18+ Language

The Same Old Song (formerly Eight Reasons Why I Kissed Hayden Beaufort) - Chapter 1

Warning: This work has been rated 18+ for language.

CHAPTER ONE
Eugene seemed very impressed with his new haircut.
Me, not so much.
“Whaddya think?” he asked, as he jogged up to our usual morning meeting spot near the fire hydrant by the school gates. He pointed at his head and wiggled his eyebrows. That eyebrow wiggle was constantly making girls swoon, but I was immune from long exposure.
“Honestly?”
“Of course.”
“Well, frankly I think you look like a bit of a tosser.”
“Oh.” Eugene’s face fell.
“Hey, you said I should be honest,” I said, trying to tell if he was genuinely hurt. Eugene exuded a perfected laissez faire attitude, but considering the fact that he’d had an almost shoulder-length mop of hair ever since the end of primary school, his new, much shorter haircut that he had gotten over the weekend would likely be a touchy subject for a while. Much like the short-lived emo fringe he had in year seven.
“Yeah, but…” He grimaced. “You weren’t supposed to be like, actually honest. Like, the truth but in the nicest possible way.”
It was the emo fringe all over again.
“Would you be offended if I said that was the nicest version of the truth?” I teased, trying to reconcile the image of my friend that existed in my head with the one that stood before me. For a guy with such a dorky name, Eugene had always been pretty rock ‘n’ roll – unkempt and loutish, with a veritable aura of cool – but sometimes his decision-making ability left something to be desired. Like now.
“Lena,” he whined, and threw himself back against the school fence, and overly pained expression on his face. “So cruel.”
“Pfft,” I scoffed, punching him on the shoulder. “In my defense, I said you looked like a bit of a tosser. Not a total one.”
“You’re so supportive.”
“I try.”
“But seriously, it can’t be that bad, can it?” He frowned, subconsciously running a hand up to fix his hair, as though he could change how I felt about it by ruffling it. And it wasn’t the haircut itself that was the problem really, more the fact that it made him look like every other guy in the school. It wasn’t a bad haircut - Eugene just wasn’t a short back and sides kind of guy.
“Nah, totally dapper,” I said, and reached up to mess up his fringe.
He pulled a face and batted my hands away, but a laugh slipped out of his lips. “Stop it!”
“Dude, what the fuck happened to you?” Eugene and I turned to see our friend Thomas striding down the footpath towards us. He was only a few metres away but his voice so loud we could have heard him a couple of kilometres away. “What’s with the hair - and crap, did you iron your pants?”
I’d been so transfixed by the change on top of Eugene’s head I hadn’t noticed that his uniform was looking positively respectable.
“So?” Eugene asked, straightening his school tie. His shirt was tucked in for the first time since we’d started high school, and his pants, for once, didn’t look like he’d picked them up from his floor. Even his tie looked like it had been done up tight enough to restrict his airways. With his brochure-perfect uniform and newly short hair, Eugene was going to give Mr Branwaite a heart attack when he walked into class.
With our matching Monday morning messy hair and hastily pulled off the washing line shirts, Thomas and I looked scruffy by comparison.
“So,” Thomas said, “you’re full of surprises.”
“Is there a girl you’re trying to impress?” I asked. It was pretty much a rule of the universe that Eugene had to spend an extended period of time making sure he looked as though he had spent as little time as possible on his appearance. I didn’t think he even knew what an iron was.
“Stop looking at me like that you two,” he said. He started walking towards the school gates. He called over his shoulder, “Come on, we’re gonna be late.”
“Late?” Thomas and I gasped. We started to follow Eugene, pushing past a gaggle of year eights who were walking in the opposite direction.
“Since when have you cared about being late?” I asked.
Eugene shrugged, as Thomas and I caught up to him. I exchanged a confused look with Thomas. It was reassuring to know that he was just as in the dark as I was.
The three of us walked in silence until we reached the lockers. Eugene opened his without looking at either of us, and starting taking his books out.
“You guys practising tonight?” I asked, desperate to break the silence. Whatever was behind Eugene’s new straight-laced student look, there was no way he was going to tell us when he was in this mood. He’d tell me what was going on later.
He always did.
Thomas groaned. “We were supposed to be.”
