-
Re: "Escape from Loredaen Hall" chap. 1: The Letter
Heyo Loredaen! You've got a good grasp of mechanics, and it's obvious that you can write (even for a draft, this is pretty good!). However, my main complaint with this ...
Jun 30, 2009 -
Re: A Blank Page: Prologue prt. 3: The Swirling Sun
Hey! Sorry it took me so long to comment on this. I'd read it when you messaged me, and then I got distracted by school... and well... Anyways. I just ...
Jun 26, 2009 -
Re: A Blank Page: Prologue prt. 2: The Book Room
Sorry that this isn't a full review, but I'm not finding much to criticize in this piece. Your characters are strong and compelling, and the conflict is present in full ...
Jun 5, 2009 -
Re: A Blank Page: Prologue prt. 1: An Alliance Betrayed
The first paragraph had me sort of wary, but you managed to banish that completely within the next two. This drew me in and held me in a stranglehold. The ...
Jun 1, 2009 -
Re: Little Macey
This was really cool. Short, chopped sentences captured the mentality and youth of the MC very well, as well as managing to make this super creepy. For the first half, ...
May 31, 2009 -
Re: A short book I wrote. I hope you like it.
Hmmm.... I agree with fortuna. You need to cut this up and look over it, 'cause there were quite a few spelling/grammar mistakes. And part of that is the voice ...
May 31, 2009 -
Re: Askarina Bergatrollet part 1 of 2
There's not much to critique about this piece - it was very good! You've got a very traditional voice and style that evokes fairy tales, though I think it could ...
May 31, 2009 -
Re: Gaea - Chapter 1
A well-written piece, but I am fascinated by the fact that you think this is sparse description. Your first paragraph is pure description (and I tend to dislike Setting starters, ...
Feb 23, 2009 -
Re: No title...yet (prologue)
Interesting premise, very nice structure with the three princess types. The descriptions of the three are all very well written, and you've got some nice allusions in there. The last ...
Feb 23, 2009 -
Re: Shadow Of The Sun (1)
ah, so there is going to be more of this? I read this thinking that it was a stand-alone piece - which, it almost worked, it really almost did. I ...
Feb 20, 2009 -
Re: Prologue
I think Thunder and Haruno have gotten most of the nit picks, so I won't go over those again; i'll just give my first impressions. It wasn't badly written - ...
Jan 18, 2009 -
Re: The Tale Of The Tree Child
My comments are in bold following each paragraph There once was a young girl that lived in a world called Threa. Threa was a very large and beautiful world. There ...
Jan 15, 2009 -
Re: The Stitching
Amazing work. The character interaction was so completely well done - it's all very subtle, very jane austen, as others have mentioned. You've captured the language perfectly as well, and ...
Jan 15, 2009 -
Re: Redemption Chapter 1
I think Jabber covered most of it. You can't always expect a reader to read a prologue before jumping into the text proper - I know at least one person ...
Jan 15, 2009 -
Re: Weavers Ch 1
Amazing work. This is excellently written - the descriptions are absolutely beautiful. You capture the MC's emotions very well. One thing I will say is that as I began to ...
Jan 14, 2009
