-
Re: A truth, a lie, and a half-truth
Helloooo Megrim here to review as requested, and with pretty much no knowledge of poetry so take it all with a grain of salt! Formatting first. I think I do ...
Sep 12, 2017 -
Re: The Seventh Sister (Part 1)
Hello there! I read this for Lightsong's entry into the Critique Crucible, and while I was at it I noticed some things no one else mentioned yet. While I really ...
Sep 7, 2017 -
Re: Mr. Adkins [RC: R2]
Fantastic revision! The characters are much more lovable and understandable this time around, and I think you really brought out the relationship between the Millie and Mr Adkins. I love ...
Mar 22, 2017 -
Re: A Secret Worth Keeping [RC:R2]
I looooove what you've done with this since last week. You've really smoothed it out and brought the characters much more alive. The opening makes Mia immediately sympathetic, as we ...
Mar 22, 2017 -
Re: Mr. Adkins [RC: R1]
Hey there! So far this one is pretty unique with its subject so I'm loving that. The first scene is excellent. You do a great job of immediately establishing the ...
Mar 13, 2017 -
Re: The Last Bounty [RC:R1]
Hi! I'm excited to see a SF story in the mix. I like the MC, being a strong and capable woman, who stands up for herself in the end. It's ...
Mar 13, 2017 -
Re: Seeing Lisa (RC: R1)
Hey there! Brave first submission of the contest. This is a cute story and fits nicely into its length. I particularly found Lisa charming (especially lines like Maybe I’ll reincarnate ...
Mar 13, 2017 -
Re: Prologue
I there! I got here a rather roundabout way. I saw the first chapter in the green room and thought I should do this one first. Then it disappeared before ...
Feb 22, 2017 -
Re: blank
Hi there! I spotted this in the green room and thought I'd come to investigate. This actually has quite a similar feel to my friend's book, which is also a ...
Feb 22, 2017 -
Re: Evil's Affection: Chapter 1
Hi there, and welcome to YWS! I'm Megrim, one of the mods from the Resources forums (good place to ask questions and join in discussions and brainstorming!) First of all, ...
Feb 21, 2017 -
Re: Hook-Up Shoot-Up (LMS Story 1)
Hey there! I'm not sure if I have much to say in the way of criticism, because this was really fantastic. At first, I was thinking I might comment on ...
Feb 18, 2017 -
Re: Ascension: Phyrza Prologue (The Myriad book 1)
I love this prologue! It's beautiful, especially the imagery at the beginning, and the characters are fascinating and enigmatic. I love the descriptions, and the character's reflecting on the ages ...
Feb 16, 2017 -
Re: Ascension: Corso 1 (The Myriad book 1)
Hi Feltrix, and welcome to YWS! This is a very fun world & story you've got her, and likable characters. I peeked at your wall and must confess I'm dying ...
Feb 16, 2017 -
Re: Harbingers of Revolution: Quarantine 1.1 - The Oncoming Storm
Hi! Excited to read this! I'm like SUPER worried about Isaiah because I don't really recall seeing mention of him on your character list / LMS notes in general :( ...
Feb 16, 2017 -
Re: Madly: Chapter 1
Oooh the first chapter is up, yay! I love psych ward/hospital settings. I also am really intrigued by the MC--you have some strong characterization going on with the repetition of ...
Feb 15, 2017