“What happened?”
“What do you think?” Thomas said. “Freddie flaked out on us again. Got shit on, apparently.”
Between us, Eugene slammed his locker closed.
“You good?” I asked.
“Why wouldn’t I be?” he replied, and stalked off towards homeroom. I watched his retreating back, stunned.
“I swear to God, I’m going to kill the kid someday,” Thomas grumbled. “Freddie, I mean.”
Freddie Atkins, the bane of Thomas and Eugene’s existence, was the drummer of the guy’s band, Pugnacious Dogma. They’d formed about a year ago, and were pretty good, no thanks to Freddie and his antics.
“What’s his excuse this time?”
“Hell if I know.” Thomas rolled his eyes and opened his locker. “Apparently he called Eugene last night and said he couldn’t make it. Excuses are beneath him.”
“Well, if I meet a decent drummer any time soon I’ll be sure to let you know.”
“Thanks pal.” Thomas smiled.
I opened my locker and threw my bag in, and grabbed my stuff as the warning bell rang. I waited for the electronic dong-dong-dong­ to become silent, then said to Thomas, “Guess we better be going. Wouldn’t want to be late, would we?”
.
I didn’t get to talk to Eugene again until recess. He was walking back to his locker from maths, books in hand when I caught up with him, and, judging from the absent expression on his face, it was clear he was deep in thought.
“Hey,” I said.
“Hi Lena,” he replied, without enthusiasm. He barely glanced at me as I fell in step with him.
“How was maths?” I asked. Usually, this question would be followed by an animated rant about Eugene’s maths teacher, and whatever interesting metaphors she’d come up with to try to teach the class quadratic equations. Often there were impersonations.
“Fine.”
Great.
“You know, I reckon the whole grungy rockstar aesthetic’s days are numbered,” I piped up. “You’ve got plenty of rock bands who dress nice but are still pretty cool.”
“Uh-huh,” Eugene said, possibly in agreement, possibly because he wasn’t really listening to me.
A moody Eugene wasn’t anything unusual. He wasn’t averse to a bit of teen angst, but he’d always been a communicative sort of moody - with me, anyway.
“You wanna come over to mine tonight?” I asked, trying a new topic. “Seeing as you guys don’t have practice?”
“Wish I could,” Eugene said with a grimace. He adjusted the books he was carrying. “Family’s over from Sydney. And, well, Mum overheard me talking to Freddie, when he called me about not making practice, y’know. So now I’ve been roped into a family dinner, and that’ll go from the time I get home until midnight, probably.”
“Sounds fun,” I said.
“Yeah,” he said, his voice barely perceptible. He readjusted his books again.
“You right with them?” I asked, nodding towards his school books.
“It’s fine.”
“Okay then.”
“Listen, Lena, I’ve got a dentist appointment after lunch. If Ms P gives us homework, could you let me know?”
If I’d been shocked when Eugene had stressed about being late this morning, it was nothing compared to hearing him worry about homework. Homework. Eugene was the kind of student who revelled in missing a class, and the getting out of homework that came with it.
I frowned. “Who are you and what have you done with Eugene?”
He opened his mouth to respond, when I heard my name being called from across the school yard.
I turned to see Chris Stephens, the year twelve who was in charge of the sound equipment at school concerts and assemblies. I was one of the few people he let help him out, and last I’d seen him he’d been talking about the lunch time concerts the music department were planning.
Usually, I enjoyed talking to Chris, but I wished he’d chosen a better time to find me.
“You got a moment, Lena?” Chris asked, jogging up to us. “Hey Eugene.”
“Hi Chris,” I replied, while Eugene just nodded.
“My arms are killing me,” Eugene said, gesturing towards his books, more, I suspected, for Chris’ benefit than my own. “I’ll catch you later.”
He walked off without another word, and I tried to listen to Chris as he talked about plans for getting his whole team of sound lackeys together to organise some school event that I was only vaguely aware of.
As I nodded and mumbled in all the right places in our mostly one sided conversation, I came to the conclusion that Eugene wasn’t going to explain why, over the course of the weekend, he’d turned into a perfect, short-haired student.
I was going to have to find out for myself.

Comments & reviews · 5
Note: You are not logged in, but you can still leave a comment or review. Before it shows up, a moderator will need to approve your comment (this is only a safeguard against spambots). Leave your email if you would like to be notified when your message is approved.

