E - Everyone

Bad Lights, Good Lights [Chapter 9.2]

PreviousNext

I made a Grace prayer, a a short prayer or thankful phrase said before or after eating.“Allahumma barik lana fima razaqtana waqina athaban-nar.” O Allah! Bless the food You have provided us and save us from the punishment of the hellfire. Slowly, I took a sip of the tea, savouring the hotness of it that fitted the cool morning. I had never liked coffee - there was just something about its bitterness that didn’t suit my taste. I took a bite on the roti canai, pleased with its moderate sweetness, before turning my attention to Damon. He was eating his nasi lemak, but his eyes were on me. Oh well. Couldn’t let the guy wait any longer.

“You have a point about the workers’ purpose of working here,” I said, putting on the measured voice I had used when competing in the debate team a couple of years ago, and remembering the way to start an argument. Damon talked about illegal workers, and I would focus on that. “They’re earning money from their family—I get it. But as you said, some of them come here illegally. That in itself is reason enough for us to doubt them—”

“That’s unfair,” Damon interrupted, putting on a frown. He didn’t realize by doing that he just broke the rule of debating. Well, official debating, but still. I’d allowed him to say his piece. “Despite your words, you’re indicating all of them come here illegally. Just because some of them do, it doesn’t mean they represent the entire community of foreign workers.”

Debate be damned.

I held up my hand, prompting him to stop, which he did. He resumed eating, eyes still on me, unaware of the fire he managed to trigger in me. I made a slight gesture as if beckoning him to get closer, and his head suddenly moved forward, an unknown force seemingly to push it to me. I leaned forward and hissed, “I don’t care if the foreign criminals—the ones who robbed us and ruined our lives—aren’t a reflection of others. I would do anything to stop them from making others suffer.”

I couldn’t forget how Father got angry to us. I couldn’t forget how he would blame us every time the topic about the robbery was brought up. I couldn’t.

I relaxed my hand, and his head pulled back, as if released by a mysterious grasp. We knew, however, that I had used my ability. He stared sharply at me with his black eyes, jaws clenching. “Despicable,” he whispered, gripping the spoon and fork tightly, and that was the end of our conversation.

We ate silently, and I felt like it took a long time. It forced me to ponder about my use of ability and words to Damon. I shouldn’t treat him like this. He didn’t know. He didn’t experience what I had experienced. If he did, he might not be as opposing as this. Perhaps, over time, he would understand. That the actions of some workers would affect how others view them as a whole. That the good deeds the rest displayed to us Malaysians would always be overshadowed by the crimes they made, because the crimes left a bigger implication to us.

I looked up from my food, wanting to apologize to him when I saw he was still staring at me sharply. My intend evaporated instantly, annoyed by how he viewed me. Damn that guy. Why must he bring the worst out of me?

I made another Grace prayer after I finished eating. “Alhamdulillah il-lathi at'amana wasaqana waja'alana Muslimeen.” Praise be to Allah Who has fed us and given us drink, and made us Muslims. Then, my phone buzzed. I fished it out from my pocket, and the screen showed there was a message from Sarah. Worried, I quickly tapped on it to view the message.

We’re done. Where r u?

I let out a sigh of relief; it seemed they were fine. I replied by giving her our location. A few seconds later, another message arrived.

Alright. We meet u there. Wait 4 us. xoxo

I put back my phone, and looked at Damon. I told him about the messages.

He didn’t say a word. His eyes were on somewhere else. Fine. If he wanted to be moody, so be it. I wasn’t here to be nice. I didn’t ask to be paired up with him. We were here just to find out the bad lights’ rendezvous, and that was all. As long as he maintained his cooperation, we were good. But damn it if a small part of me wondered why he cared about the foreign workers too much. He just seemed to be passionate on protecting them. What was his story? I remembered Sarah mentioned he was rejected as a prefect. Perhaps this side of him had something to do with it?

I shook my head, ridding the questions in my mind. I threw my attention to the road instead where more cars passed by. Saturday would be a busy day, what with students of primary and secondary school having their weekly holiday. The One Utama mall must have been crowded right now; it was a popular site for people to spend time with each other. I needed to go there too soon to buy novels I wanted to read. Tomorrow would be busier. I wondered if I had time to just relax and go wherever I wanted.

I drifted my thought to another path--the abduction Sarah’s mother had talked about. The general weirdness of it was disturbing. I meant, there’d be no way for someone to kidnap a girl in a car, not when the car itself was locked in the inside. Probably the girl herself left the car and went anywhere she wanted. But what made the police think it was an abduction, then? Probably the state the car was in. Probably it was messy inside, indicating there was a struggle between the girl and her kidnappers. In that case, shouldn’t people around be aware of it?

I shook my head. Too much to think. I really needed to clear my mind right now.

Unintentionally, I turned towards Damon. Damn it. Right now, I expected no one to be in front of me so that I didn’t have to focus on anyone.

He catched me looking at him. “What?” he asked harshly, his voice leaking irritation. That guy was intense.

