Hello again! Have my 650th review!
I must say, your writing has improved leaps and bounds since you first started this story! Many of the things I mentioned in early chapters are no longer issues for me. Your writing is a lot stronger and I can tell you've settled into the plot and the characters a bit because it seems to flow more naturally as well. So nice work! I love when I see progressions like that!
On to the good stuff!
When we got back to the house, Father was waiting for us in the living room. He sat on the sofa, leaning his back against it with a cigarette hanging in his mouth. Irregular line of smoke spiraled upward. One of his arm was leaning on the sofa, and his eyes were fixed on the television. The screen showed Al-hijrah program, a channel based on Islam religion. It was his favourite channel nowadays.
I loved this opening paragraph. You set the scene really nicely with what the dad is doing and all of the little details to make the scene feel realistic. This also sets the tone nicely. The way he's sitting and what he's doing make me feel like bad things are coming.
I didn’t want to sit with him not only because I still had bitter feelings from the scolding he gave to me the other day, but also because I hated the pungent smell of the cigarette smoke. I had made Imran and myself vow not to smoke because it was unhealthy and didn’t make you attractive or mature at all. Some of the guys in my class smoked, and I never wanted to talk to them because of it.
And here we have a great internal monologue! This is perfect. You show her feelings towards her father and his actions and why she feels that way. Love it.
Imran was sitting beside him, watching the television.
Now Merah and Imran just got back. They just saw their father. I got the impression that Imran was standing with her but he's actually sitting. Since when was he sitting? While things are being described and Merah internally monologues, still show what Imran does, even if it's as simple as him taking a seat next to his father.
I sat at the sofa opposite to them, taking off my scarf, which wasn’t compulsory to wear in the house.
Love the little cultural detail here.
“Yes, Father?” I said, my voice came out slow. I didn’t make eye contact with him and fixed my eyes at the tiny bowl on the table between the sofas made to dump cigarette ashes.
Love the action and description you include with the dialogue!
“Tomorrow is holiday,”
"Tomorrow is a holiday,"
I knew where this was going. It was the time Father wouldn’t back down. He didn’t like people arguing with him, and I happened to always argue with him more than Imran. He didn’t like his daughter to be like that. He wanted me to be proper and obedient, but I wasn't. I just inherited his stubbornness. And it wasn’t like I didn’t want to help him washed the cars at all.
And here's another beautiful internal monologue! Ignore what I said earlier about maybe making this third person. Keep this first and make the earlier chapters like this!
“The plan Imran and I have is just once for all. After that, we’re not doing it again,”
The wording here is a bit funny. I think "The plan Imran and I have is just for one day." would sound better and you could leave it at that and not include the second sentence.
This was the part where I should say “please”, but it would give the power of decision in his hand.
Love this! I have a weakness for rebellious ladies
One little wording thing. I would say "but it would give him the power to decide, and I didn't want him to have that." I added the little part on the end about her not wanting that just to solidify that this is something she wants to avoid.
“I wouldn’t want to carry out the plan if it isn’t important, Father,”
"wasn't" instead of "isn't."
I really like the subtle contrast in how Imran and Merah try to sway their father to do what they want.
Am sure you’re going to regret it.”
Ominous!!
when he would go to the bitch’s shop.
The use of "bitch" gets repetitive, especially in a few paragraphs it's used a lot. Are there other ways she can refer to this woman just to change things up every now and then. I get that she doesn't like her, but I would prefer a bit of a broader vocabulary.
“You know how he has spent lesser time with us when he married that bitch.
Wording - "You know he's spent less time with us after he married that bitch."
Contractions help make dialogue sound more natural. (By the way, I think your dialogue has improved a lot too.)
He worked at day,
"He worked during the day"
Like swallowing a bitter medicine, it was hard to deny him. Unlike me, Saloma’s children were more abiding, although they still called Father as “uncle”. I closed my eyes and leaned my head to the sofa. I needed some rest. There was too much for me to think right now. I didn’t know how my search with Damon would turn out tomorrow. What was more, I didn’t want to think how Sarah and Imran would cooperate. Sarah with her flirtings, sure, but Imran? He might flirt back like he did before. That was troubling.
Love this internal monologue and how you gently transitioned into the next topic of conversation. Great!!
I’m learning on getting used to her attitude.
"I'm learning to get used to her attitude."
Imran’s attention was already in the television. The channel was now changed to Star World, and he was watching Devious Maids. Weirdly enough, he liked watching all these stupid dramas. His favourite was UnREAL, for goodness sake.
I'm guessing these are real TV shows. I don't know if there's a rule about mentioning real TV shows (like copyright stuff). You wouldn't have to worry about that unless you intended on publication. However the other thing to consider is that the majority of your readers have never heard of or seen these shows. You could include the names for the cultural aspect, but it will be lost on many readers.
When I was in the room, Scarlet exited my body and floated on the bed. I followed him and sat on it, getting ready for what was going to happen.
I thought this transition was a bit weaker. I would like more internal monologue about what she plans on doing when she gets to her room.
The improvement is really amazing. You should be proud! I'm proud! I'm looking forward to reading on and seeing what's going to happen next! In the meantime, let me know if you have any questions or if anything I said was confusing!
Points: 32055
Reviews: 1162
Donate