The RWBY fan club

The RWBY fan club

Fans of RWBY unite (Pancakes!)

  • 9 forum topics
  • 130 wall posts
  • Created Mon Oct 19, 2015 8:51 pm

Wall

130 posts — share updates and reply to club members.


  • BrumalHunter
    Say what you will about the series, but the music is sick. I absolutely love what Casey and her friends managed to do for Volume 9's soundtrack and score, and I'm especially glad that Ruby got not just one theme, but two. Trapdoor is amazing, and Guide My Way is even more so.

    Volume 10 might apparently not materialise, but if this is the last volume, I think it's an acceptable conclusion to the series.

  • JoyDark
    Ahhh lookie here!! I honestly kinda have a love-hate relationship with this show. I love Volume Three to this day, and Volume Six imo isn’t too bad. But I also hate Volume 7, Volume 8, and Volume 5 for the most part. Honestly, my favorite part of RWBY is that it’s basically a breeding ground for fan fiction and making OCs in the universe.

    Caerulean replied · May 26, 2021

    I think I liked V7 and V8 overall, though, of course, I wasn't fully sold on certain parts. First half of V6 was great. Second half was quite weak. First half of V5 was nice, but then the second half was oof except for certain scenes.


  • Omni Admin
    I have just finished Volume 7 (I'm taking a bit of a break before Volume 8) and I just want to tell any queer RWBY fans who have not watched Vol. 7 yet that, from a gay person, there's definite queercoding and queer baiting in this volume and spoiler

    Spoiler
    bury your gays


    Volume 7 is awesome. But this left me a sour taste in my mouth.

  • BrumalHunter
    Ugh, it's sad that YWS doesn't have a very big RWBY fanbase, since I want to see other people's thoughts on Volume 7. I'm enjoying the newly released OST a ton, but more than half the time when I'm listening to it, it causes me to dwell on how incompetent many of the characters were and how royally Team RWBY (Ruby especially) screwed up.

    dragonfphoenix replied · Aug 11, 2020

    I stopped watching about halfway through Volume 4. It just felt like they took the series in such a different direction from how it was originally going, and I really didn't like the thematic tone. Which is sad, because I really like the RWBYverse. Maybe I'll pick it up again, I've been thinking about it recently.


    BrumalHunter replied · Aug 12, 2020

    Oh, it absolutely took a different turn. RWBY was an energetic story about teenagers learning to hunt monsters, containing lots of silly humour and epic battles where Rule of Cool was king. I'm invested in some of the characters and the gorgeous soundtrack (it's the only aspect with consistency in its quality, haha, though there are certainly still ups and downs), which is why I've continued following it. I'm... also a diehard optimist, so it's difficult for me to give up on some things.

    But yeah, CRWBY has decided to go for a high fantasy-ish story that turned the scope from stopping bad guys while attending class to saving the world from an immortal evil. Volume 4 is slow and Volume 5 is just bad, but Volume 6 improved in a lot of ways, and so did Volume 7, though the conclusion is assinine. I'm still holding out hope that Volume 8 might improve enough to warrant a sincere recommendation to continue watching, but I shan't fault anyone for deciding to drop the show.

    PS: Pandering to the shippers without properly developing relationships and actually showing us their pivotal moments, as well as blatant contradictions or inconsistencies in both plot and character depictions are two main reasons why I would drop the show myself.


  • BrumalHunter
    Yesterday, I decided to watch some reviews of RWBY, and today, I continued doing so. In one of them, reference was made to a document called Shane's Letter, which is a letter from Shane Newville (essentially Monty Oum's right hand while they worked on RWBY) to anyone wishing to know the truth of RWBY's situation. It's 36 pages long, and you can read it below, if you like.

    I still love RWBY, but over the years of following it (I started watching after Volume 3, so I am, admittedly, only a "new" fan), with Volume 8 set to come out later this year, it's clear that there are several significant flaws in the story, and many things don't make sense. It would appear this is because the Rooster Teeth management tried very hard to take RWBY into their preferred route, rather than Monty's. It's worth some pondering.

