Published June 22, 2008
Writing more in progress............
Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
I only skimmed the reviews, but it looks like you got some pretty detailed ones, so I'll just tell you what I thought.
This piece was very... random. I don't get what's going on, and everything is all over the place. A lot of your grammar and spacing was bad as well, so I'd fix that up.
I think that this could be interesting, but you need to slow down. Introduce these characters to us. Think about it a bit more. Is this supposed to be a novel? Because if it is, you have plenty more time to start off the story. Right now, I want you characters and maybe a little bit of plot, but I don't want to be jumping around everywhere and having to scroll back up to check something.
And one inconsistency I noticed: the price went up from $2 an hour, to $2.50 an hour. Easliy fixed up, but something I noticed.
Good luck!
Thank you Jamie_Rocks for also taking your time to review and edit this.
And yes I am planning on edit it and furthering the story. I don't know where the plot is headed yet but you all will be able to see the progress of this.
Ink
Okay, wow that took a while. That's not a bad thing, though. Okay, as I pointed out in the story, you tell instead of show us a lot. The examples hopefully show you how to do something about that.
I don't know how many times I told you this above, but you have to start a new line whenever a new person talks, especially in a conversation, so you can tell who's saying what.
Another problem is you state the obvious. Very bluntly. You hint at most of then a lot first, most smart people can tell what you're saying, without you coming out and writing it directly.
Now, you've got my interest in this story. I want to see what happens with this strange guy, and what the job is th Brad and your MC are working on. I'm sorry if I sound harsh, but the story line has a lot of potential, and I'm only trying to help you reach that potential. This is a good, solid start for the story. (You are going to lengthen it, aren't you?) I don't think you should stop here, there's still way too many questions. If you are going to continue, that's good, it makes em want to keep reading.
If you have any questions about my review, or when (if) the next part comes out, please PM me.
Thank you Avens, for taking your time to go over most of this piece. I would like to apologize to you, because I did not look at the forum rules before posting this and as you have made clear, that there is many errors present.
Ink
Comments in red.
Okay, I'm sorry but I kind of gave up where my comments ended. I read through the rest, but it's all pretty much in the same vein.
First off--
Said.
Said is a very beautiful word. I give it to you in a pretty gift box with a red tinsel bow. Use it wisely. As in use it a lot. Instead of all of the other speech descriptors.
You see, the word "said" is very easy on the eye and works so well in writing; as soon as you become accustomed to it, you'll cringe when encountering anything else.
Also--
Tense.
You need to pick one and then stick to it. The piece boomeranged over the place.
And of course--
Characterization.
You should probably go back over your characters and work on sinking some more life into them. The MC is so unbelievably calm the whole time. It's as if he's bored.
Went to the market. Picked up some eggs. The weather was nice. House burned down. Some one shot at me. Made dinner...
He doesn't freak out; his fear is nonexistent, and thus when he's yelling at Brad (in an email of all things) I just don't feel it.
If he's non-human, then that should be clarified at the beginning of the story, but, as it stands, I had no connection at all with Ray. I wanted one. I wanted to believe what was happening. I wanted to care. I just couldn't.
Other than that, I have this sneaking suspicion that you didn't proof it, as there were a number of mistakes in capitalization, punctuation, and spelling. Please see the forum rules on that.
Now obviously the concept and writing belong to you, and you have the final say, but let me know if you take any of my advice and I'll try giving it a second read.
Avens.