Why is death blackheart? That’s what I want to know. You spend the whole poem describing it, then you name it, but you don’t really give a reason for why you call it by a different name.
Combining words that are usually separate in the English language is a very powerful technique. You can essentially create new words and feelings from the combination of what you choose. Each word brings its own associations and solid meanings, but together they can evoke something much different. Take for example Seedwood. You get the image of the seeds, but the strength of a tree, something floating and steady at the same time. It makes me think of truffula trees. But that’s just me. Or Treecup. What’s that? The daintiness of tea time with the nature of a tree? Refinement and rural feelings all together in one? You knew, maybe, that words worked this way, so you tried. But BlackHeart falls short. Why? Because they can be paired together in proper spacing with the same meaning. Black Heart is a heart that is black the same way that BlackHeart is. There’s no necessity, no force in their pairing, so it falls flat and weak and doesn’t carry the poem.
Go further. Get more associative. What does it mean to you if a heart is black? Does it mean withered? Does it mean dark? Does it mean painted with a mask? Find the words you really want to call death, then go back and rework this poem. Make every word play to that naming. Make us understand exactly why you chose those two words to rename something that is common to everyone on earth, so much so that we don’t need to rename it. So why did you feel that you needed to?
Also, did you intentionally use the language of the Jack and the Beanstalk faerie tale? “Crush my bones and grind my lungs”? Sounds like the giant who wants to eat the thief in his house. To make his bread, you know? Are you familiar with that? If not, it gives a somewhat ridiculous tone to that line instead of the seriousness I think you’re intending.
Anyway, PM me if you have any questions or comments about my review, please. I don’t get notifications about replies to reviews.
Good luck and keep writing!
Points: 25864
Reviews: 1334
Donate