-
Re: Open Up [edit]
I have to say I like it. Phorcys may have a point in that the waking-up-in-a-torture-room narrative is a little overdone, but it was well-written enough to overcome that. I ...
Oct 22, 2007 -
Re: Stevie Wonder
This is a decent essay. It flows well while efficiently disclosing information. Your main problems are mainly in syntax and grammar and all that--I'm just going to correct them here. ...
Oct 20, 2007 -
Re: Dawn to Dusk
I'm not really sure what to think of it, Cameron. I enjoyed the imagery, but as far as I can tell, this poem has little or no point. It displays ...
Oct 20, 2007 -
Re: Love is a Cliche
Love is cliche....but so is this poem. Only the ending really struck me as something interesting. I think this has the potential to be much improved, though; this poem should ...
Oct 20, 2007 -
Re: The Coward
Wow, Brad went on a critiquing binge today! I'd have to agree with him. I think this topic could be pulled off, but you need a little more practice. It's ...
Oct 20, 2007 -
Re: Wide Awake in a Dream
I rather enjoyed it. It made me think of Walt Whitman's "Song of Myself", especially III. I disagree with Brad's comment on the speaker's confusion--I think that, for the mots ...
Oct 20, 2007 -
Re: Talking to Chris
I really like this...the first stanza especially pulled me in. At first thought, it seemed like a cliche sort of image, because poems about memory so often involve beaches, but ...
Oct 19, 2007 -
Re: An Ode to Death
Oooh, I agree with elephantwalrus...excellent job of putting another meaning into the phrase "grim reaper". It was a very clever, original poem. I like it! My main problem is that ...
Oct 19, 2007 -
Re: All Was Dark/Light (Two Halves of A Whole) by James Goh
might be a prose-poem? Poetry or not, I take issue with this because I don't know why I'm reading it. What does it mean? What sort of conclusion shall I ...
Oct 19, 2007 -
Re: "She is not human"
Hi there! I see that you're new, so I just want to make sure you know a very important rule around here. Please critique two pieces before you post your ...
Oct 18, 2007 -
Re: The Heart of the Heavens
Haha, did you mean to put "The Heart of the Heave m s" in the subject line? This really appealed to me; I do enjoy seeing suicide written about in ...
Oct 17, 2007 -
Re: 'The Moons Lament'
Man once worshipped me They offered sweet sacrifices to me Beautiful tokens of love put out for me They put down their very lives to me. I think you should ...
Oct 17, 2007 -
Re: More than emotion but less than a life
I agree; the sentences were choppy and you weren't very articulate in expressing emotion. Structure and Tone. Poets can use sentence structure and tone to their advantage; here, I don't ...
Oct 17, 2007 -
Re: City girl
You have an interesting premise here; I definitely know what you're talking about because I moved from a rural area to the suburbs when I was ten. You have some ...
Oct 16, 2007 -
Re: For the Win
...I, too, went "FTW!" the second I saw this. My main problem with this poem is that it doesn't sound like a poem. It sounds like prose. What's worse, it ...
Oct 16, 2007
