cidrianwritersguild

Good Evening, Kit/Kitkit/Kitkitkat, Now, I'm not really one for the deeper side of writing or thinking, but I figure you deserve a review, so here goes nothing. Firstly: If you've ...

Hello there, Recal! Quite excited to jump back into YWS on your work! So, onward! BRAVELY! Firstly: Marla Thatcher. I'm Irish, so you can see some problems I have with ...

Hello! We are the Cidrian Writers' Guild, here to fill you day with unsolicited advice! Your story is good overall. It's got interesting characters and an even more interesting premise. ...

Hello there! We are the Cidrian Writers' Guild, here to brighten your day with unwarranted and unsolicited criticism. Are you ready? We've read through the whole thing and come to ...

Hey there! We're the Cidrian Writer's Guild and we'd normally make a sarcastic comment about tearing into your work for no reason but you seem nice so we won't do ...

Hey there, Inu! *half-hearted sarcastic joke about being unnecessarily critical* This is a small piece you have here, so we don't have a lot to tell you, but we'll give ...

We would quickly like to preface this by being EXTRAORDINARILY pedantic and pointing out that Albert Einstein once said: I know not with what weapons World War III will be ...

Hello there, Zycoptl! How are you? Good? Well, we're about to make it not that way. Let's get into the review! This is a good story. The only problems we ...

AH! We're back! Happy to see us? No? Good! That means we're doing out job write. HA!! GET IT?! Into the review! Right off the bat, lots of respect to ...

Hey there! The Cidrian Writer's Guild is here to make you feel bad with pointless criticism and obtuse remarks! You ready? Doesn't matter, we don't care! First off, your beginning ...

A tale chilling to the bone! Shut up, that can be used to describe things other than temperature. The thing that sticks out to us the most about this is ...

Now, don't take this the wrong way, we're just very blunt, but the best way to describe this work is...confusing, or maybe helter skelter. Maybe that was what you were ...

Ho there, James! The Cidrian Writer's Guild is here to satiate our own egos by being unnecessarily mean about something you're, in all likelihood, emotionally attached to! Ready? No? TOO ...

Hello there, Underscore! We understand your frustration. Countless times have we touched quill to parchment (what is this "typing" you refer to), heads filled to bursting with ideas, only to ...

*Irish accent* AND RIP IT APART WE SHALL! Hello there, Ilium. We're here to be critical, nitpicky, boring, and slightly insulting to this work of literature you've clearly put lots ...