(Review: Ruelle and Altha just got pulled into an emergency with a local village woman who had been mysteriously injured. When Ruelle tried to help Altha administer an herbal treatment to counteract the poison, she accidentally made things worse by using a poisonous lookalike to the healing herb she was meant to use.
Also, Elfrida is the local woman whose house the injured woman was brought to, and Idylette is the injured woman's daughter.)
By the time everyone had departed who had no further need to remain by the injured woman, Ruelle felt very exhausted. Elfrida had persuaded Idylette to leave her mother’s side to have some tea and a little food, but only when Altha had assured Idylette that her mother’s condition was only growing more stable. This in addition to the younger woman’s own evident fatigue finally coaxed her away from the cot for a few minutes.
When Elfrida had Idylette engaged for the moment, Altha took Ruelle aside to speak to her.
In the flickering shadows cast by the remaining lamplight, she looked gravely into Rue’s face for a long moment. Ruelle wanted to look away, but she forced herself not to do so.
“You made a very grave error today,” Altha said at last.
Ruelle cringed at the directness of her words, but she knew they were true. She nodded miserably.
“I know. I’m so, so sorry. I really didn’t mean to. I didn’t even know about duskwither!”
Altha sighed.
“That’s just the thing. I explained it to you right as we were entering the wood to renew our supply of dawnshade. But now it is clear you were not listening.”
Looking back, Ruelle knew Altha was right. In fact, she did not even need to recall the day’s occurrences to know exactly why she had not been paying attention. She had been too caught up feeling hurt and disgruntled about the task, about the way Altha had shut down her questions about orcs, and about her whole situation in general.
“I know,” Ruelle admitted, averting her eyes. “It is my fault, and I’m sorry. Please believe me. I promise it wasn’t my intention to get the wrong thing!”
“I know, but intention isn’t enough,” Altha said sternly, her gray eyes hard. “A woman nearly died tonight! Your failure to pay attention could be the difference between life and death. Do you hear me?”
Ruelle nodded miserably. Tears pricked her eyes, and she hung her head to hide them. But Altha reached for her face and guided her chin back up until Ruelle made eye contact again.
“I haven’t known you for very long, Ruelle,” she said, her voice softer now. “But if I may make a conjecture, I believe you want to protect others. You want to do something significant, and you think that gathering herbs is a menial task. But you need to be present and pay attention no matter what you’re doing!”
Altha’s tone had dropped to hardly more than a whisper, but it was full of urgency, and her eyes looked into Ruelle’s with searching earnestness.
“You had me to save the day this time,” she continued. “But it is a marvel I acted quickly enough to save this woman, not to mention that my estimation for what kind of antidote I’d need to reverse the error fortunately appears to have worked.”
Ruelle followed her glance to the cot where the woman now at least seemed to be breathing calmly and evenly.
“It might not be that way next time, Ruelle,” Altha said soberly, bringing her attention back. “That is why you need to learn to care, to pay attention to detail. You must learn that every choice you make, every detail you observe or overlook, is vital even in matters you think to be the smallest.”
Ruelle sighed heavily.
“That’s why you are suited to do these things and I am not!” Her shoulders sagged in defeat.
“You do not have a choice, Ruelle,” Altha stated. “You are an apprentice of the kingdom of Paxaria now, and you must do your best in the role you have been given. Anything less would be an injustice to the kingdom.”
“If they wanted me to do justice to the kingdom, they would have put me amongst the warriors training to fight, where I thought I was going to be!”
Ruelle turned away unhappily.
“And yet your responsibility is no less.”
Ruelle tugged on a lock of hair. She didn’t know what to say. But she did not need to, because at that moment, the woman stirred on the cot, opened her eyes, and looked around in confusion and panic.
Altha was at her side in an instant.
“Easy, now,” she said, placing a gentle hand on the woman’s arm. “You’ve just had a major injury, so don’t try to move much yet.”
The woman moaned painfully and tried to raise her good arm to cover her eyes, as if the light in the room were too much.
Ruelle’s heart pounded as hope and fear mingled their powerful streams, the one warm, the other cold, and shot through her like a great geyser.
“Bring some water, Ruelle,” Altha ordered.