    Now, as a disclaimer, I'm not choosing a side as much as I'm urging fans to educate themselves on all the facts and drawing informed conclusions. I'm not undermining the work that CRWBY has done over the years, both before and after Monty's passing, because what they've done is amazing. However, the dissatisfaction within the fandom with RWBY's content and RT's treatment of some of its employees shouldn't be ignored. I think Monty was very passionate, but also rather impulsive and made things difficult for a company that wanted definite processes and such in place. Nevertheless, he also confided in his wife, Sheena Duquette-Oum, about the story in its entirety, yet RT completely ostracised her. Granted, Shane himself is clearly a very troubled man and has built up immense resentment during his last year at RT. His words should absolutely be taken with a grain of salt, but at least a couple of people (Sheena included) confirmed what he said.

    There are many people working at RT who still want to honour Monty and carry out his vision — of that, I'm certain. Unfortunately, I also believe there was a great deal of politics going on, and people who weren't aware of them were misled. We should continue to enjoy RWBY, for those of us who still do, but we must keep a clear mind.

    ~ https://ia800404.us.archive.org/34/item ... ntyOum.pdf

  • BrumalHunter
    Volume 6 was one of the best seasons of the series — in my opinion better than all of them besides Volume 3. But its soundtrack?! It is by far the best of them all in terms of overall technical skill, musical complexity, and depth of lyrics. It's my favourite for this reason and because I highly anticipated almost every song (but enjoyed each nevertheless).

    Which are your favourite songs? They're wonderful and glorious and everything I hoped they would be, and all of them are on YouTube already. Forever Fall is the one song I instantly sought out, and I must say... Pyrrha's love for Jaune was not done justice until now. I happily wept for four consecutive hours before finally going to sleep. <3

  • wakarimasen
    So, apparently, on a recent Reddit AMA, Miles Luna (voice of Jaune and co-writer for the show) confirmed that Qrow and Ruby's relationship is merely uncle and niece, putting to rest the compelling but sadly untrue theory that Qrow and Summer are Ruby's biological parents.

    Spoiler
    I'm a bit disappointed about that, personally. In my mind, having Qrow and Summer as Ruby's parents / Tai and Raven as Yang's parents seems a bit less messy and a more positive reflection on Taiyang's character.


    A Lien for your thoughts?

    Europa replied · Feb 14, 2018

    I'm not sure how the situation would reflect badly on Taiyang's character. He didn't really do anything wrong. His first wife left him, and with the ties of that relationship completely broken off, Taiyang was completely free and justified in choosing another woman.


    TinyMochi replied · Feb 14, 2018

    hum.....


    wakarimasen replied · Feb 14, 2018

    @Europa - Oh, absolutely.

    Spoiler
    But it seemed to me like he got over his wife's loss very quickly for Ruby to have been born when she was. It just seems a little ... unfeeling to me, but I suppose grief can make people do a variety of things.

    I saw more appeal in the idea that Summer and Tai were both abandoned at some point by their Branwen partners and did a Brady Bunch to raise their kids together in a blended family unit. But that's just my headcanon.


    Europa replied · Feb 14, 2018

    @AllisontheWriter Another idea to consider might be that Taiyang wasn't intending to have another child at first.

    Spoiler
    Taiyang seems to me to be a very sensitive man who forms attachments quickly. After Raven left, he was probably suffering a lot of grief and maybe a hint of betrayal, but he did have a daughter to raise. Maybe he decided to get together with Summer because he felt like Yang needed a mother figure in her life. It makes a fair amount of sense to me because until Summer died, Yang never knew that she had a different mother than Ruby. Tai may have not wanted her feel like her family was different or broken, and so he hid the fact that he'd been with any other woman. However, its clear that after a while, Taiyang and Summer did develop feelings for each other because Ruby was born, even if Tai wasn't planning on having another child. Plus, according to Yang, when Summer died, Taiyang "shut down", and throughout the series, even though we've heard him talk about Raven, he hasn't said a word about Summer yet, maybe because it's still too painful for him to remember her.


    wakarimasen replied · Feb 15, 2018

    Oooh, that does make a lot of sense!


