-
Re: Chasing the Sun - Prologue
Hey there, this is rather long. Prospective reviewers will be scared away. Cut it into two parts. Many reviewers like to tackle shorter things. That said, I skimmed some bits. ...
Nov 12, 2013 -
Re: Facing the Fire: part 1
Hey there. Your introduction post intrigued me to the point that I decided to check out if you'd posted anything, and, lo and behold, you did. Overall, this is pretty ...
Nov 12, 2013 -
Re: [deleted]
Hey there. This is pretty flat. It's more as if I was reading some sort of essay. Is your narrator a machine? I assume they are human, and therefore has ...
Nov 9, 2013 -
Re: The Zarareth's Legacy Chapter 2
never mind.
Nov 7, 2013 -
Re: Cyberpunk Fantasy, part one
Hey there, welcome to yws. I don't understand that much about guns, and I don't feel like doing my research for you. That said, I'll assume you've accounted for the ...
Nov 6, 2013 -
Re: Malec forever
Hey there, As I said below, this does not have a plot. This does not have a setting. This does not have interesting characters. We like romance between characters for ...
Oct 21, 2013 -
Re: Blank Draft
What just happened. She's pretty, she's throwing herself off a cliff, no wait she has a glider, no wait it breaks, there's a translucent man staring at her aaaand she's ...
Oct 17, 2013 -
Re: Roses Dyed by Blood
This is at the very least interesting! I can't give a very solid critique because this is so short... why post an excerpt? Reviewing them is rather pointless. The scent ...
Oct 17, 2013 -
Re: Knighting ceremony for Kal
Why even bother showing us the end, without everything else? It defeats the point of... pretty much anything I can think of. I can't really express preference for a book ...
Oct 17, 2013 -
Re: Kira's Story, Chapter 10
Well then. There are new characters introduced. From an apparently meaningless hostage situation at a diner in the previous chapter, we are now reading Call of Duty: Black Ops. There's ...
Sep 29, 2013 -
Re: Kira's Story, Chapter 9
well alright then. Remember how I said you aren't capable of juggling multiple plot lines and characters? Here it's incredibly obvious. You dedicate one chapter to one, one to another, ...
Sep 29, 2013 -
Re: Kira's Story, Chapter 8
First thing. Why, o why repeat the previous chapter? It's absolutely useless, it's not like we need to be reminded what we read two minutes ago. Ok, so, forget what ...
Sep 29, 2013 -
Re: Kira's Story, Chapter 7
I'm not... sure... what's going... on...? Suddenly there are moderators, sages, and jesus christ Kira seems to have been completely forgotten. Turns out she's not the main character at all, ...
Sep 29, 2013 -
Re: Kira's Story, Chapter 6
Ah come on, come on! How much more forced can you get? I agree with Pengi, Obsidian has been delivering false threats throughout this entire novel. He wouldn't kill the ...
Sep 29, 2013 -
Re: Kira's Story, Chapter 5
Hrrrrm. Hey Knight Dragon, your faithful Louis is here to continue the reviewing spree. The first paragraph is again an info dump, albeit of a different nature. Instead of showing ...
Sep 29, 2013
