Hello, and belated welcome to the site! I hope you're having a good day or night thus far!
I loved how you executed this chapter. Though it was heavy on worldbuilding, you conveyed the information through this emotion laden conversation between Tyr and Gheythas. I think you struck just the right amount of exposition to fill the reader in on all the context they need to appreciate the characterization found here.
I also liked the dynamic between Tyr and Gheythas. Though the former has committed atrocious acts, the reader still finds a way to sympathize with him. We also relate to the latter, who is forced to reconcile this person he cares about, with the wicked things said person has done. It's a very compelling start to a narrative!
At the start, I did have some difficultly catching on to a sense of place. For example, in the fourth paragraph,
The warlock sighed, pausing for a moment before lifting up his shirt to reveal a numerous mess of fresh wounds, sliced into his skin like a cursed pattern, “You’re not hiding anything very well. You set out for the church earlier this afternoon, you didn’t come back until the very latest you could, and you’re a bloody mess. Someone in there took it out on you. You paid a debt today, and a heavy one.”
I initially assumed that Gheythas had revealed his wounds. I had to go back and reread the line to understand what had actually happened.
With the introduction as well, the characters were doing a lot of different actions, but aside from the allusion to a tabletop, I had no idea where they were. Even by the end of the chapter, I'm still not entirely sure. There are stairs, a bed, and a counter, which just felt like a strange configuration of furniture to me.
You write some really fantastic prose, and I love, love the dialogue. However, I did have one small nitpick with a very specific line,
Gheythas’ hands fell slightly down his back, and he could swear he saw him shake his head slightly from behind.
I noticed you occasionally "over-clarify," specifically when a character takes an action. (This is something I'm very guilty of, and have probably done in this very review.) The above quote might flow better if it was instead written as "Gheythas' hands fell down his back. Tyr shook his head from behind."
This comes down to your discretion, as it may be a me thing.
One last suggestion- and this really is just a suggestion, one that comes down to personal preference- but consider when revising to play more with sentence structure. A lot of these lines fall at similar lengths, with a similar frequency of commas. For example, this paragraph,
The warlock struggled to keep himself from lashing back defensively at his words, and to keep the tears from falling from his eyes. He wrapped his arms fully around the paladin, ignoring the open wounds still uncovered, though he seemed not to notice, taking his silence as both a blessing and a curse. The warlock leant himself against the headboard, bringing his legs onto the bed, allowing Tyr to rest against his body, safely comforted in his arms. Gheythas found the pendant hanging from his neck, and danced it through his fingers for a moment before resting his hands against his chest.
could be broken down into a series of very long sentences. Adding some variety helps minimize confusion, increase readability, and overall create more interesting prose.
I hope this all proves helpful! I really enjoyed reading this, and I love the characters you've introduced. They have a very sweet dynamic that is well exemplified throughout this chapter. The opening quote, too, (which I somehow haven't mentioned yet?) is super intriguing to me. The concept of a disillusioned paladin rebelling against the status quo is a fascinating one, and I look forward to seeing where you take it!
Even then, if I were only to look at this chapter as a standalone, it already conveys many powerful themes of guilt, forgiveness, and love. You are a very talented writer, and I look forward to reading what else you have in store! So with all that said, keep at it, and have a great remainder of your day!
Points: 7191
Reviews: 468
Donate