“Nothing,” I said. Another thing I couldn’t help to wonder: could Damon be a pleasant guy? If he could, then there might be a side of him that wasn’t completely insufferable.

I would like it if Scarlet spoke up, spilling his wit, but he was quiet right now. Same went to Mauveine. They had to, or else someone might be frowning to us, confused by how there were more voices than people at our table. It was frustrating, though. Talking with Scarlet would be more reassuring than talking with Damon. At least with Scarlet, he didn’t try to argue with me passionately, making me uncomfortable. Damon didn’t care about me—he was so fierce with what he believed.

And Mauveine... well, that light had a sense of mockery. He pointed out Scarlet’s obedience to the royal lights, and how because of that, Flaxen lights despised Scarlet. He also talked about Scarlet being rebellious to Scarlet’s own creator. Those statements clearly offended Scarlet. And it wasn’t just that. He talked about Sunglow, the princess light, not opposing her brethren’s actions, and that royal lights acted like they were gods.

And yet Scarlet said his clan and Mauveine's had no problem with each other. That, while Mauveine shared some of Flaxen’s sentiments, he had the same goals with Scarlet... and what differentiated them was how they achieved their goals. This was interesting. I realized I needed to have a better understanding about the politics in the light world, and how they affected the relationship between the lights. Hmm, yes. This would be a necessary distraction to avoid me from being frustrated over someone’s attitude.

Comments & reviews · 3
Note: You are not logged in, but you can still leave a comment or review. Before it shows up, a moderator will need to approve your comment (this is only a safeguard against spambots). Leave your email if you would like to be notified when your message is approved.

User avatar
BluesClues
Review

I am frustrated over the narrator's attitude, frankly, but that's not why I'm here. First, some good stuff.

There was a decent mix of dialogue and prose for this chapter, so it read pretty easily and didn't feel too bogged down in description or too quick-fire in speech. Another note on your dialogue: I like that the characters don't overexplain things to each other. Also how you sometimes use a lack of speech rather than more words to show how tense things are or how people are feeling.

The only bit that gave me trouble was the three paragraphs or so at the end, when the narrator turns her (her? I haven't been reading along, so I'm not sure) thoughts toward the lights. Well, actually this first paragraph was okay.

I would like it if Scarlet spoke up, spilling his wit, but he was quiet right now. Same went to Mauveine. They had to, or else someone might be frowning to us, confused by how there were more voices than people at our table. It was frustrating, though. Talking with Scarlet would be more reassuring than talking with Damon. At least with Scarlet, he didn’t try to argue with me passionately, making me uncomfortable. Damon didn’t care about me—he was so fierce with what he believed.


(I find that last part admirable, myself. Damon interests me quite a bit, actually.)

Because in this section, the narrator's thinking how their company would give her some relief from Damon's. But from there she starts thinking more about the "politics in the light world," as she says. It sounds as though she's thinking of conversations she's had with the lights in previous chapters.

And Mauveine... well, that light had a sense of mockery. He pointed out Scarlet’s obedience to the royal lights, and how because of that, Flaxen lights despised Scarlet. He also talked about Scarlet being rebellious to Scarlet’s own creator... He talked about Sunglow, the princess light, not opposing her brethren’s actions, and that royal lights acted like they were gods.

And yet Scarlet said his clan and Mauveine's had no problem with each other. That, while Mauveine shared some of Flaxen’s sentiments, he had the same goals with Scarlet... and what differentiated them was how they achieved their goals...


If that's what's happening in these parts, I'd say try whittling them down to the narrator's thoughts about these things rather than rehashing them for the reader. Or give us more of a transition, like "my mind wandered back to the things Mauveine had said about xxx...."

Now, my other thought on this is that you could mean for this to be a conversation that's happening right now, deflecting the narrator's attention from Damon's argument about foreign workers. I don't really think that's what's happening, but it seems like a possibility. If that IS the case, I suggest dramatizing the dialogue rather than paraphrasing it, with a different transition. Like, "As if in response to my wishes, Scarlet piped up...."

I'm 90% sure this is actually her thinking about past conversations, but there are my two suggestions in case I'm incorrect.

The most interesting part of this chapter for me was this bit.

But damn it if a small part of me wondered why he cared about the foreign workers too much. He just seemed to be passionate on protecting them. What was his story? I remembered Sarah mentioned he was rejected as a prefect. Perhaps this side of him had something to do with it?


As I said, Damon interests me anyway. He's "fierce in his beliefs" and passionate about the issue of foreign workers. So when this part is mentioned, it arouses my curiosity. I hope the answer is something far more dark and secret and intriguing than "because he didn't get prefect."

User avatar
Mea
Review
Mea wrote a review · Sun Jun 26, 2016 11:29 pm

Wait, I show up on review day to find I haven't reviewed this already? What on earth is wrong with me...

I'm kind of ambivalent about this part - it just kind of feels like nothing happens in it. I feel like you could cut most of it and still be largely fine. You'd want to keep the debate, but after that I feel like, by and large, you could skip to the part where something actually happens. A fair bit of it felt like filler, especially the parts where Merah's attention was drifting.

