-
Re: Why I Hate Liking You
Oh my... this is an old poem. It's quite amazing how you've progressed throughout the years. You've progressed a long way from this sort of ranty non-poem thing to some ...
Feb 2, 2008 -
Re: Flying Cows Say Oink
Haha, love the title. ;) Right now, it's very abstract, but I'm yearning for some substance here. You have her listening to the record, but why does she die suddenly? ...
Jan 28, 2008 -
Re: Terminal
Right now, this character is slightly confusing because we don't know who's who. Put names to the characters! Instead of just saying, "the figure came up," describe what the figure ...
Jan 27, 2008 -
Re: cold black heart
Okay. This poem made me want to commit self-flagellation, simply because if I flog my back until it's a bloody pulp, then maybe the physical side of me will match ...
Jan 25, 2008 -
Re: EverWayward #1
First of all, welcome to YWS! :D Errant mentioned my name, though he didn't mention this story to me persay. I suppose I might be considered one of the harsher ...
Jan 21, 2008 -
Re: Self-Reflection
Some really nice stuff here! When I read and critique poetry, I tend to read it out loud, and it wasn't completely unsmooth when I read it, which is very ...
Jan 16, 2008 -
Re: Moonlight Seagull: Chapter One Flickin' Erasers
Hehe, you had some pretty amusing typos. ^_^ He had short gelled black hair and pail white skin. pail = You want pale. :) Get a holed of yourself Sam... ...
Jan 13, 2008 -
Re: Reasons
It's too vague to be really powerful. Right now, you have a rambling, image-less poem and there seems to be no feeling involved. Take a deep breath. What do you ...
Jan 13, 2008 -
Re: Leonardo
I like the beginning, because it is slightly ambiguous. Instead of telling us exactly what is happening, you use details that are not too specific and we can form our ...
Jan 13, 2008 -
Re: God Knew
The main qualm I had is it seems to be the Judeo-Christian God that you're talking about, and yet you never mention Jesus at all. Which is weird, because the ...
Jan 12, 2008 -
Re: Life!!!
1) Do not comment on your poem. I deleted that post. 2) Poems that have smilies in them should be kicked into submission. Why? Smilies are cheesy. And they make ...
Jan 12, 2008 -
Re: Fifteen Eternal Candles (Chapter 1, Scene 6)
The reason why it's not working is because it's too rushed. You spent all this time talking about dresses, using all these bloated adjectives and everything to describe it, but ...
Jan 9, 2008 -
Re: I hate Life
This has several conflicting messages. The narrator hates life and yet he would be perfectly happy if he goes to another place? Confusing! So this guy obviously doesn't really hate ...
Jan 7, 2008 -
Re: An Unwanted Truth
I have to agree with kittykat. Maybe it's the several days I've spent of editing a story, but there seem like a lot of unnecessary words that were not too ...
Jan 5, 2008 -
Re: not my fairy tale
You start off with a fairly interesting start (at least interesting for us writers anyway) but then... you get off topic. What exactly is the point you want to make? ...
Jan 1, 2008
