
I'm going to start by talking about what I believe you can improve on. Please keep in mind that these are my opinions and suggestions and you don't have to listen to them if you don't want to.
The last portion of this sentence didn't really sit right with me, particularly your use of the past tense form of 'give'. For some reason it doesn't feel right in the sentence.
I think that using 'giving' would be a little more appropriate.
First off, you need to place a comma after the word 'added'. Secondly, you need to separate the dialogue here, to keep it from feeling to crowded.
Thoughts are indicated using italics.
Another thing about this. At first I read this as a separate thought, which is why I pointed out the italics. But reading back over it, I discovered that it could also be considered part of the sentence. Which do you want it to be?
And I you don't want it to be a separate thought that requires italics, I would suggest turning all the words before the comma into a separate sentence. In other words, replace the comma with a period.
I liked the story, the plot. I liked how you had one little bit of humor underneath all the angst. (I found it funny anyway, even thought I probably shouldn't have)
I just imagined a puppy running in one ear and out the other.
I thought that this could have used more thought. That the narrator could've gone deeper into what Cal was like before he died, so that the readers understand the loss better. The dialogue you have is good you just need to separate it out.
(A bonus is that this adds a little bit of length without adding any content at all)
I think that the ending was appropriate, although I do find it hard to believe that he just got over it like that (that is the impression I got anyway).
Oh, well, I've said all I need to say, so I'll get out of your hair. And off your screen.
Peace,
HT
Thank you very much for your review, I really appreciate it.
Hi, I like the idea you worked with here, but there are a few things to comment on.
The whole, what I feel is too much of a happy ending, kind of messed the story up for me a bit. It just seems a bit cliche' that the guy just finds a way to recover from the depression he feels about his brother. After all, getting over a loss takes a long time, and often one never gets over loss. I feel that you could've alluded to the character making some brief improvement, indicating hope. But the full recovery-as it seemed- was too much, and an easy option.
Also, there could be less conversation in the story and more decription or thought from the character.
But again, these are just my personal views of your story. Choose whether to take on my criticism if you like, but you don't have to.
Overall, the story was really good.
Legy,
Thanks you Legy. I'm working on my second draft of this, which I'll take onward your opinions. After re reading this I've found that I agree with you.