z
  • Home

Young Writers Society



ingrained in my rainbow blood

by Mageheart


ingrained in my rainbow blood

the beginnings of a revolution
got its victory in a
muggy kitchen
when my mother told me
that the supreme court
had just decided
that there was no difference
between queer rights
and human rights.

she told me of
a legal theory
that had already been
ingrained in my
rainbow blood.

and though my lips
remained closed,
the pitiful whimper in
my trembling chest
had become a
majestic lion’s roar.


Is this a review?


  

Comments



User avatar
43 Reviews

Points: 2406
Reviews: 43

Donate
Tue Jun 16, 2020 6:16 pm
View Likes
Cow wrote a review...



The title... MMM, that's some good stuff. It definitely got me intrigued! The moment I heard about that... I wanted to throw my phone. God, it pisses me off still thinking about it. It is so unbearably frustrating and just, why? The description is wonderful though, with the setting and what you are seeing making it simple yet so good at conveying what you are getting across to the reader.

I presume the last two ones are about the mother, perhaps yours, agreeing with these horrid laws that have been passed. I'm truly sorry. But you've got to have hope, you've got to fight back. Even if it's in small ways, like slowly moving furniture a few centimeters a day so that it's all off course and she continues to bump into it.

I hope the laws don't stay for long. I just can't believe it but at the same time, it's not surprising.

- Cow




Mageheart says...


Hi, Cow!

I'm not sure what law you're referring to here, but this poem was actually referring to the US Supreme Court's decision that federal workers can't be discriminated against because they're LGBTQ . Rereading my poem, I definitely see how it could be taken a different way if you're looking at with the context of a different ruling - so maybe I should try making the poem more uplifting?



Mageheart says...


Also, thank you for your review!



User avatar
100 Reviews

Points: 7
Reviews: 100

Donate
Mon Jun 15, 2020 7:50 pm
View Likes
Em16 wrote a review...



I love this piece! The title is particularly amazing; I love the imagery and meaning behind "rainbow blood". You do a good job walking the reader through the events of the poem, guiding them through what happened, and the development of the ideas and themes. I like that you place the reader in the "muggy kitchen". It starts out with a specific detail, in a familiar place (everyone has a kitchen), before launching off into complex ideas and perhaps unfamiliar ideas.
I also love the last stanza. The comparison of the "pitiful whimper" to "a majestic lion's roar" is brilliant. For me personally, it represented how a movement that used to be weak and underrepresented has now become powerful and legitimized. It's a feeling of freedom, and of claiming your greatness. It's also a great way to end the poem.
However, your second stanza didn't seem quite as impactful to me. The idea that the "legal theory had already been ingrained" in your rainbow blood seemed a little weird to me. Personally, I feel like legal theories are very separated from the body. I know you're trying to express the meeting point between the law and what you know is right, but it just felt like a strange way to express that. Is there another comparison you could use?
Overall, though, this was an amazing poem. It's short, but contains so much meaning and so much emotional impact in a few lines.




Mageheart says...


Hi, Em16! Thank you so much for your review. The legal theory line definitely feels weaker than the rest of the poem now that I haven't touched it for a month, so I'll work on coming up with another comparison to put there. :)



User avatar
583 Reviews

Points: 34856
Reviews: 583

Donate
Mon Jun 15, 2020 7:37 pm
View Likes
Atticus wrote a review...



Hi there Mage! Tuck here to review your poem.

There are some really powerful lines here, largely because it's clear that this poem stems from a very personal place. I think my favorite chunk of lines is "The supreme court / had just decided / that there was no difference / between queer rights / and human rights" because this is a very concise and simple way to describe the importance of this victory for queer rights. It also emphasizes the importance of queer rights because they are human rights -- it makes a statement in a very subtle and factual way.

One nitpicks that stood out to me as a potential improvement is the line "had just decided / that there was no difference". I have a hunch that if you moved the "that" from the second line to the first line it would put more emphasis on the line "there was no difference", which is an important part of the poem more so than the decision. The first line, to me, is a transition from two important themes and should really set up the next few lines to have impact after impact. It's definitely a subtle thing, but I think it could create a better cadence and more appropriate emphasis.

Another nitpick is in the final stanza -- I think if you flipped the tense of "had became a / majestic lion's roar" to present tense (became a / majestic lion's roar") it could show the connection between this burst of self-confidence with the news the MC has just received. I understand that this is a very small point, but I hope it'll still have a decent impact and improve the poem, even subtly.

As a more major point, I feel that saying "the beginnings of a revolution" in the beginning of the poem is an inaccurate portrayal of the journey to acquire queer rights. This Supreme Court decision isn't the beginning of a revolution, in my eyes -- it's the result of decades of protests, battles, and revolts against the heteronormative status quo and aggressive homophobic ideology pushed on queer people. I see this more as a victory in the battle for equality -- certainly not the final victory, but a monumental one -- than the beginnings of a revolution. Of course, if you have a differing perspective that's fine, but I hope that gives you some food for thought in the way you approach this topic.

But beyond that, this poem is very powerful, very personal, and very important. It presents a valuable perspective and shows the importance of this landmark decision in a beautiful and concise way. I really enjoyed reading this and found it an adequate celebration of an important day in the fight for LGBTQ+ rights and equality. I hope some of my points were helpful to you, and if you have any questions please feel free to reach out!

Best,
Tuck




Mageheart says...


Hi, Tuck!

Let's pretend this reply isn't a month late.

Thank you so much for your review! The areas you pointed out that could use some more work were the same areas I was hesitant about when writing the poem, so it looks like my concern was well-placed. :P




It usually takes more than three weeks to prepare a good impromptu speech.
— Mark Twain