12+ Language

The last blow that broke my heart *edited*

It was a landscape heartbreak.

I loved you. Did you love me? I may never now, but I settled with I think so.

I was there for you when you were sick, when you were getting ready to go to the hospital for surgery..

You were never there for me..

A day after our one month anniversary, you say "I don't think we should continue this relationship"

Those words will forever be burned into my heart.

Your excuse was that you have to be in the hospital longer .. Or always "sick"

So I lay here broken, stoned, and in distress, whispering to myself  "where did I go wrong..?"

You told me be happy with someone else. Don't you get it?! No one else could love me like you, no one wants to be around me except you. I gave you my heart but you never gave me yours in return.

I thought you saved me, but you just brought me up to cloud nine and let go so I could fall to the cold worn cement that I have felt to many times before.. 

I told you everything, my exes, my dreams when I grow old, my secrets, my sorrow, I shared it all. You shared nothing but a nod and a few tears. 

I was an idiot to believe you.

Comments & reviews · 3
Note: You are not logged in, but you can still leave a comment or review. Before it shows up, a moderator will need to approve your comment (this is only a safeguard against spambots). Leave your email if you would like to be notified when your message is approved.

Hey there! *trumpets sounding* I have come to review!

So, since this is a poem, I guess I can just jump right into things, so here we go!

It was a landscape heartbreak.


I absolutely loved this line! It gives a different picture than any other heartbreak and it tells us that this is how you felt it was yours. However, throughout the rest of the poem you do not carry out this idea of a landscape, so we are left wondering how it was a landscape heartbreak.

I loved you. Did you love me? I may never now, but I settled with I think so.


Nitpick: "now" needs to be "know"
Also, You have an entire line that rhymes within itself. I would split this up since you have it rhyming, but also to give each part more emphasis.

I was there for you when you were sick, when you were getting ready to go to the hospital for surgery..


Nitpick: there is an extra period at the end of this line
Also, this line is very long and kind of disrupts the flow of the poem. If you split it up it might work better, or took certain words out so that it leaves us wondering. However, it is your choice and you don't have to listen to what I or anyone else suggests. Poems are works of art and art is interpretive so you can do whatever you want.

you say "I don't think we should continue this relationship"


Since you are talking about how he said this in the past, "say" needs to be "said" with a comma before the quote.

So I lay here broken, stoned, and in distress, whispering to myself "where did I go wrong..?"


I loved this line! I have only one nitpick for it, though: the two periods before the question mark can go away

Don't you get it?!


So here, your use of punctuation is interesting, but the reader would get the impression of the exclamation point if you only used a question mark since that is how that particular question is usually asked and we already know that you are upset.

No one else could love me like you, no one wants to be around me except you. I gave you my heart but you never gave me yours in return.


This is one very, very long line. Since you are trying to get your point across, split the line up. It will give the reader more pause and emphasize your words better.

I thought you saved me, but you just brought me up to cloud nine and let go so I could fall to the cold worn cement that I have felt to many times before..


Again, this a very long line and I would split this up.
Nitpick: the extra period at the end of the sentence can go

I told you everything, my exes, my dreams when I grow old, my secrets, my sorrow, I shared it all. You shared nothing but a nod and a few tears.


In this line, I would split up each thing you told him about. It will make each thing more valuable and prominent.

And finally, your last line. It is a good ending, but I am not sure that it needs to be bolded. It makes us feel like you are yelling at us even though we did nothing wrong. If you just provided an extra space between the other ones and this one then it might be just fine.

Over all, your poem got your idea across with some wonderful thoughts, but it was a little bit jumpy. I did enjoy reading it and I hope you keep it up!

Happy Writing!

The extra periods are meant to be there, I put them there because I (at the time) wanted to say more but didn't know what to say. And for the long lines I felt like they were disruptive too I just didn't think I should chop it up but I will! Thanks so much tho ~The Written Girl

User avatar
FancyDragon
Review

This is very good. there are some weird words and phrases but over all you did a great job! I loved a few of your lines. i really liked this one here.

I thought you saved me, but you just brought me up to cloud nine and let go so I could fall to the cold worn cement that I have felt to many times before..