User avatar
BluesClues
Review

Splendid, a mystery. "The Case of Eugene's New 'Tude." I love the style--I feel like it's similar to the original (as far as I remember it) but it's evolved. It flows well and is easy to read, not to mention humorous!

Stella already touched on the punctuation, which I would worry about more later on anyway, but I have to disagree with her about Chris Stephens. Like, yes, okay, he's in charge of sound equipment and let's Lena help out, but she tells us right there that she "wished he'd chosen a better time to find me." Plus, considering Eugene's odd behavior and her current concern for him, I don't think it's at all odd that she would treat Chris as she does at the end of the chapter: barely listening to him. Actually, what surprised me a little was the fact she even turned her attention to him at all when she was so concerned about Eugene--not that he was going to tell her why he got his hair cut or anything, he's being really enigmatic about everything, but still. I was kind of like, "Not now, Chris, there's something going on with her boi," but she was like, "Sure, what's up?" albeit not really listening as Chris told her what was up.

Excited for part two! Ping me when you post it, please.

User avatar
Carlito
Review
Carlito wrote a review · Wed Jan 04, 2017 2:33 am

Helloooo! I totally remember this story and I'm really excited because I definitely recognized parts of this and my memory was refreshed a bit while reading this new chapter, but I don't remember what happened and why Eugene changed so I'll get to re-find out :D

I'll tell you right now that I'm not going to have a lot of constructive feedback about this. I remember thinking the first draft I read was pretty good and this is already better somehow.

Your characterization is just lovely. One chapter in and I feel like I already have such a strong sense of who your characters are. I absolutely loved how much attention you put on Eugene's hair. There was so much focus on hair in that first scene, and in most other stories that would be super dull and unimportant, but I thought it was so clever that you took such a mundane detail about someone and turned it into something so interesting and important. Our hair really does say a lot about us and I'm glad Eugene's friends notice and care about his sudden change in appearance.

I also really liked the way you did the dialogue. It felt natural and like a real conversation. I also liked that Eugene didn't talk in these long flowing sentences but the MC's internal monologue filled in the blanks to help show the reader that something is off with Eugene. Perfect execution of showing <3

I have two very small qualms.

1. Did you mention the MC's name and gender in this chapter because I don't remember you doing so. It's not a super big deal, I just like to know a little bit about the head I'm in. (It's a great head by the way!)

2. Some of the dialogue confused me. I'm sure I said this the last time I read this too :P I know it's just because you're from down under (I didn't make that up right) and I live in the middle of the US. I was never confused to the point of not being able to understand, but there were a few lines I had to read more than once to make sure I read it right, like:

“You wanna come over to mine tonight?”


Overall though, I think you've got a great start here. I love the subtle ways you introduced the characters and set up the conflict/mystery. Super good effort already, I'm sorry I don't have anything constructive to say. I have a feeling all of my reviews of this are going to just be me saying some variation of "you're great", so if you want me to keep reading you'll have that to look forward to :P But I would love to keep reading on as you post it! Remind me if I forget! And let me know if you have any questions or if you want feedback about something I didn't mention! :D

Thank you!
I think Lena's name pops up a couple of times, but it's probably buried in dialogue. It's one of those things that I find weird and awkward to include when it's in first person, something I've gotta work out how to do without constant name dropping ahaha.

User avatar
Apricity
Review

Hey Sarah, Apricity here for a review! Boy, it feels good to be seeing your work in the GR again. I've missed them, I don't think I followed the first draft but hey, better late than never right?

I really like the characters here, Stella has touched on introducing Chris already so I'll try and not repeat anything. Your dialogue, as usual is well done. I love how natural the flow with the just that enough amount of teenage slang, but it's not overdone.

However, something I noticed was the shift in mood from Eugene. Because at the start of the chapter, from the way he bantered with Lena I got the general feeling that he was feeling ok. I mean, sure he's upset about the way Lena commentated on his haircut but he was still pretty chill with it. But the shift in mood, I felt was too sudden. There was transition, where you moved onto Lena noticing his clothes and perhaps at that point. You could bring out some verbal or body language cues that something wasn't right with Eugene, apart from being told that his haircut kinda sucks.

That being said, I am really curious as to what's bothering Eugene at the moment.

Also, I could just be very pedantic about this. But after this particular line of dialogue

“You wanna come over to mine tonight?” I asked, trying a new topic. “Seeing as you guys don’t have practice?”


Eugene, have suddenly departed from his monosyllable replies to an actual reply! I don't know how Lena would feel, and I don't know if this was a frequent question she asks him. Do they have regular plans to meet at her house? But, Lena's lack of response to Eugene's reply here seems off. He's given a lot more information there that she could snag out and prompt further conversation. Maybe something about the family dinner, or ask him about practice? Granted, Eugene may not answer but hasn't Lena up till this point been trying to make conversation with him?

Other than these, I don't have much else to add. Hope I helped you a bit with this review and I look forward to reading future chapters! :)

-Apricity

User avatar
StellaThomas
Review

Hey, @TriSARAHtops! Do you know how excited I was to see this was a thing? Thank you so much for the tag!

Image

And then I started reading it and remembering all the reasons I loved this story in the first place, like gosh darn Freddie Atkins.

Image

Okay. Enough reaction gifs. (Was it enough reaction gifs? There may yet be more).

It was a delight to return to the story again, and of course I remember the reasons behind Eugene's transformation, but I really like that they're becoming a lot more front-and-centre this time around. I think it's going to pack way more of a punch whenever we find out why.

One thing - does he really have a dentist appointment? That also seems like a non-Eugene thing to worry about. Or is that code for something else?! It just seemed a bit random that Lena was like, amazed at all these other responsible things he was doing, but was just like "oh yeah, classic Eugene and his dental appointments". That just rang a bit odd to me. (Who knows? Maybe he needs extensive work on his teeth and this is a regular occurrence!)

Okay. To business. I just have a few small points for you.

#1 is a punctuation thing - before a name, in dialogue, there should be a comma.

So like "Hi Lena" should be "Hi, Lena." It also applies to addressing people, like when he says "Thanks pal" it should be, "Thanks, pal." There's another - "Hi Chris" should be "Hi, Chris." I don't know why it is that way, because I know we don't speak or sound the comma the way it makes the sentence look, but that's just the way it is. So remember, comma before/after a name in dialogue (that also means that if you're addressing someone - "Lena, I think" is correct rather than "Lena I think"). Make sense? Perfect!

The next thing is a small note that I felt like the description of Eugene's haircut and the change that it is from his usual mop should have come earlier on. Like, we have a whole chapter concerning his hair but at first all we get is "short" and later that it's short back and sides, but is it a buzzcut or is it a hipster short-back-and-sides-but-still-really-long-in-the-middle? I feel like for such an important detail of the story, we need more description, and we need it earlier on in proceedings - there's a lot of dialogue before we even really get to the hair - in fact the first paragraph of description is about his as-yet-unchanged eyebrows. So I'd change that.

Also, considering Eugene has family dinner from end of school until midnight, when's he fitting in all this homework he's planning on doing?! Not a big deal, I was just surprised that Lena didn't get a jibe in about it xD (I know I would have!)

Finally, poor Chris Stephens gets off to a bad start here. I realise he's probably only a secondary character, but if it's such a privilege for Lena to handle the sound equipment, you'd think she'd at least be trying to listen, despite being completely distracted by Eugene's personality shift. Instead, he starts off as a little bit interesting and then seems to take a total nosedive. As well, originally you mention lunchtime concerts, and then he's talking about 'some school event I was only vaguely aware of' - so he actually declines very rapidly indeed. It just seems off-balance is all, rather than I have a vested interest in his character or anything!

Seriously though, I'm very excited to see the changes you'll be making to this story, and can't wait to read part two!

Hope I helped, drop me a note if you need anything!

-Stella x

Thank you!! Yeah, I was trying to work out how to balance the Chris thing. Mostly because he barged his way into the story (I never planned on him existing until right as I was writing his entrance) so I'm still trying to figure out his importance/relationship with Lena.
Also there is never enough reaction gifs XD

User avatar
Apricity
Comment

if I don't review this in 2 days, please poke me



If I see an American in real life or a kiwi in a blockbuster, it feels surreal and weird, and like a funny trip.
— SirenCymbaline the Kiwi