Ruelle wasted no time in obeying, and by the time she came back into the room, Idylette and Elfrida had joined the gathering around the cot.
Altha carefully helped the injured woman take a small drink of water.
“Oh, I’m ever so glad you’re awake, Mysie!” Elfrida cried tearfully. She clasped her hands together in relief, but seemed unsure where to look, perhaps afraid the anxiety that still remained would evidence itself in her eyes and betray the weight of the situation.
Idylette just knelt by her mother’s side weeping silently, too overcome with emotion to speak. Rue eyed her warily and stepped around to Altha’s other side. She had begun to worry that Idylette would be angry at her for the mistake with the duskwither.
“What . . . what happened?” the injured woman managed to say in a frail, cracked voice. With her good arm, she had reached up to feel the bandages on her other shoulder, her fingers fumbling to investigate the wrapping that covered the ugly gash left by the stranger’s blade.
“Don’t try to talk too much right now,” Altha soothed, placing a cool, damp cloth on the woman’s forehead. “You’ve already exerted yourself a lot just now. You need to rest and get your strength back.”
Ruelle noticed with relief when Idylette took her mother’s hand and held it, keeping the patient from messing with the bandages.
“Idylette,” the woman whispered, becoming aware of her daughter’s presence. Her eyes searched the other faces around her. “Elfrida? Tell me.”
“Just rest, Mysie,” Elfrida said, still not meeting the other woman’s eyes. “That’s what the physician told you. There will be plenty of time to catch you up on things tomorrow.”
Less than an hour later, Ruelle settled in for a long, anxious night. She sensed an unspoken expectation that she was to stay near the patient the whole time like Altha did, although her mentor never instructed her to do so. But either way, whether Ruelle was told to do it or not, guilt for her grave error drove her to the rejection of her own comfort.
End of chapter
Continue to next chapter To Paxaria: part 5.0Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Hi Winny! Here to check out another glorious chapter of this story! This is a bit of a shorter chapter, but there are a lot of important character moments!
𔓘 Writing Commentary 𔓘
I like that Altha’s words here aren’t exactly made to hurt Ruelle. They are more or less stern. These are real situations they are being thrown into, and I’m sure Altha recognizes there is more at risk than Rue knows. Either way, I think she’s a good mentor. She even goes further to show that she understands Ruelle in the next lines!
I will also say here that I think you are doing a good job of characterizing Ruelle, flaws and all. A character like her could EASILY turn annoying. However, her flaws are clearly recognized by the story and she is punished for them. It feels less like a product of brattiness and more a product of misinformation (in terms of expecting to be a warrior but then being assigned to someone else), which she can’t really be blamed for as a fourteen (or was it fifteen?) year old girl.
❀ Closer ❀
Seems like Ruelle is starting to learn a bit more about how the life of a physician really is. I love how you handled the conversation between the mentor and student, and the ending of this chapter is a nice capstone on the events of chapter 4 as a whole!
Heya Winny! I've been going through my reviews and noticed that I somehow forget to leave reviews on some of other chapters of this story, so here comes the crow once again! There's possibility that this review will be a little bit different then those you're used to from me since I already read next chapters, so I have a little bit of a different insight on stuff...but let's go down to business, right? I'll try out my review template this time, so let's see where this goes!
First impressions
Well, that's a chapter! At first glance, it has a slightly different pace than the others and some might say it's "boring", but I disagree, because even though it may not seem like it at first glance (we spend most of the chapter reading the dialogue between two characters), chapters like these are what really deepen the chapters. So from my point of view, it made total sense for both the plot and the characters for this chapter to happen the way it did. Thanks to what I saw in the future through my oracle ball (I also read the following chapters, lol), I know that the things that happened here will still be in the story and leave their mark. So the first impression is pretty good, I also really like that you started adding summaries of what happened before at the beginning of the chapters (I'm not sure if I mentioned it in other reviews, so I'll say it like that now)
What's up, crows? (characters)
I always have a weakness for analyzing characters in stories and this chapter is great material for that, so here we go!