You can picture that some one making you feel invincible and amazing and them completely breaking you down. you can see feel and understand it.

I was there for you when you were sick, when you were getting ready to go to the hospital for surgery..

I like this line also.

You have an interesting rhyming thing going on here i like it it was cool to read. Keep up the good work!.

User avatar
Aley
Review
Aley wrote a review · Sat Dec 06, 2014 9:57 pm

Hey Written Girl 46

My name's Aley and I'm here to review your poem.

First off, I'd like to say that you don't have to apologize for what you want to put out there as a poem. We're here to help everyone improve.

About the poem. The content of the poem is rather scattered. At times, we have a very clear message about what's going on, but it's not that personal, and at other times, it's not so clear what's going on, but it is very personal. Personal is good, so my suggestions will be to help you shift away from impersonal, towards personal and perhaps it will be less cathartic to write, but I think it will be more cathartic to read.

Overall, the most personal line I see is "Your excuse was that you had to stay in the hospital longer, be happy with someone else." but there is a lack of clarity here because we don't know several things about what's going on. We come from this point of matrimonial vows almost with "Till the end" and then we go into a potential end, a hospital. What I'm confused about is how they ended up in the hospital, and how that's supposed to be affecting the relationship between the two characters. At this point, you as a writer, can decide whether you want to include more of the backstory, or less of it, but I'd like to know more about how things started going wrong for this poem to be clearer. Also, the end of that line "Be happy with someone else" feels out of place because there are two ways it can attach to the other side of the sentence. Either the excuse was that they had to stay in the hospital so they could be happy with someone else, or they had to stay in the hospital, so the narrator should go and be happy with someone else.

To clarify what you want, you could consider breaking it up into individual sentences, or putting it in quotation marks for the individual to say that to the narrator.

As you launch into the next point of the poem, the point where the narrator is talking to the individual specifically, and dramatically, I feel like you use a lot of lines that I've heard before "No one could love me like you" "you saved me" and so on, but I like this middle part, and think it has some good clarity to it, this part here: "no one wants to be around me except you" The reason I like this part is because that's not a typical thing in a romance/break up poem. It's a very lonely feeling that comes from another personal point. I want you to keep that, but I'd like you to consider cutting out the line before it so it reads "Don't you get it? No one wants to be around me except you." and there are a couple grammatical changes I made for the line too because if you have that particular line as it's own sentence, it's stronger, and "Don't you get it?" is a clear defined statement in itself, that no, the "you" does not get it, and that's what's breaking the relationship apart.

I also feel like from this point, you could go two different ways, You could make it a poem about loss, or a poem about this loss. The one way you could branch out to explain how the speaker feels that there is no one but this one individual who wants to be around them, perhaps adding a paragraph where they go through the loss of other people, and the rejection they've felt. You could then swing back around and recapture this moment by adding it on top, and use the rest of the poem.

Of course, these are just suggestions and critiques. You don't have to do anything. It is your choice 100%. My goal here is just to help you find another way you can take this poem and potentially write it again so you can decide what you want, what you wanted to say, and how you wanted to say it.

Personally, I like personal poems better, or at least poems that feel personal. They don't actually have to be about yourself as long as it feels like no one else could have said it like that. To me, that's important and in parts of this poem, it is spot on, in other parts, it's missing because romance is one of those cases where people have a playbook due to how frequently it's talked about and in what specific ways it is spoken about. I'd love to see you get away from that playbook more, and really explore different ways to say some more of these passages.

Also props for your first poem being a non-line paragraph form.
oh, and you have a typo.

I should have none you didn't mean it.

none should be known.

I'm not exactly sure why you have double periods in some places, but I'm not going to bother commenting on it aside from to say it looks weird to me.

I hope to see more from you soon!
-Aley

I edited it, better? Or kinda worse ~The Written Girl

Wow! That made a huge difference in the clarity of the poem and really getting into the personal attitude that I was hoping for! The multiple stanzas actually really helped too because it was much easier to read. Great improvements <3

You're going to get one more review because this is in the Green Room, so I can't wait to see what they have to say.

I think it's better.



cron
attempting foot extraction
— Mea