Decision of Change, Pt. 5

by TimmyJake

Published May 26, 2014

In A historical fiction.

PreviousNext

Ireland wasn’t quite what he had expected. John was rather disappointed, actually. England was filled with commoners as well, but they still held a certain dignity—well most of them, anyway. In this country, a land that seemed to hold nothing but commoners, he hadn’t seen one well-dressed person. Not one man or woman who at least hinted at Irish royalty.

The one thing his father hadn’t told him—something he hoped he had known—was the environment and the culture of the Irish. Entirely unexpected.

The deep ruts in the road from wagons, putting along the dusty trail. Mounds alongside the road acted as fences, initially made from blocks of stone, but had been gradually formed round by dirt and the decay of time.

And the rolling hills. Sloping pastures covered in lush grass went out into the horizon, stretching out as far as he could see. The few lone trees that dared to show their presence on the Irish’ precious pastures stretched up and out, spreading an ample shade for cattle.

And then there was the smell; that ever present stench of cow that hung in their air. Those noisy animals that left such wreckage behind them. And the bulls—they were the worst part of Ireland in his opinion.

It was all the peasants could do to keep them from attacking John while he rode up to the castle. His soldiers chuckled behind his back and whispered that the bulls had a good judgment of character.

His first impulse was to turn around and exchange biting words with the soldier who voiced that opinion. To tell him that he was the one who was a poor judge of character. Perhaps he would punish him as well, to make him regret the jest.

But he bit his tongue and remained silent. After all, what would it really do? His soldiers already despised him as it was. Anything more might make them doubt their loyalties.

What was he, really?

He was a prince of England. One among many. If he was at home, where the power of England lay, his men would have more reason to follow him without question. But here in Ireland, so far from home, the fear of punishment—the fear of execution—seemed very distant.

He even felt that way. Separated from his homeland, detached from everything he had ever known. The feeling that he would fail seemed less in the forefront of his mind, since his father wasn’t watching his every movement, as if waiting for him to fail.

He hated being taught—as if he was a small child—things he already knew. Having old lessons reiterated each day. At least in Ireland, he was far away from that. Away from his father’s sharp gaze. His critiquing voice.

The weather began to turn sour and the wind whipped through him, blowing his cloak about. He hugged it closer to him. Confound everything! Even the wind seemed to show its dislike.

He could see the Irish chiefs awaiting him at the end of the causeway. They looked nervous—pulling at their long, silly beards and adjusting their old-fashioned cloaks unceasingly. But who wouldn’t be?

How did they know what John was like? What his character was like? No doubt they were expecting a strong Norman overlord, someone who would protect them from invaders and govern them fairly… Well, he would try his hardest to govern them well, but he was human… And more than that, he was John.

There were a few complications.

Something inside told him that there would be complications. That he would fail yet again. That he did everything wrong, this would be no different. That he was a terrible leader, and wouldn’t know what to do.

He wanted to push those feelings aside. To convince himself that John can do things right. But he couldn’t shake them.

The castle doors opened and the Irish went inside, alongside a few English that stood alongside them. But the door remained open. Was that their way of welcoming him? To say, the door’s open. Make yourself at home.

What hospitality.

Comments & reviews · 2
User avatar
GoldFlame
Review
GoldFlame wrote a review Review · May 27, 2014

Back again! :D

Ooh, awesome title.

The narrator's voice's been fluctuating throughout the novel. From what I've observed, you're having trouble solidifying it, although you shouldn't, really. You're a natural at fleshing out characters. I think you've achieved the point where you're able to slip in and out of John's skin easily; and I'll confess, things roll smoother without the excessive italics, the sarcasm, the snide comments. There's the hint here and there, but it's so subtle it meshes with the atmosphere. I'm also admiring how John expressed his opinions: "He hated being taught—as if he was a small child—things he already knew. Having old lessons reiterated each day." Using narrative instead of scene.

But I think the sentence structure lent the most. The fragments: broken at prepositions, they're like line breaks in a poem. The repetition: you executed it flawlessly. The rhetorical questions: they accented his doubt.

