Hi there, TheDepressedCat! I'm here to review your piece. Since this is the first review you're receiving from me, I'll give you a quick rundown on how my style of reviewing works. I start off with a section where I comment on individual lines and/or paragraphs of your story, and end with a section where I give my overall thoughts on the piece. If you're not looking for reactions or nitpicks, it might be best to skip to the ending section instead.
I woke up in my bed that day. The day everything went wrong, and stayed that way.
That was two years ago.
Great hook! The combination of the story's title and those first three lines really have me curious to see just what's going to go wrong.
I said good morning to my sister, which I assumed was there in the room with me, but she didn't answer. It's not that she wasn't there, no, rather the fact that she was lying on the floor, a hole in her heart, a knife beside her, and blood splattered all over her clothes and the floor. Her light brown hair was lying on the floor, full of blood, and her green eyes was staring distantly at the ceiling.
Oh no! I love how you add the action in right away, but I do have to feel bad for our poor protagonist - no one ever deserves to wake up to seeing their family dead on the ground.
I stood there for two days straight, not eating, not sleeping, hardly blinking.
I'm not sure this is medically possible, so you probably should do some research to check if it is. I'd highly suggest asking @StellaThomas over in The Character Clinic thread, since she's one of the people with the most medical expertise on the site.
Then, she stopped, her mind making a connection, a connection which was going to follow me forever. She came downstairs.
"You killed her. You killed her. YOU KILLED YOUR SISTER."
Oh, jeez. Poor protagonist! I definitely think her reaction to her sister's death can be explained through shock, but it doesn't seem like her mom would agree with that assessment.
Then, as a final goodbye, I kissed her on the cheek, whispering into her ear that I love her.
It makes me so sad to see how quickly everything has gone downhill for the protagonist. <3 She's still struggling to deal with her sister's death, and now she's suddenly on the run. I definitely don't envy her!
The story has an interesting premise, but there's just a few little things that you need to tweak for it to be entirely realistic. I also have a question or two, so I'd love to find out the answers so I can give you more thoughts on the chapter.
Why is the protagonist living on her own with her sister? You mention that her brother is barely fifteen and is two years younger than her, which implies that she's either seventeen/eighteen. Is there a reason why she wouldn't still be living with her mom, since most teenagers that age still live with parents or guardians?
Also, I felt like the mom jumped to conclusions a little too quickly. There's no reason for her to think that the protagonist is the murderer without seeing the body, and the call to her mom came across as someone in desperate need of help trying to alert a family member to an emergency while still being in shock. If you want to make the scene more realistic, add some more details to explain it - maybe her clothes are covered in her sister's blood, maybe she found the murder weapon and has it out on the counter, or maybe even that she's suspicious that she didn't call 911 before calling her.
Whatever you chose, there's a lot of options to elaborate, and using some or all of them will make your story stronger as a whole. <3
But, besides those critiques, I really liked the beginning of this story! It sounds like it has the potential to be a really great thriller, with the protagonist trying to evade the law, her family and her sister's killer(s) as she tries to track them down and clear her name.
Good luck on your future chapters, and let me know if anything in this chapter didn't make sense!
Points: 1234
Reviews: 590
Donate