Published June 17, 2008
Deleted.
Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Yay! The second part is up! The first thing though, it's not double spaced, which makes reading it very annoying. Reckon you could double space it, just for me? Now, onto your actual writing...
I know that you said Jamie's sister's for our benefit, but I think he'd probably just say her name (Claire, I think it was).
For a second I was a bit confused here, because Joe was just talking. I'd say, Pete nodded.
I think this is one of the best bits. Your writing is really good here, and I can imagine it very easily.
Make the or, and.
Overall
I still like this. Your plot is very intriguing, and I want to read more. I agree with Sam, Pete's accent is so heavy and it's getting very annoying to read. I'd ease up on it a bit, because it stops me reading it fluently.
There wasn't really much to point out, just a couple of word changes really. So yeah, you've got a good thing going on here.
Let me know when you post more!
I like it. The characters are very real. You have the process of grief down completely.
This sentence seems a little too smart for a drunk. I think you should dumb this down a bit.
Other than that. I really like it. I would like to see where this goes and what happens to Pete. PM if you have any questions about the review, or when the next part comes out.
Deleted
I read this before I went to school, but I didn't have time to critique it, so here I am now! I hope I do it justice.
I would get rid of the first and, and then add in a he after the second and.
I would change around the falling across his face and the woke him.
I think this would read better as-
A waft of stale air hit his nostrils, a mix of his unwashed body, cigarette smoke and Scotch. A bottle sat on the bedside table, a half-full glass beside it.
What's with the neat?
He was drinking Scotch before, so the another doesn't work here, or are the two interchangeable?
This bit is really good. It's so... real. Is this Joe guy going to be a recurring character, because I like him already. And the end bit is really funny.
Give him what? I'm assuming he's talking about the mobile, because they were just discussing that, but I'm not sure. You should be more clear.
Get rid of the comma.
Overall
I really like this. It's very real, very gritty. I hope you keep posting it because I want to keep reading.
I like your characters, and I'm interested in meeting Alex. I don't really have much else to say expect that I'm looking forward to more!
Heidi! *throws love at*
Okay, so I absolutely adore this piece. Jamie and Pete are great characters, and I choked up a little reading the sweater scene. It was really beautiful--it's just this mundane thing, but when someone you love is completely gone from your life, you really have to search hard (and desperately) to find something they've left behind. You do the drunken, upset character rather well. Even though I haven't quite met Pete, I felt really bad for him and was able to feel the tears come on in the first chapter. That's a mark of a job well done, dahling.
The only thing I would like to chat with you about is Pete's accent. Granted, I know it's probably a huge marker of character for you, and really helps you to get into his "feel" and voice. However, it's something that I'm going to try to wean you away from--I know you're not doing this, but it can't become a stand in for legitimate character development. You have to make his speech sound natural and Pete-like without misspelling words.
Granted, if you want to make this a small element of his characterization, that's okay. I'd recommend reading through Suzanne's God Still Loves You--she uses words like "warsh" characteristic of the American midwest that really help readers to place where her secondary characters are, geographically and intellectually. If that's what you want to mark in Pete, that's okay. But if you misspell everything, your readers (e.g., me, because I'm a freak) spend more time reading Pete's dialogue aloud because they think it's cool to sound Scottish, rather than mulling over what it actually means. People walking around their bedrooms muttering "Och, aye" and reading Pete's dialogue aloud is definitely a mood-killer.
Please PM me if you have any questions or if you simply want to chat about this piece. ^_^ I love it to bits, and would love to hear more from you about it.