Warning: This work has been rated 16+ for language, violence, and mature content.
REDACTED
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Hello, rhia here to review.
I'll focus on nitpicks, grammar, and sentence correction first, as I read through this.
First off, what exactly is a "nerdy scent"? You need to use descriptions that your reader can understand. I can't visualize anything from a "nerdy scent", because it doesn't really make sense. I'd use a better adjective here. Even if he is nerdy, scent isn't the best sense to alert readers to that. ANd just in case you hadn't already figured it out, you misspelled "scent", it isn't sent.
Very redundant. I recommend cutting one of those out.
I would add a comma after "darling", and a comma after "said".
Youdo know that opaque means not transparent, right? It means it's solid, you can't see through it.
These don't need to be seperate.
The dad in the boat has a very sudden death. There was absolutely no build-up or context. I get that it's a short story, but still, it needs something more to it than that.
Umm, I'd ssay that that was a bit of an over-reaction on her part. Y'know, since their stranded and she's dealing w/ a girl who's dad just died. Try to make it more realistic.
I don't know what you were trying to say here, but it doesn't make sense. It's probably just a typo of a word or two , but for right now, the meaning is lost. Double check that bit.
Alright, overall, this has a lot of discontinuities in the plot, and the dialogue is very stiff. I caught myself saying aloud "What?!?" more than once, because so many things that happened were so sudden and random and just confusing. And were they in a boat, or a plane? Cause first a boat capsized, then Jack said the plane wrecked, and I'm just confused. I would suggest some rewriting for sure.
Yea, this story is shit. I should probably delete it.
No, I wouldn't say that, it just could use editing and such.
No, i'm saying it.
This part was absolutely has great detailing!!
''She felt the water rush around her body as the boat sunk in to the jaws of the South Pacific Ocean." Pictured it so well in my head.
The plot is crazy, very dramatic and omg depressing.
Your story is full dialogue and I disagree it needs all that, sorry. I believe showing than dialogue is more important.
I think there can be more detailing on the scene of this incident:
"Before Jack could reply there was a huge tremor and an explosion. "
What exactly is a nerdy scent?
1. sent-should be scent
2. He said kissing the top of {your} head.- it should be {her} head.
3. I thought they were on a boat, not a plane. That part seems to be unclear. Because their on boat and than it explodes and its falling apart and when she wakes up they tell her it was a plane crash?
Omg Jack's a fucking whore! lol omg he kissed Ali to make her stay and than Sarah forgives him? Oh no Sarah, were going to have some problems. I bet Jack does that often!
When I read that part I got so angry, she's so gullible and naïve and she's like every teen. Inlove and dumb.
Great dramatic plot, I was intrigued.
Yo, thanks for the review. Yea my punctuation is sucky and I wrote this about a year or two ago. So I'll probably go and rewrite it at some later date.
for a two or so old, it's not bad.
Hey, Huda here for a review.
I'm making pointers so that it may be easy to understand. The story, in general, was good but there are a few errors I would like to highlight:
1) In the first paragraph's line 5, there should be a comma after after shut.
2) 'Ali nodded and Sarah grabbed the one he was holding, he through one over to Ali'. This is what you've written. Here, you've written wrong word, it must me threw not through.
3) They are many punctuation errors in your writing.
4) I really wonder why you've made too many paragraphs. If we take a closer look, we find that you have written merely two or three sentences as a paragraph and then again you've started a new one. This breaks the flow a lot, consider fixing it.
4) Instead of describing a person in sex,age and appearance order, try to write anything special about them. Like you can describe that the girl had a pointy nose or whatsoever, instead of penning down her whole physical appearance.
5) In my view, you have confused your readers in an attempt of twisting your plot.
6) The events in your story seem hushed. Take your time to describe every event appropriately so that the reader does not think that you're overloading the story with events without giving them a proper space in story.
Lastly, I would appreciate your attempt. I mean it was much better than mine's. The words you've used are good and enhance the beauty of this piece of writing. This story shows that you do have skills to write and a very good grasp on words, all you need is a bit of polishing before you shine. I hope that my review helps you. Don't get disappointed because unless you are not aware of where you lack, you cannot achieve success. Keep writing! I'l surely be reading your next stories.
Yo, thanks for the review. Yea my punctuation is sucky and I wrote this about a year or two ago, I'll work on losing some dialogue and fixing the flow when I get around to it.
Cheers, Tigga