Technical aside, I love the internal debate going on. It's always fun watching how characters change. Maybe it's me, but John's a difficult case. He's scornful and pessimistic, a lot like Marvin the Paranoid Android, although less depressed, hopefully. You'll need a slow transition.

Without doubt, this is my favorite chapter. I loved it all-around. It isn't just solid; it's fluent. It reads exactly like a published work. And the contractions—perfect. I know that's a random comment, but really, they were perfect. You can spot an inexperienced writer by how they handle contractions, so looking at this, you're very experienced.

—well most of them, anyway.


There should be a comma after "well." I'd give you technical terms to justify this, but I'll just end it at "insert a comma wherever you hear a pause."

The deep ruts in the road from wagons, putting along the dusty trail.


This sentence sounds a little chunky. I think there're a few forgotten words in there. Most likely a mistake, so I won't suggest any corrections.

initially made from blocks of stone, but had been gradually formed round by dirt and the decay of time.


Even if they're rounded, they're still blocks of stone. I think you're referring more to the contour: "initially blocks."

And then there was the smell; that ever present stench of cow that hung in their air.


The clause on the left is dependent, so the semicolon's being underworked. Semicolons' sole purposes are connecting independent clauses and separating items in complex lists. In other words, it should be exchanged for a colon.

His soldiers chuckled behind his back and whispered that the bulls had a good judgment of character.


So here it's indicated that multiple soldiers were whispering ...

His first impulse was to turn around and exchange biting words with the soldier who voiced that opinion.


... and here it's indicated that only one was. That aside, I love this part. It does a fine job of describing John's personality without describing it.

His critiquing voice.


"His critical voice" flows a little better here. A voice can't really critique things; a person, however, can.

Keep it up! Looking forward to more! It's refreshing reading a piece without dialogue. :D

Ooh. Thank you! That sentence DID read wrong. I will work on fixing it up. :D
This one took the longest to post because I didn't know what to do... I had two pages done, and I didn't know what to do next... I figured it out. :D
As usual, thank you sooo much for your nitpicks. I really appreciate them. :D It helps me make fewer mistakes next time!

No problem! ^_^

User avatar
Deanie
Review
Deanie wrote a review Review · May 26, 2014

Heya Timmy!

You know that lovely er, shiny review I promised? It might be a little shorter than expected as well... this chapter was just too good. You had such brilliant descriptions of the setting and gave a bit of a taste to what it is like living in Ireland during those times. Really, there is nothing to criticize there, and since this stole away for most of the chapter, what can I say?

Prince John is really have a change in character, trying to bite back his snapping out comments he wishes to make. But we still know he is thinking them and also the end of the chapter there shows he is still changing out loud, but just the same person as ever inside for now. Good job on managing to show that.

castle was even more impressive as he walked through the roads leading up to it.


I really doubt it is possible to walk through roads. Maybe along would be a better word to use here?

Sloping pastures covered in lush grass went out into the horizon, stretching out as far as he could see. The few lone trees that dared to show their presence on the Irish’ precious pastures stretched up and out, spreading an ample shade for cattle.


You've got three out's in this paragraph. The first can stay, the second can simply be completely cut and the last one can be there as well. Two when well spaced out isn't too repetitive.

Also, he is commenting on how rubbish this country Ireland is, as well as weird. But how does he feel knowing his dad has left the worst bit for him, a country that is as hardworking and feeling severely upset about how their country is going now. He is going to have to work on that as well as deal with the fact her was cut the worst slice. I wonder what he is thinks of that!

I would've liked to the scenery admirations cut up a bit with dialogue to make it seem less samey and just admiring the country, but still contributes to the plot or getting to know some of the characters...

I am going to sleep now because I am exhausted. Petty as this was, I hope it helps!

Deanie x

Ohhhh, Livvy. you work yourself too hard. :P
Thank you for the amazing review. I will work on your edits. Next one will have dialogue. Mesa promise. :D

Deanie replied · May 27, 2014

Says the one who has been reviewing allll my stuff lately xD



“And how shall I think of you?' He considered a moment and then laughed. 'Think of me with my nose in a book!”
— Susanna Clarke, Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell