Young Writers Society

Hello Pineapple! I would like to give your poem a short review since I found it very interesting and the style of writing used here is quite appealing.

Quick disclaimer before I begin, I am in no way a professional or anything remotely similar to that so my advice may not be particularly correct!

First of all, I would like to say that I love the themes you have expressed here. Experimenting with the idea that a word can have many different meanings is one of my favorite things to see in literature, especially in poetry. The first stanza is beautifully written and the rhyme between "calm" and "wrong" is very satisfying. I really like how you used fairly simple lines all throughout the poem, it really added a nice effect to the message you were trying to convey.

There are I couple of small things that felt a tiny bit off to me. I did not quite grasp the rhythm or flow of the poem, of course poems don't always need to have a set rhythm but maybe it would be a good idea to add a pattern that ties together all the stanzas. I am not the most perceptive person but I also did not really understand the metaphor behind the last two stanzas. This is probably entirely just me being bad at understanding poetry though, ha-ha!

Overall, a fantastic effort and I really enjoyed reading and analyzing your work!

Hey There !!!!
Wow Your poem is indeed absolutely stunning that I cant express it in words ...
Your Originality and Expressiveness is exemplary just like your writing skills ...
You have presented both the Horrifying and the Sweet truth of Silence that is so relatable to the contemporary times ,when people yearn for silence and calm to escape from the hectic reality ….
You are truly a promising writer
Looking forward for more poems
Cheers!!!

Hey there, pineapple, I hope you're having a good day and staying as safe as you can!

When I read the title, I immediately thought of the song The Sound of Silence. It's silly, I know.
Your poem itself is rather good. You've played with the idea of silence and what it means to you and what it can mean to others, and it's intriguing to see what you think. You did contradict yourself in the poem - whether that was intentional or not, I think you need to clarify what you want to express - which made me doubt the point of the first stanza.

You end by saying, "We cannot be silent."
Well, that depends on the allegorical meaning of silence in this poem. Supposing it is sadness or depression; yes, it is comforting and calm, even interesting, but not something we should actively pursue. So I can agree with you. What if I interpret it as death, or peace? Is it really so bad then?
My mind is a little clouded, so if there's a much deeper meaning I don't think I've found it.

Now, regarding structure. I don't see the need for a rhyme scheme. Good poetry does not need a rhyme, and while it can often emphasize certain parts of the poem, here it is redundant and has inhibited your skill. Matching "comforting" and "interesting" feels out of place.

Silence can be fear

Silence can be dangerous

Silence is always near

It is treacherous

Good morning, good evening, good afternoon, and goodnight, as well as many other pleasant things that I do not have time for as I am here to review this. Anyway, wolf here.
I really love this poem I can tell you put a lot of thought into it and it really shows through.
I find this very relatable as I often find myself seeking silence because as you said "Silence is comforting"
It is indeed a very beautiful and well written poem. Nice work I look forward to seeing more of you work in the future

As always,
Wolf

Hi Pineapple321 I love this poem, because you put a lot of thought into it. This poem was very interesting to read, and I love the effort you put into it. I love the vocabulary and the amount you put. Keep up the great work because your peaces of work are very nice to read.