-
Re: Masquerade
This was really good! I for one do not like poetry, but I really did like this one. I'm really sorry but I'm afraid I don't have any constructive criticism ...
Apr 10, 2006 -
Re: Abandoned [deleted]
Wow...beautiful imagery...you've just blown me away My favorite part: and the broken wings of dead dreams litter the earth, like leaves; However, the end did not work for me. I ...
Feb 20, 2006 -
Re: "Writing Challange 2/6": Shh
I hate to be repititive but yeah I like the word 'asunder' too. I like this!! It's really nice and sweet. :)And yeah, I'm really bad at criticizing I'm afraid ...
Feb 11, 2006 -
Re: Requim for lost life
Wow, first of all I just hope this isn't true. You asked me to critique this piece, so here I am :D They hate me, why? What I do I ...
Dec 26, 2005 -
Re: Seafoam - Lifting the Velvet Curtain of Fear
I really like this, it's got a very poetic feel to it. I can hardly find anything to critic, this really is one of the nicest pieces I've read in ...
Nov 16, 2005 -
Re: Shift, Part One - Warning: Smoking Kills (comments needed)
This is good, I can't wait to read more. There are a few typos, I think you need to go over it once. She sleeps in the springtime in hollows ...
Nov 7, 2005 -
Re: A Sentence of a New Life - Chapter 4
“You lazy scoundrel, I’m firing you from the regiment. You’ve been so mopey (There’s no such word as mopey, I would suggest you use broody or sulky instead) and disobedient ...
Oct 25, 2005 -
Re: Featherweight
(Welcome to YWS, by the way!) Yes, this is in the right section. I like this piece a lot, you have displayed the emotions really well. It almost has a ...
Oct 16, 2005 -
Re: Chapter 3 - A Sentence of A New Life -
Okay...this is getting better and better! Just a few tiny mistakes "...she couldn't bare it" It should be bear, not bare. "You shouldn't be on deck" It should be "on ...
Oct 15, 2005 -
Re: Chapter 1-2 - A Sentence of A New Life
Sorry, I know this is kind of late, but I wasn't feeling well so I could'nt get to your story before. Chapter 1 Nefer has pretty much covered everything, so ...
Oct 15, 2005 -
Re: To Rend This Tattered Heart (formally "Shatter")
I really liked this poem. I could definitely relate to the feelings portrayed. I'm afraid I can't critic anything in this poem because I find it so perfect. I know ...
Oct 4, 2005 -
Re: The Gaurdians (Chapter One)
Well, okay, your story has potential. But there are a few things you could change; that would perhaps make the story more interesting. First of all, I think you should ...
Oct 3, 2005 -
Re: The Phantom Pains (short story)
Well, this was an okay story. You write very well, the only thing is that you kept the story really confusing, which is good, to a point. The start was ...
Sep 25, 2005 -
Re: Title pending poll. Wow, this was cathartic.
Wow! I like this, its got style. It's a very direct poem, which I like. Here’s how it’s gonna work, Princess. He’s gonna be you’re Prince Charming first, But then, ...
Sep 25, 2005 -
Re: Romantic Fiction: The Perfect Gift
This was good, i really liked it. It's nice and simple, which works for a story like this. My only suggestion is that you should expand a bit more on ...
Sep 25, 2005
