He made me promise not to tell anyone.
It was a summer afternoon, the birds’ songs filled the warm air but they would soon be drowned out. I ran my fingers through my hair, brushing it from my eyes. I could now see him bounding on ahead; running through the grass to the side of the path. I joined and sprinted after him laughing as we fell, collapsing in a heap on the ground. We rolled onto our backs; our hands linked and stared up at the blue sky.
“I love summer” I smiled and he returned the favour.
“Come on” He said whilst lifting me from the ground. I spun around; my skirt flying high then leaned in towards him.
“I want to show you something.” He started. I kissed him on the cheek, waiting. A smile wavered on his lips.
“But you have to promise not to tell.” I didn’t doubt him then, I just loved him. So I nodded and he began to lead me through the woods to the side of the path. The ground crunched beneath our feet as we walked along in silence. He moved a few paces ahead his hand trailing behind as it held on to mine, keeping me close. I followed his footsteps until they began to slow. Deep into the woods now, we had left the birds behind and the air was quiet.
“Are we here?” I asked him, my voice disturbing the silence. I got the sense that it was too quiet, my question felt like a knife cutting through it. I don’t know why, maybe it was the look in his eyes. I’d never seen that look before.
He nodded.
“Just over there, by the shed.” He pointed ahead of himself and ushered me forward. Curious, I walked towards his outstretched arm and the shed he had mentioned was revealed. It was a small shack with rusted iron walls and a tin roof. But however strange it might have been to find a shed in the middle of the woods, it wasn’t the shed that caught my eye. It was the girl. The little girl lying slumped against the ridged wall of the shed. She wore pearls around her neck and a doll lay rested by her side. Her hands and feet were tied in pristine rope, her hair secured in flawless plaits, a blonde fringe sweeping across her white forehead, her ocean eyes staring at me without seeing.
I gasped and stumbled over to her. Cradling her in my arms I checked her pulse to find the answer I already knew. Nobody’s skin can be that white, that cold, on a clear summer’s day.
My words were caught, my throat dry. Tears were on the edges of my eyes, held prisoner there by pure shock. Tearing my sight from the girl I turned my attention to him. He was standing a few feet away, his hands in the pockets of his shorts, his toes tapping on the sole of his sandals.
“Do you like her?” he asked nervously. His words barely registered, I didn’t understand what was happening, or rather, I didn’t want to.
“What?” I asked, the tears pressing at my eyes.
“Do you like her?” he repeated. “I got her just for you. You said you wanted a daughter. I even dressed her for you, in a brand new dress, a pink one just like you said you’d buy. And her hair, I did her hair. I learnt how to do it for you so I could do it on her, don’t you remember?”
I tried not to listen but I did remember. He had asked if he could plait my hair. When I realised he couldn’t do it I showed him and then let him practise on me for hours on end. That was weeks ago. All this time he’d been planning this. How could someone plan something like this?
“You don’t like her do you?” It wasn’t a question. He strode forward and grabbed my wrists, pulling me from the ground but it wasn’t like before; he’d changed. He was hurting me. I tried to get away but his grip just tightened.
“Why don’t you like her?” he asked, pushing me against the shed. My back slammed into it but the pain went numb before I could feel anything. His eyes had turned dark, his whole body tensed. I turned my face to the side not wanting to see him anymore. This wasn’t the man I loved.
“Why don’t you like her, she’s perfect. I made sure of it, just for you. Look at me when I talk to you!” He slammed me against the wall again, forcing me to look his way. The blow was harder this time and a sharp pain flowed down my spine.
“I worked so hard on her. She’s my masterpiece, our masterpiece. Why don’t you like her?” He wouldn’t shut up and he looked so mad. I was so scared, I didn’t know what else to do.
“I do.” I breathed, “I do like her, she’s incredible. It’s just so… overwhelming.” He didn’t believe me; I could see it in his eyes.
“Thomas, I love her. I love you.” I tried again and this time his grip loosened. After a minute or so he let go and started rubbing his face. I began to move away only to be stopped by his rough hands cutting into my wrists once more. A small whimper escaped my lips and his hold relaxed. Moving his hands to mine he held on tight, leaned in close and made me promise not to tell.
“Just promise okay? Promise you won’t tell anyone. She can be our little secret. Promise me?”
“I promise.” I said. He nodded and let me go. We walked back hand in hand leaving the girl behind.
So that’s how it happened, that summer afternoon, but you should know, sometimes I break my promises.
Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
That gave me the shivers. It was creepy! I was not expecting at all. Seeing the title, I thought it might be a cliché love story, but you proved me wrong. The first sentence instantly caught my interest, bringing up questions like, what had he done? Why did he ask for a promise?
However, like any other story, I found some issues.
1. You gave us the hint too quickly (in the second sentence), and that kind of ruined the shock. You could have gradually built up the tension and left it to us, your readers, to figure out that something’s wrong.
2. I noticed a couple of mechanical (grammar, punctuation, and spellings) error/mistakes, but nothing too major. Perhaps you should read over your story and edit it.
3. You could have taken more time to develop or describe your main character’s thoughts and feelings. It’s obvious she’s shock, feels sick, or is scared – rather take us through the emotional journey. Don’t just tell us.
4. Give us more background of your characters. How did they meet? How long have they been together? Had he ever behaved strangely? Did she ever suspect him to be different from others? These sorts of questions heighten tension and mystery. Moreover, do describe your characters to us. It really helps us to imagine them.
Regardless of all required improvements highlighted above, I truly enjoyed reading this story. I loved the plot twist. Once again, I got to say, I didn’t expect it at all . The last sentence was a fine-tuned finish to a marvellous piece.
Well done, and keep writing!
How did you know about my ex-boyfriend? Just kidding, I've never had a boyfriend. Anyways, my terrible jokes aside, this was very very good. The beginning was very suspenseful and the twist was shocking. I really loved the dark nature and would love to see more.
Hey Wakegirl!
And feel free to PM me with any questions.
So one nit picky thing to get out of the way at the beginning is to just be careful of your punctuation when coming out of dialogue. For the most part it was fine but in the beginning few bits of dialogue you forgot to a comma or a full stop. So that's just something to look out for.
I like the idea of this little scene. I see it more of a scene rather than a completed short story because there is so much more that can be told here and I want to know more, which is good. It's quite creepy or at least I felt creeped out when I was reading it but I guess that's what you were going for!
The one thing I wanted to comment on was just the pacing and the changes in the characters. For me it was a little bit quick. I could've done with more suspense more of the feeling like 'What the heck is going on?'
Tied into this is the switches in the characters. I like the idea of the guy switching from being apparently harmless to be being this chillingly warped killer but I just felt like it was a little too fast. To find it even more affecting I think I would need a little more of him from before hand, that would help with the kind of shocking punch you were going for I think. Also I felt like I wanted more of the woman's internal thinking. Like I wanted more of her going through the plan to pretend to go along with it because as it is now it felt a little too sudden.
So basically I guess you could just flesh it out more, pull us in more, build the suspense more and then I think you'd have a cracker of a story!
Let me know if you do any changes or if you have any other works you're putting up
Bex x
Thanks so much Bex and yeah it was supposed to be creepy, the picture I had to base it on was quite disturbing so that's what I got
. I really appreciate your comments and I shall go back over it to make some changes shortly. Glad you enjoyed it! x