Here as requested. You've already got two pretty good reviews, so I will see what I can say on top of that. You wanted feedback on your tone, setting, character and background if I'm not mistaken. So I'm going to do exactly that.
The title is very interesting, reminds me a bit of the opening line in 1984. Would you mind explaining to me why it’s called that?
The setting of the story to be honest is rather vague; I didn’t get very much from it. There wasn’t a lot of context to base it on; you have a very short interview written simply for the sake of telling us that information. Or more precisely,
If living without knowing why you are living is agony, doesn’t it mean that this pain is the payment you have to make to live? To me, that is cruel. I think that a reason to live is only required for someone… Who wants it.
What I’ve quoted from your story, the entire interview is built up for that climax a philosophical exploration of life. Now, don’t get me wrong. I adore philosophy to death and back (by the way, if you ever want to discuss philosophy, chat me up.) but in writing, you can’t just dump it onto the page. You need context to back it up. The person being interviewed is an office worker; he doesn’t seem to be an ordinary office worker? Where is he working at, is a documentary well why is the documentary on him? Why is he so special? Under what circumstances does the interview take place? The lack of background information makes it hard for me to visualize both characters clearly, and the duration of the interview also strikes me as unrealistic. He just wanted to ask that one question? Most of the time, documentary details someone’s entire life, so if he’s only asking that one question I think you should expand on why he’s just asking that one question.
Though if I had to take my guess, it paints a picture that it’s set somewhat into the future; it’s not the present but we don’t know exactly when in the future. Have you read The Handmaid’s Tale, the setting resembles that slightly but more sci-fi ish.
Onto the characters, they’re both very intriguing characters granted. Intriguing but totally undeveloped characters, I’m sorry to be blunt but there is nothing in there that tells me about who they are, or what their personality is like. The office worker gives off the vibe that he is one who ponders about life a lot, and someone who believes that life should be lived to its fullest potential but at the same time. He sounds like one hell of a pessimist. But I don’t why he is like that; I want to know the psychology behind his reasoning that’s what makes a character realistic. Onto the man itself, I have to say that the ending was rather unexpected. He goes in for an interview, walks out, and kills himself.
So…that was pretty abrupt. Even though he intended the killing, it still comes off as something that’s rather disjointed from the rest of the story and frankly I’m not sure how that serves as the ending to this story. If he was affected by what the office worker said, then he didn’t show any signs of it. It’s not a bad ending, but it’s not a good ending either. If you worked on developing idea a bit more, then perhaps it’d be a good ending.
As for tone, I’m guessing you’re settling for more of a post-modernish, mystery tone. In that case, you’ve achieved it. There’s a very strong sense of suspense and mystery that permeates throughout the story, your description is very nice in the second half of the story. A very steady, almost Kafka-like sort of voice, that being said it would be nice if you spend some time describing the man’s inner emotions to the earlier meeting as well.
Hm, the feeling I got whilst finishing this story was a mixed between, well that was an interesting read really got me thinking about what happened. And prompted several philosophical thoughts into my head, on the other hand I was going. ‘Ok, nice story but what’s with that ending. That was totally random, and I wish they expanded the interview more.’ So, you’ve got a rather unique idea there but it does need some tweaking. If you have any questions regarding this review, please feel free to ask me.
-Flite
Points: 561
Reviews: 476
Donate