-
Re: The Bird and the Cage
A nice bit of catharsis, but it's not particularly cohesive. It needs to be streamlined, both allegorically and otherwise. A number of symbols remain nebulous or redundant or undefined. For ...
Apr 28, 2013 -
Re: Dream Diary
Frantic night times are inevitably followed by the aching mass of fear, frustration and relief. I mark down each one on a pink calendar. I'm writing an essay on sleep, ...
Apr 28, 2013 -
Re: Still Standing
While I think this was still a bit too structured to be labelled as strictly free-verse, I enjoyed the honesty of this piece. It's simple at first glance, and accessible ...
Apr 28, 2013 -
Re: Chapter one: Voices (Edited/Revised!)
1. The behavior of the doctors and was noticeably theatrical, and unrealistic. No doctor--certainly no doctor treating something as serious as amnesia--would be so lighthearted about waking a patient.
Apr 28, 2013 -
Re: Jeff's Diary: The Book of Shadows
Your voice certainly made this an enjoyable read, even if there wasn't any discernible or logical plot. I can't decide whether this should be labelled as a postmodernist experiment or ...
Apr 28, 2013 -
Re: Ashes and Shards
This was done well. The repetition of destructive imagery works well to tune this piece to the angrily regretful ambience I think you were shooting for. Your symbolism was effective, ...
Apr 28, 2013 -
Re: A Twisted Torture
It wasn't sad. It was disturbing, maybe, macabre, but there was no context or basis for sentimentality and whatever plot exists here is masked by the gore. My guess is ...
Apr 28, 2013 -
Re: subject, verb, object.
Everything from Oh, it’s a technical problem, down, I love. The first half isn't particularly cohesive or convincing, probing before realizing specifically what it's attempting to say, what you are ...
Apr 26, 2013 -
Re: Meditate
A few suggestions: 1. Don't write in second person, or at least not in the way you've done it here. Much of this piece reads less like poetry and more ...
Apr 25, 2013 -
Re: A Faceless Man
While I enjoy the inventiveness of your premise, I feel that a bit more cohesiveness and concision would do this piece good. It lacks a single, unifying theme. Consider you ...
Apr 13, 2013 -
Re: Do you trust me?
As a loyal student of Kafka, I found the bizarreness of this piece amusing, if not especially moving. The characteristic disturbingly honest symbolism, at least, evidences Kafka, though the style ...
Apr 6, 2013 -
Re: there is light in me, even when I cannot see
I ask a sinner what worship tastes like and they said, "acceptance" Other than the odd tense incongruity between "ask" and "said," there's nothing much to complain about here. It's ...
Mar 26, 2013 -
Re: Hope Against All Reason
It's like a scene straight out of a Disney children's movie, isn't it? Designed for an audience with zero deductive ability, reduced and simplified and chipped at until no further ...
Mar 20, 2013 -
Re: Unrequited Love Pains
Well, it's a sex-driven world. There's no way to get around that. One thing you could do with this piece is expand it and go into greater detail. Both for ...
Mar 18, 2013 -
Re: The Devil's Traitor I
Great opening chapter. Your diction is engaging and your pace is well-measured. I have a few comments. First, the transition from the opening seasonal description to that of the training ...
Mar 17, 2013
