Hey, Artemis! I'm jumping right in here with only reading one of the other chapters, so I apologize if any of my feedback doesn't go together well with the rest of the story!
There seems to be a lack of description in all of this, which is shadowed over by most of the dialogue. Most of this seems like inner thoughts, which is a problem I share as well. Even though this is set in Camp Half-Blood, there still has to be some base descriptions of surroundings.
Even the smells of horse poop and lava were comforting.
While that's the kind of added description that is needed, the phrasing felt a little off. Perhaps replace 'smells' with 'stench'. (Also, what does the lava really smell like? While someone might be able to guess what horse poop smells like, lava isn't one of those day to day fragrances that someone might be able to familiarize it. Maybe tack on a funny thing about how it smelled and what it reminded Leia of, to give a larger point of reference.)
"Yeah. Why am I so jumpy?" she wondered as he put his firm hand on her shoulder.
While this is entirely personal preference, it's a little hard to differentiate actual thought between dialogue. Some people like using single quotation marks for thought, others like to use italics to make it stand out, and some don't use anything at all so it just blends in with the natural order of things. Just something to think about. Reading on, the thoughts are shown through italics, so consistency is key.
"Yes, I'm a centaur. My name is Chiron." the centaur calmly informed her, then turned to Leia's parents.
I might be entirely wrong here, but aren't Leia's parents Annabeth and Percy Jackson? Then why wouldn't she have not known Chiron? The centaur was a big part in both Percy and Annabeth's life and it's strange that she wouldn't have known him at all. I'm probably missing a big piece in the puzzle here, but that's something strange enough that I'd point it out. Also, from what I gather, hadn't she at least been at Camp Half-Blood long enough to be familiar with all of the scents across the ground? Chiron was the camp activities director last time I read the series, so it doesn't make all that much sense for him to not be seen around the grounds.
"He's immortal now, because he wanted to keep teaching demigods to become heroes." Annabeth quickly explained.
If Percy is only going to be referred to as "Leia's father" or "her father", wouldn't it make sense to refer to Annabeth in a similar manner?
Overall, this could use some improvements, but I liked it! The idea of the Percy Jackson crew having kids, while a bit over done, is sweet and always a nice story to read! (Hey, there's nothing new under the sun. ) I'm interested to see what type of creative twist there will be on this story. I absolutely live for fanfics. Anyway, I hope that you keep on writing!
~Adrian
Points: 0
Reviews: 324
Donate