I think in terms of character development that we've had so far, this is probably the most important and pivotal moment for Ruelle. Because yes, she made a gigantic mistake, but how she responded to it is extremely important. I like that you didn't choose the path of unnecessary angst-creating here and instead gave Ruelle the opportunity to not only realize her mistake, but also to admit it. That, that's important, and it's clear from the entire chapter (and the beginning of the next one) that Rue is all too aware of what she did and what the consequences could have been. We also have this moment:
which I think nicely shows how the whole situation is getting a little bit more intense. Throughout the story so far, we sense that Rue can't come to terms with being an apothecary's apprentice. Here it's clear on the page, Rue says it to Altha's face. I overally found whole their discussion really interesting and well written, not too repetetive but staying in character. That's not always easy to do with emotion-driven chapters, but you did a pretty good job!
As old tale says... (plot)
I think this chapter moves the plot forward in a different way than the previous ones (and the upcoming ones). As I've mentioned a few times, this is a chapter driven by characters who have been through a lot of stress and now have to sort out the causes and talk about the consequences. I think from a character perspective the plot definitely moved forward, but also from an overall "bigger picture" perspective we had a contribution from this chapter when the mature woman woke up. I like that you didn't just let the whole chapter run with just the conversation between Altha and Rue, because that would have been a bit boring.
Shiny stuff (or what worked well)
Why do I feel like I've already praised most of the things I liked in other parts of the review??? I need to start paying attention to that...so, here's a quick summary of what worked well in the story from my perspective! I loved how Altha reacted throughout the dialogue between her and Rue, it really showed her values and it really solidified her as a character! Ooo, and I really liked the ending too: Kinda depressive as heck, but it shows the point of chapter and that Rue took a lesson from everything that happened. At this point I honestly think that this girl deserves a hug.
- Kay, your local (friendly?) crow
Ah nein, my template has betrayed me.
Hello once again, Winny!
Just here to leave you a quick review. I have caught up with the story so far and things are much clearer and fresher now. Also really appreciate the 'review' section you have at the start. Great refresher for my forgetful brain! Anyway, let's get started.
FIRST IMPRESSIONS
This chapter (or part of a chapter) wraps up the first part really nicely. It gives us some time for Altha and Ruelle to actually talk about Rue's mistake outside of a crisis situation and the woman surviving makes the guilt Rue feels a little less. I can imagine the guilt to be 10x worse had she died...
HIGHLIGHTS
You focus alot on conveying the gravity of Rue's mistake and for it to come from Altha is super important. I really liked how Rue gets progressively more guilty the more Altha reprimands her but Altha switches her tone when she realised Rue was on the brink of tears.
Interesting. Altha appeals to Rue's service to the kingdom as opposed to appealing to her desire to help others and make a difference. If I recall correctly, Rue was pretty upset she was assigned to healer and not a warrior when Altha and Rue first met.
I think this reveals alot about how Altha sees their role. She sees the responsibility of a warrior equal to that of a healer even though they may be different. A common responsibility to serve their kingdom despite their differing roles. That type of mentality that leans towards service wherever you are needed shows Altha's experience and maturity in contrast to Rue's youthful ambition and perhaps even tunnel vision with regards to her aspirations. I don't know if Rue gets that yet as the conversation was cut short but time will tell.
THE NITPICKS
And nitpick is all I can do, really. The main takeaway from this chapter as a whole plot-wise would be the poisoned weapon belonging to an outsider but character-wise it's Rue's mistake followed by her guilt. I think rounding out the chapter with at least a mention of the poisoned weapon (even if it is in passing) may help carry momentum into the next chapter.
Lastly, I just wanted to touch on the point of nicknames. I notice you often fluctuate between Ruelle and Rue in actual narration. This can cause a bit of confusion on first read considering it is not uncommon for people to have very similar names in the same scene. I think a compromise to keep the nickname (which I like. Always adds a bit of personality to writing) would be to refer to one of them in dialogue (so Altha exclusively calls her Ruelle) and the narrator exclusively uses Rue? Or the other way round? Up to you. Just a minor thought but not a big deal. As I said, nitpicks all round.
CLOSING THOUGHTS
Overall, I really liked the closing of chapter 4 and it ties up the immediate problem with the woman being on the brink of death. It also effectively pushes forward Rue's character. Interested to see where this story goes. Feel free to tag me when you post
Happy Writing!
-Reaper