12+

AIO for wanting to break up with my boyfriend because he wont clean up?

PreviousNext

[deleted] • 2 years ago

AIO for wanting to break up with my boyfriend because he won’t clean up?

I feel like I’m going insane, and I don’t know who else to ask. My (27F) boyfriend (29M) keeps leaving messes around the house and no matter how many times I ask him to pick up after himself, he won’t.

This all started when he got back from serving in the military. He kept leaving his dirty dishes in the sink. I asked him multiple times to wash them or put them in the dishwasher, but he’d just brush me off and I’d end up having to do it myself. He’s never acted this way which is making me think I’m doing something wrong, but at the same time it’s infuriating.

After a while, I just started washing the dishes myself, thinking this wasn’t going to last and he’d be his old self again, but things started getting worse. He’d leave dirty clothes around the house, even though the laundry basket would be right there. The trash wasn’t being taken out, he wasn’t helping with chores; it was just all around chaos.

Not only that, but my stuff would go missing randomly. I first thought I was just getting clumsy and losing things, (lip-gloss, keys, etc) but I’d find them in his dirty clothes while doing laundry, or in random places I’m usually not in. Idk, maybe I sound paranoid, but it felt like he was taking my things and hiding them.

We ended up fighting often about this because it was tearing our relationship apart. For context, I have major OCD, and I cannot function in a messy house. It overwhelms me to the point where I just shut down. My boyfriend knows this, which is why I don’t get why he suddenly stopped caring.

We had a major fight one morning because I came downstairs to make coffee and almost threw up when I saw a dead pigeon in our kitchen. It was just lying there on the counter next to the breadbox, the smell hit me before I even processed what I was looking at.

I called my boyfriend downstairs, because who else would put it there? I was literally shaking as I demanded he tell me why he did this, but he refused to tell me; he even called me paranoid, and an idiot because, “the bird probably flew in through the window and died,” which he knows isn’t true because I always lock all the windows and doors at night.

At that point, I was genuinely just pissed off so I yelled at him that if he didn’t stop doing this creepy shit that we’d break up, and then I locked myself in our bedroom.

It’s only been a few hours since, so idk what to do. My friends never liked him to begin with, so I can’t go to them. We’ve been together almost two years and I don’t want to throw it away but I can’t live like this.

Am I overreacting?

***

 u/Familiar_Talk • 16 hours ago

Update: AIO for wanting to break up with my boyfriend because he won’t clean up?


Original post: https://media1.giphy.com/media/v1.Y2lkPTc5MGI3NjE...

Hey guys, sorry this took forever. A bunch of people asked for an update and honestly I just… didn’t know how to explain everything without sounding completely insane.

So, after the pigeon thing, we had a massive fight and I locked myself in our bedroom for hours. (Yes, I made him sleep on the couch.) The next morning he actually apologized, like a real, genuine one. He promised he’d do better and for a while he actually did?? He started cleaning, he picked up after himself, he even remembered where I left my stuff without me having to ask a million times. It felt like we were back to normal, and I kind of convinced myself I’d overreacted, which is why I never updated before.

Anyway, fast forward a few months, and he tells me he’s going on a family trip, which isn’t out of the ordinary since his family loves taking short vacations. He packed a bag, and left on Saturday afternoon. I was actually glad to see him out of the house because that gave me time to wind down and just relax, but a few hours later I heard a knock on the front door.

I really didn’t think anything of it at the time, because I’d ordered some packages a few days ago and they were supposed to arrive today, so I went to open the door but when I opened it, it’s not my package; it’s my boyfriend.

And of course I’m shocked and confused because he'd literally just left. But before I can even say anything he sweeps me up, full on spins me around, kissing me and saying how much he missed me. And I’m frozen because… what??

Then I notice he’s in his military uniform, and my brain immediately goes to “okay, dumb prank,” because he used to do stuff like that when we first started dating. But he looked dead serious.

He puts me down, sees how confused I am, and goes: “I’m home, baby, why aren’t you happy?”

So I blurt out, “Didn’t you literally just leave for a family trip, like a few hours ago?” And now he’s looking at me like I’m crazy. He pulls out his phone and shows me a text he sent earlier that said, “Hey baby, I’m coming home soon, can’t wait to see you ❤️”

My hands literally started shaking while I read through the texts because if he was just now coming home, who the hell had I been living with these past few months?

My boyfriend saw that I was getting anxious, so we walked into the kitchen to sit down, and I told him everything: the messes, my missing stuff, the pigeon---All of it. Both of us were obviously tense, and he looked horrified and said he’d been deployed this whole time. He even showed me photos and timestamps to prove it.

