-
Re: Up!
This was cool. It's nice to see a light, happy sung here for one, because most aren't. Simple tune and I got it immediately. This song kind of reminded me ...
Jun 28, 2008 -
Re: Out of Focus [Edited 8/29/08]
This was really good. I was able to get the picture before I reached it because it was kind of obvious (what else would have happend), but it was really ...
Jun 28, 2008 -
Re: Breaking Rain
This is really good. Will you have a recordig by any chance, because I really liked this, and I'd love to hear it sung. I could definetely hear it very ...
Jun 28, 2008 -
Re: The Elbe is Filled With Prayers
This was really good. I'm very interested in WW2, and I beleve this was the bombing of Dresden, when the English got back at the Germans for the Blitz? Correct ...
Jun 25, 2008 -
Re: A Time Before
Welcome to YWS! The first thing I'd like to point out is that we have a two for one reviewing policy. We like it if you would make at least ...
Jun 25, 2008 -
Re: Abortions.
This reads more of a speech than an essay. And I'd like to say one thing: state your position at the beginning of the piece. I hate reading it and ...
Jun 25, 2008 -
Re: A Father's Legacy: New Take
I only skimmed the reviews, but it looks like you got some pretty detailed ones, so I'll just tell you what I thought. This piece was very... random. I don't ...
Jun 25, 2008 -
Re: Thank you, Mom.
Okay, so your writing wasn't bad. There weren't any mistakes or issues I could spot, but I have a couple of issues with how you wrote it. This piece was ...
Jun 25, 2008 -
Re: Enigma
I don't have time for a proper critique, so I'll give you my impressions. This story went way too fast. Slowly it down, break it into chapters. You need more ...
Jun 24, 2008 -
Re: Coming Home
I liked this, especially in the beginning. I thought the second bit broke the mood a bit, but it was so good. I can't say a lot about your writing. ...
Jun 22, 2008 -
Re: Faded Love, Not Jeans
I agree with the above. It was nice, but it short. I can see this being a prologue, and the story being the longer version of the events. it all ...
Jun 21, 2008 -
Re: Stranger
I quite liked it. It was short, but it was interesting. What's the lone adjective? I can't spot it, although I'm not good at that sort of thing. Now, onto ...
Jun 20, 2008 -
Re: Song
First of all, welcome to YWS! I hope you have a great time here and find everybody very helpful. Second, here on YWS we have a 2:1 policy. That is ...
Jun 19, 2008 -
Re: On End
Well, you seem to have gotten a lot of detailed critiques on your actual writing (I only skimmed the critiques, so sorry if I repeat anything), so I'll just give ...
Jun 18, 2008 -
Re: Deleted
I read this before I went to school, but I didn't have time to critique it, so here I am now! I hope I do it justice. Pete drank, and ...
Jun 18, 2008
