Hello again! Okay, I skimmed over the chapters I reviewed for you way back when I think I'm all ready to move forward now. I skimmed over my review of 6.1 and how confused I was and while I'm still a bit confused, I think I liked 6.2 much better. Brace yourself, because I have a couple of huge (maybe crazy) suggestions for you for draft 2.
1. Maybe write the whole thing in third person.
Your third person writing feels a lot more natural to me than your first person writing. I'm not saying your first person is bad, but that it seems like third is easier for you. (Which if that's the case, that's totally fine!) I thought this flowed a lot better and felt more right to me. Now that I've seen both, the first person stuff almost feels like it's third person trying to be first person.
So. In the next draft you could get crazy and try writing the whole thing in third to see how it feels. You might find that it's easier and comes more naturally to you and you can tell the story easier that way. If you really want to keep Merah's part in first, that's fine too, but you're going to need a lot more voice and a lot more of her in it. This is a great article about first person writing and when to use it.
2. Maybe make the whole thing a multiple POV situation.
Even though I still don't remember who these characters are, I'm intrigued by their story and I find them interesting. I saw a comment you made on someone's review in 6.1 about how you felt the need to include his story. I think that's fine and that's great, but I think it'll be weird if his story only happens in one random chapter of third person and then you go back to first person Merah's story for the rest of the novel.
This might be a painful decision. If you think he's interesting enough to support his own story line, great. Make this a multiple POV situation. It's going to require a lot more work because you're going to have to write a bunch more of his scenes and weave him into the story, but it could end up being really cool. If you don't think he's interesting enough to support his own story line, then I would cut this entire chapter. And I know that's going to hurt because you like him, but sometimes painful things need to happen for the health of the novel. In the novel I'm working on right now, I'm writing the 4th draft and decided I need to cut two major story lines (it's a multiple POV thing) in order to be able to really develop the other story lines. It was sad, but I know it's making the novel better.
If you're on the fence, think about how he will end up impacting Merah. If he's going to somehow become a villain and end up fighting against Merah and the gang in some way, I think it would be really interesting to see his story unfold and develop alongside Merah's. If he's going to be on the good side but not necessarily working with Merah and the gang, it could still be interesting to follow his story and see how he helps (especially if eventually he teams up with Merah). If he's not really going to be part of the effort (either on the good side or the bad side) then I wouldn't give him his own story line and I would take the chapter out.
One other thing to consider if you go the multiple POV route is how you're going to execute each POV. There are no real rules here other than to be sure the reader can distinguish between the two POVs. You could easily have them both be in third. Merah could be in first (as long as she's still super voicey!) and he could be in third (I'm doing that with my novel). Or they could both be in first as long as they're both super voicey and the voices can be distinguished so you know who the scene belongs to.
That's a lot to think about and I hope I didn't rock your work too much! If you have any questions or you want to bounce any ideas off of me, let me know and go right ahead! Also, as I keep going with the story (and slowly get caught up) if there's anything I'm not mentioning that you want feedback about, let me know and I'll be sure to do that!
Points: 32055
Reviews: 1162
Donate