I liked seeing more of the Muslim prayers - it makes it all feel more realistic, not to mention that it's interesting for those who (like myself) aren't too familiar with the Muslim religion.

I thought the little debate they had was definitely interesting, and I thought you did a good job of showing how emotion comes into these things. Because on the surface, Damon is right - most of the foreign workers aren't illegal or hurting anyone at all, but it's hard to see past that when you're being hurt by them. I think that's a really important difference between Merah's character and Damon's character that you showed well here.

I'm also glad she's going to investigate more into the light's politics, though I don't see why you couldn't have her start talking to Scarlet about it in this part. Regardless, I agree that that's important and interesting information we'll need.

Slowly, I took a sip of the tea, savouring the hotness of it

You can write this as "savouring its hotness" or "savouring its warmth." Both of those read better.

I took a bite on the roti canai

Should be "I took a bite of the roti canai." In general, I notice a lot of your errors are with prepositions, which I guess makes sense - they are kind of hard. Just watch out for them.

Another thing I couldn’t help to wonder: could Damon be a pleasant guy? If he could, then there might be a side of him that wasn’t completely insufferable.

This was just worded confusingly - pleasant and insufferable are kind of opposites, and I wasn't quite sure what you were trying to say.

And that's all I've got for this part! I know you're kind of re-working it now, and I might come back and review your new draft.

User avatar
Carlito
Review
Carlito wrote a review · Sun May 29, 2016 1:29 pm

Hello again! :D

Oh well. Couldn’t let the guy wait any longer.

I don't think you need this. It sounds a bit self-important or melodramatic, like Merah is setting this up as some big dramatic confrontation. That's not how this goes, and I don't think it's necessary.

He didn’t realize by doing that he just broke the rule of debating. Well, official debating, but still. I’d allowed him to say his piece.

I don't think you need this either. It makes the conversation seem more formal than it needs to be. This isn't a formal debate, it's two people talking. Trying to make it seem like something more than two people talking makes it too formal.

Debate be damned.

Same here. This isn't a debate. It's a conversation. You don't need this little line, just continue with the conversation.

I couldn’t forget how Father got angry to us. I couldn’t forget how he would blame us every time the topic about the robbery was brought up. I couldn’t.

"Father got angry with us."
Who is "us".
And expand this a bit more and give a little bit more of this internal monologue and thought process. What does her father's treatment have to do with her views of foreign workers? I feel like we're right on the edge of it and I can make an assumption, but I want her to process through that.

I relaxed my hand, and his head pulled back, as if released by a mysterious grasp. We knew, however, that I had used my ability.

Remind us what her ability is and explain how she used it here.

We ate silently, and I felt like it took a long time. It forced me to ponder about my use of ability and words to Damon. I shouldn’t treat him like this. He didn’t know.

I slashed that bit because it feels like it's setting up the thoughts and the internal monologue that's about to come. You don't need to set it up, just give us the thoughts :)

He didn’t say a word. His eyes were on somewhere else. Fine. If he wanted to be moody, so be it. I wasn’t here to be nice. I didn’t ask to be paired up with him. We were here just to find out the bad lights’ rendezvous, and that was all. As long as he maintained his cooperation, we were good. But damn it if a small part of me wondered why he cared about the foreign workers too much. He just seemed to be passionate on protecting them. What was his story? I remembered Sarah mentioned he was rejected as a prefect. Perhaps this side of him had something to do with it?

I mentioned this in the previous review and I'll say it again. Your showing of thoughts and Merah's internal monologue has gotten a lot better! I really liked this paragraph. I feel like I'm getting to know Merah and I'm understanding her more, which is so important and so awesome. So nice work! :D

The One Utama mall must have been crowded right now; it was a popular site for people to spend time with each other. I needed to go there too soon to buy novels I wanted to read. Tomorrow would be busier. I wondered if I had time to just relax and go wherever I wanted.

I'm not sure if you need this. It feels a bit strange that her mind is going here and she's thinking about going to the mall and having a relaxing time reading when she has a bunch of huge problems going on right now with this light situation and her brother falling for her friend and her issues with Damon.

Another thing I couldn’t help to wonder: could Damon be a pleasant guy? If he could, then there might be a side of him that wasn’t completely insufferable.

They're going to end up liking one another. There. I called it. :P

I would like it if Scarlet spoke up, spilling his wit, but he was quiet right now.

I didn't care for these last three paragraphs about the lights. It was a lot of information and it was hard for me to absorb, and to me, it distracted from the point of the chapter. It slows down the intensity and the natural progression. I would prefer her thoughts about the abduction be interrupted by Sarah and Imran showing up so we get things happening again.

Looking forward to reading more soon! I'm still very intrigued by your premise and this idea as a whole so I'm curious to see what is going to happen next! Let me know if you have any questions or if anything I said was confusing! :D



huh. didn't realize santa was a batman fan-
— Mageheart