-
Re: Secret Storm by Mark Worger
Worgs, There's a wonderful sentiment behind this, and I think we've all shared it at some point. The problem is that the poem as it stands is simply far too ...
Oct 11, 2006 -
Re: To a Victim of the Tsunami
Hi Worgs, I do not know where this has been successful, other than perhaps in sympathetic circles. For this reader, however, it is awful. It's a self-absorbed, privately coded tour ...
Oct 11, 2006 -
Re: Our Pain
Sureal, I feel like I've seen this poem, with its lists of small events and items, and its trigger to a flashback, hundreds of times before. I expect I'll see ...
Oct 11, 2006 -
Re: 'Dad' by Mark Worger
Worgs, The piece seems intent on plowing the same patch of ground until the reader "gets it." This didactic approach and the shift from "he" to "you" runs counter to ...
Oct 11, 2006 -
Re: Remix of an older poem
Lexy, I'm glad you enjoyed it. Ani, Same to you. xanthan_gum, I understand that it is confusing, but I do not know that I agree with "unclear." To brush one's ...
Oct 11, 2006 -
Re: Life is a picture
Jiggity, I see a dignified attempt to create something. What?--I'm not certain it's complete, but at present it's an idea that has been rehashed a few times too many to ...
Oct 10, 2006 -
Re: I said oh! aren't ~ aren't you God? Hello. Sir.
Misty, This poem is overrun with grammatical havoc. The idea is laudable, but I don't feel like the means were correctly executed. In fact, it was so poorly delivered, I'm ...
Oct 10, 2006 -
Re: An Award winning poem by Mark Worger
Welcome Worgs, We always enjoy a new read. The only above comment worth saving is backgroundbob's. This is too politically motivated for me to empathize with you. Subtlety is the ...
Oct 10, 2006 -
Re: Debatable
Hi xanthan_gum, This fails to please the way your last poems have. I feel that you rely too heavily and directly on the "countdown effect" at the end of this ...
Oct 10, 2006 -
Re: The Pearl, by John Steinbeck
My only issue with Steinbeck is that he underestimates the reader's ability. Everything is spelled out, and there is really nothing left for you to think about. Even that pesky ...
Oct 10, 2006 -
Re: wanderlust
Hi Jack, I'm glad you're still writing poetry. This, for me, redoubles into itself. The notion of being One is brought up either too much for this, or else this ...
Oct 10, 2006 -
Re: Despair/Rescue, my Twins
Hi Gyrfalcon, This requires a great amount of trimming. You have excesses of words that obscure the meaning of the piece. I do not mean to jostle the rhyme scheme, ...
Oct 9, 2006 -
Re: Removed
Hi BohemeMistress, Worry not--this is not as bad as the last piece I reviewed. That being said, you need to work on your ability to consult the thesaurus and the ...
Oct 9, 2006 -
Re: Sunbathing
Hi timjim77, I am glad to see you around again. The same can not be said for this piece. It seems to me an excuse for a string of Poetickal ...
Oct 9, 2006 -
Re: Crayons
SlickJimmy, "Is it poetry?" That was the question asked when Whitman published his Leaves of Grass . Many of the poems written by Fernando Pessoa would seem prose if one ...
Oct 9, 2006
