AAAARGH. Dreamy, you're driving me crazy! You're replying to everyone, and I always get so excited when I see you've made a new post on this thread... And then I just see you're thanking someone for a critique or the offer of a critique. Hmph.
The ladys at my college LRC will hate me for it, and say I'm wasting paper (they say that even if it's work -_-") but I'm printing this off so I can have a read through over Christmas too, something to stop me from going mad between writing and revision. *hums and skips away*
please grant me my small wish; (love me to the marrow of my bones)
The very first Chair of Wind and Darkness was not so very different than the one you might be sitting in now. It was very simple, white wood and wicker, and it stood on four elegantly swooping legs before a desk so that it could spend its quiet days near the window that overlooked the lawn, the stone courtyard and the stately trees outside.
Ok, this isn’t really a spell-binding beginning, personinally I dislike how an author talks to a reader however I can see its good points.
It sat, in all its years, in a little airy room beside a small desk while the gauzy curtains blew in from the window and swept, billowing, against it.
Point in this paragraph?
It was such a chair that, looking at it, you could easily see yourself sitting in it, could easily imagine that the book on the desk was yours as it ruffled from page to creamy page, blown into a chaotic flurry by the breeze. The feeling could arise that all those neat, black-inked, handwritten pages were yours, paragraphs and words that compounded to build personal secrets, dreams, hopes; all the good things in life and all the bad, unhappy things you only lived through by screaming your outrage at the sky - the things you’ve endured and looked back on and understood. And forgiven.
This seems to go on and on but it still seems to flow. Well done.
You could easily imagine that, to see the chair. What you could not imagine would be that this plain, serviceable, simple chair reigning before an evenly plain desk and a single, beautiful book could be the Chair of Wind and Darkness, something that you’ve doubtless known about your entire life. Though likely never by that name. And likely never in that way.
The end of the start is good, I now feel that I must read into chapter 1 and get into the story. Its not a favourite way to begin of mine because it isn’t a story of a character. However you have fulfilled the purpose: I am forced to scroll down.
Chapter One
In the dream it was raining. Raining was not ordinarily a bad state for the weather to be in, but in the downtown sector of the city Barduev, it was an inconvenience which made the Agra-Wazir District particularly challenging to get through - the sunken sidewalks and muddy, flooding gardens lay a level below the street. Shan Tefur’s boots and the bottom of his long black jacket were completely soaked as he stood beneath the looming columns of the Provincial Development Building, the only government building on this street and therefore the only one with a raised porch.
Beautiful. You begin with a simple sentence and extend it by introducing a character and give a location as well. My only critiscism is the “Agra Wazir” it seems a bit of a mouthful to give to the reader at the start of the novel./b]
He ran thin white fingers through his dripping dark hair and looked left down the avenue towards the Kier District and the general direction of his apartment. A glance up the street towards his destination and he leaned forward a bit to glance up a the stinging misty curtain that wasn’t allowing him to see either. He stepped back a pace on the porch and paced for a moment in the pre-moonlight shadows, drying his hands uselessly on the soaking edge of his coat. [b]I think “thin, white” would be better but it seems a cluttery first sentence just to stay that he looked to his apartment. Ok, the second sentence doesn’t seem to work for me at all, it doesn’t make sense. Maybe you want to reword that one.
As he turned once he caught a quick glimpse of the guards who had been following him since the Academy Block. They were huddled under the porch roof of some dark house, miserable in water that was up to their ankles in the depressed stonework - five... no, six of them, right there across the street. Still, their presence irritated him, and he sighed, rubbed a hand across the back of his neck and took a step out from under the overhang.
It would read better if you used the “—“ before miserable instead of the comma. Throw in his name again here instead of using “he” all of the time as I almost forgot who the story was about.
“Strazhas!” he shouted across the street, cupping his hands around his mouth so that the noise carried through the rain. The call had an astonishing lack of volume through the downpour but still they heard him. Strazhas were trained to hear in the dark, in the rain. And they had no choice now that he had seen them - they slipped around the corner of their building and disappeared into the alleyway as if they were just a handful of old friends out for a walk in the soaking night. They were still going to follow him, of course, they were just going to do it a little more discreetly.
