

maybe “(They Long to Be) Close to You” by The Carpenters< I love the match-up between this song and this character xD Those are great character questionnaire responses - I think you've captured the essence of character types that are just 'too good to be true' even in fiction, while also subverting that and giving them story-relevant character flaws (i.e. insecurities -> wants to prove she's not a Mary Sue).
“Angel, I don’t know what you’re trying to say,” said Bryony, shaking her head. “I can’t read your mind. Jhémes just got here at the beginning of geography. Is there something I’m supposed to notice about him?”
Angel flinched slightly as Bryony said his name. She drew another deep breath, suddenly feeling her entire body start to tremble. “He isn’t like any boy I’ve met in the past,” she said, her voice wobbling melodically. “He’s making me feel things I’ve never felt before.”
Bryony’s expression changed to one of disbelief and almost horror. “Angel, no.”
“I have to admit it!” exclaimed Angel, stopping in her tracks in the middle of the hallway. She placed a hand on her chest. “My heart is beating so fast right now, and I can’t get him off my mind because—”
“Shh!” hissed Bryony, pulling Angel toward the lockers and out of the way of the throng of students who had stopped to stare as Angel began what was definitely shaping up to become a monologue.
Bryony laughed awkwardly and waved a hand dismissively. “No need to be concerned, everyone. Angel’s just practicing for an audition. Method acting, am I right?”
The students continued walking, murmuring about how Angel was going to break into yet another sector of the entertainment and arts industry. Bryony let out a heavy sigh, pressing her fingers to her temple.
“Angel, I know he’s different and all—I mean, I couldn’t help staring at him either. But why don’t we take a step back and—”
“I feel like my existence has been threatened by him,” said Angel, continuing as if she had never been interrupted, though she lowered her voice. “I never thought the day would come when I encounter a rival.”
“What? A rival? Angel, I thought you were about to say you fell in love with him after only one second when you guys bumped into each other before class and you did that long stare into each other’s eyes!”
“I—we didn’t stare into each other’s eyes!” Angel scoffed. “Anyways, no way! I meant his appearance and his aura. I even heard someone saying earlier that his beauty was on the same level as mine.”
Bryony pinched the bridge of her nose. She sighed again. “So that’s what you meant. Please don’t scare me like that again. I’ve had too much excitement for a Wednesday morning.”