We called the police. He searched the house top to bottom and locked everything while we waited. The cops showed up, took our statements, and searched the house, but found nothing. We even asked his parents (thinking maybe it was some bizarre prank?) but they said they were visiting relatives and hadn’t seen or spoken to him recently.

We even asked for a forensics team to be called in, but when they searched the house there were no fingerprints, no DNA, no sign of anyone living there but me.

Edit: For anyone asking, yes I’m safe. We moved in with his parents for now. We’re selling the old place and moving somewhere new. And for the people saying this is fake: I wouldn’t put myself through this just to post a Reddit story. I’m seeing a therapist now, and this will be my last update.

Comments & reviews · 8
Note: You are not logged in, but you can still leave a comment or review. Before it shows up, a moderator will need to approve your comment (this is only a safeguard against spambots). Leave your email if you would like to be notified when your message is approved.

User avatar
Milesperhour133
Comment

idk how I didn't see this earlier, but this is amazing! Everything about this- the reddit format, the mystery aspect, the characters, just drew me in immediately! Also the plot twist at the end was insane, but there was enough subtle foreshadowing that it made perfect sense. Overall, insanely creative, no notes!

Aw tyy!! (Also I loveee your pfp!!) It took me forever to figure out the formatting so it would look like a real reddit story, I'm so happy with how it turned out!! :D

User avatar
oirichu
Review
oirichu wrote a review · Sun Aug 31, 2025 8:11 pm

This is really well scripted together! I was already taken in from when you mentioned the addition of Major Ocd. It ties back into the details of things being unkept, how everything slowly trickles into feeling like something is off but you can't put your finger on it and it drives you maddened insane till you fix it. The format reels in this immersiveness as if I am just reading another r/AIO post, and the questions won't stop forming as the words get lesser and lesser.

Thank you for the review, Oiri!! <3<3

<3 thank you for a wonderful read!

User avatar
Matt Bellamy
Review

I'm trying to think of what to say but my brain keeps saying "oh that's so weird" over and over, but in a good way! I love reading these sorts of posts on Reddit - AIO, AITA and so on - so I think the fact that you've written it in this format is so cool and accessible, and as others have said you've done a really good job with the formatting and the kind of language people use on Reddit. The ending is so surprising and crazy and leaves me with all kinds of questions! How much did the guy look like him? What else does she remember about the guy now that doesn't quite feel right - for example the way he kissed, or the language he used. Did anyone else see him in all that time he was there, and did they notice anything? Is it all in her head and she imagined the whole thing? I imagine it's the last one but can't be certain, and I both love and hate that I am left wondering!

There are just a couple of things that don't quite sound right for me. One is "it was just all around chaos." I'm not sure why, if chaos maybe sounds like too strong a word? Also about the forensics team, I wonder if they would actually come. Which also makes me wonder if the police or anyone else believed her or if she really struggled to get anyone to understand, so I'd love to have read more about that. But all in all, this is a great, imaginative piece, that works really well as it's grounded in such a familiar format!

User avatar
velvetcatsz
Comment

I think it's so unique...great work you've got here!

Thank you, cat!! <33

Glad to review! Keep writing, my friend!

User avatar
lalalucky
Review

this is just so insanely creative, ive genuinely never seen anything like this on here. to just burrow from something so real, but at times fictional, but also popular and niche at once, to create a short story like this is amazing. I also love how the language burrows from the posts on the subreddit; the amount of detail, the mixture of the formality and causality of some parts, mirrors both the real and the fake experiences on that subreddit, which adds to how ambiguous this story is. I also have to give props to the formatting. not only because it adds the immersion but also because the editing tool on this platform is so simple (yet sometimes complicated to use, perhaps because somehow that simplicity makes it complicated). the effort into making the formatting so precise with this simple, sometimes complicated, editing tool is just. yeah. i'll say it again. amazing.

the twist is interesting- and i definitely think the twist holds some weight. it does recontextualize some of the earlier text, and makes it believable that the outcome of the end was the reality of the story. i have to say i havent felt this passionate about commenting on a story in so long, like genuinely this is just so creative. like wow i'm so impressed, and i adore this usage of creativity and the editing tool so much!!

Omg ty sm for the comment, Lala! I really appreciate it and I'm so glad you liked my story!! <3<3

I'm sorry I had too, I can't let the meme die >:D

Random avatar
deleted46
Comment

this is so creative and well done!!!

Original and unique! Love it, Cupid!



I hate television. I hate it as much as peanuts. But I can't stop eating peanuts.
— Orson Welles