Hi there! Lim here with a short review.
Before I get into the review, just wanted to make a note: I’ve bumped your work up to 16+ because it contains acts of violence, which have to be at least 16+ even with the ‘Violence’ tag, according to YWS Content Guidelines. Now on to reviewing!
General Impressions
The story is definitely very mysterious. The lack of character names or many identifying details makes it hard to tell who is who, and I think that might be part of the ‘mystery’ of this mystery story. Both characters’ states of mind are shown in the style, so it feels kind of stream-of-conscious-like. I kind of sympathised more with the person in the first and last sections (and I think they’re the same person) because they seem to have reacted violently in fear.
I interpreted it like this: there is the driver of the red car, and the killer. The killer is the one who wakes up in the second scene and he somehow causes the red car’s driver to crash. The killer mistakenly thinks said driver is dead and walks away. The driver is not dead and follows him. Now here I’m not sure if the driver finds out about the killer’s previous victims or is angry that the killer made him crash + left him for dead. But my theory is that it’s the driver who kills the man in his house.
Glows – What I liked
I liked how a lot of the descriptions create this visceral, scary feeling. For instance, “burnt god” seems to be a figurative expression of how much power this person has over the man in that moment, when earlier the man was the one who was in charge.
I also like the way you use punctuation to convey the character’s emotions and fragmented thoughts.
Like a rusty knife dug deep into his canals. So strong, so powerful.
^ For example, these aren’t punctuated like conventional sentences, but the punctuation marks good places to pause that convey the character’s thoughts. It makes him sound very overwhelmed by the smell of blood, which shows his horror at his situation and what he has done.
Another strength of this piece was that I could tell by the word choices that something was not quite right about the man in the second/ middle part.
The man walks towards the car, pulling the broken door off its hinges looking inside for anyone alive. There is no one alive in the car. Only broken, burnt products. So the man leaves, disappointed.
^ The fact that he calls the dead bodies (?) of people in the car accident “burnt products” is very telling.
Grows – Ideas to Consider
I wonder if the onomatopoeia, such as the “Tick . . . Tock . . .” in the beginning, is really needed to convey the atmosphere. I personally didn’t feel like it added a lot to the descriptions. The clock ticking example also initially made me think of a slow ticking of the clock because of the “…” in between – but I then realised the next sentence is about how he feels like time is passing quickly instead.
that's right, he was at the new mall that opened up, hoping to find someone of suitable looks.
^ I wonder why the appearance of his victim matters to him, if what he does is cut them up? I interpreted the “meat” paragraph as being about that anyway, so sorry if I’ve got this wrong ^^’ And he didn’t seem to focus much on that after those few lines in the beginning, so I kind of feel like it doesn’t need to be there to understand the story.
Something else to think about might be paragraphing. Having a lot of thoughts be in one paragraph can help convey a character’s rushing mind. At the same time though, I felt the effect was weakened since most of the paragraphs here are fairly long. I also kind of found myself wishing that new actions would be introduced in a new paragraph, for example, between the killer calling a number and the “soft voice” coming in – I thought that could have been a good place to start the next paragraph.
Overall
I thought this was an interesting piece that did some experimenting with style. I liked the narration – I thought it was a unique and fitting way to tell this story. My main suggestion for revision or future stories would be to think about paragraphing (and also maybe go lighter on onomatopoeia).
Hope this helped – let me know if you’d like more specific feedback!
-Lim

Points: 24142
Reviews: 459
Donate