  • wakarimasen replied · Jan 22, 2018

    :/ It was better than Vol 4, I'll say that.


    Caerulean replied · Jan 23, 2018

    Honestly, part of me is saying V4 is generally more entertaining than V5, though I must say V5 seems to have more polished action scenes than V4. V5 felt dragged out in the middle with dialogue scenes that could have been shorter/utilized more efficiently and executed better.

    Anyway, I'm one of those YouTube-only viewers and I still haven't watched the last chapter. :3


    captainearth replied · Jan 24, 2018

    same i only watch on you-tube lol


  • Omni Admin
    Time to wait eight months for Volume 6. I don't have spoiler thoughts for this episode as it runs similar to last, but I will have a rant about RWBY in general soon.

    FigrothFelanor replied · Jan 20, 2018

    There go my hopes for Jaune meeting Pyrrha's family... *sigh*


    KaiRyu replied · Jan 20, 2018

    Eight months?! o.o


    Omni replied · Jan 22, 2018

    @KaiRyu given the timeline of the past, yep! Volume 5 started in late October, and finished last Saturday. Taking that into account, we would have to wait until October again for Volume 6 premiere


  • wakarimasen replied · Jan 15, 2018

    Poses... *unflattering shot of Nora* Yeah, that about sums it up. XD

    I had no idea they'd stopped using Poser. That explains all the subtle differences in the character designs, beyond aging, like Weiss having ... softer eyes, if that makes any sense.

    I guess I have to watch the rest. :D


    Omni replied · Jan 15, 2018

    Oh you didn't know they changed animation programs between Season 3 and 4? That's why the animation quality (like, looks-wise) looked better but everything went down. I'm surprised that they stopped mo-cap (I thought they still did but this guy convinced me otherwise) since that adds a lot of realism to the animation. Apparently Monty was a genius at Poser but the software was hard to use for basically everyone else. The industry moved to Maya, so RT did as well. They just need someone who can animate well in Maya, man.


    wakarimasen replied · Jan 15, 2018

    Wow, yeah, that surprises me too. So what do they use the Monty Oum Memorial Mocap Studio for these days?


    Omni replied · Jan 15, 2018

    Probably Red vs Blue. Last I saw on that show, they used quite a bit of mo-cap.


  • Omni Admin
    Volume 5, Ep. 13 Thoughts:

    Spoiler
    Ruby's beginning skirmish with Mercury and Emerald is horribly done. The way she picks up her scythe is so slow and just sloppy. Fighting is difficult, I get it. But, sloppiness is unacceptable. I also find it hard to believe that an entire animation team cannot bring forth the quality of fighting that one man did, genius he may be. Rooster Teeth, please, for the love of everything out there, find someone who can animate fight scenes. Pay them well. RWBY will die off if Volume 4 & 5 will become the norm.

    So, this isn't Jaune's Semblance? But his aura boosting Weiss' okay, fine whatever Jaune's Semblance doesn't even interest me anymore ROOSTER TEETH IT'S BEEN FIVE YEARS JUST TELL US ALREADY unless he can bring back the dead then I'm okay with that.

    Raven and Cinder's fight was good, but I still noticed cheap animation cheats that made the fight feel bare in places. There wasn't much up close fighting done ala Monty's fighting. But, it looked spectacular to watch, as every Maiden fight so far has been.

    I'm excited to see what the last episode will bring. I surely hope there's more fighting and an actual conclusion and not just a denouement. You don't waste the final episode with exposition exposition exposition.

    Anyway, all around good episode. Not great. But good. The best thing about it was the Cinder/Raven fight and Nora smacking Hazel like he was a twig. Everything else was weeeeeeeaaak

    wakarimasen replied · Jan 14, 2018

    Yes yes all this yes.

    Spoiler
    phpBB [media]



sometimes i don't consider myself a poet but then i remember that i literally write poetry
— chikara