Perhaps give a teensy weensy niblet of who the strazhas are here.
He swore and looked right and left again sharply, up and down the street through the downpour. He ran a and down his dripping face, moving a bit and craning his neck to see down the now empty alley. It occurred to him that he was wasting time, that at this point getting wet was the least of his worries. Finally he went to the opposite side of the porch, turned and ran for the edge, with the mind to jump far enough so as to get to the area of semi-dryness under the next porch, sunken though it was. He tripped pushing off the edge and landed on a knee in the wide, soaking street in between, bruising his palms and getting himself thoroughly drenched. He pulled himself up with his long, once fastidious coat tangled around his leg and shin-deep in water, and he kicked the rain-water in an arch of spray towards the main street. Shan saw the movement beyond the rain as the inexpertly trained Strazhas dispersed and spread out, waiting for him farther up the avenue, drier than he and, for the moment, under a porch roof.
I think once again you put too much strain on how the character looks, I don’t think it needs the amount of importance you put into it. Fastidious seems a little complex in context of the piece, I’d change it to a synonym.
Thanks Lilyy and Fish, for the read and the possible crit - very much appreciated. ^_^
Phorcys: You make good points with both the Prologue and the first chapter... the prologue, though, has been changed since, so perhaps it's a bit more character-driven now. It lacks mention of the the Chair as... well, a chair, entirely. ^_~ Thank you for the notes on Chapter One - it was quite helpful in the revision.
Crysi: >.< Don't kill me. On the bright side, this is due the 26th, so I figure it has to get posted at some point before that... if you want, I can PM you when I finally get the revised continuation up. ^_^
Look you finally got around to critiquing Chair? ME! Erm, if there is anything unclear or vague, or my chicken scratch is illegible please holler.
Oh, I just realized like 3/4s of the way through Chair that I am spelling Kasimov wrong, I am spelling it with a z, Kazimov. 'Cause every time I think of Kasimov, I think Kamikazi. All Shan's fault, of course.
Three and Four to come.
Ta,
Cal.
Fraser: Stop stealing the blanket. [Diefenbaker whines] Fraser: You're an Arctic Wolf, for God's sake. (Due South)
Hatter: Do I need a reason to help a pretty girl in a very wet dress? (Alice)
Cal, thank you so much. So much. So very much. Did I mention how much. I have to say, no one's wondered yet if Livny's on crack, but you'll be pleased to note that he's not - only wonderfully snarky. ^_~
Indebted to you as always, Cal. You always do give such helpful critiques. ^_^
*shifty eyes* Livny may... or may not be a sociopath...
As for poor Shan, I think your mention of BBC Robin Hood commercial fits rather well. All he wants to do is go smoke a cigarette and take a walk, but life's seems to have other plans, doesn't it? And I very glad you like him so much as character (Pros once told me to"just shoot him and get it over with so he stops kvetching"). ^_~
I'll be sure to work out the punctuation and great love of ellipses on the redraft, Cal. Once again, thanks so much.
DREAMY!!! I saw that you had posted and nearly had a heart attack of joy that there was more Chair!!! *sobs*
"In a sort of ghastly simplicity we remove the organ and demand the function...We laugh at honour and are shocked to find traitors in our midst. We castrate and bid the geldings be fruitful." ~C.S. Lewis
gyrfalcon wrote:DREAMY!!! I saw that you had posted and nearly had a heart attack of joy that there was more Chair!!! *sobs*
Haha, don't cry over it. *hugs*
I'm not going to try to sneak an update in here on you, I promise. I shall PM you the very instant I submit the next bit, the next redraft, the next rewrite, whatever. If you don't get a PM? Then there is no update. ^_~ No heart attacks. How on earth would I explain that to the paramedic crew?
Like... this has been the only story I've read completely on YWS and when I saw it updated, I hoped that either this meant:
1) You had updated this.
2) You had published it.
So yeah.. Write!
Ubi caritas est vera, Deus ibi est.
"The mark of your ignorance is the depth of your belief in injustice and tragedy. What the caterpillar calls the end of the world, the Master calls the butterfly." ~ Richard Bach