“What, have you never seen a Human boy before?”
The male voice was a mixture of bemusement and irritation, and Ruelle made a face before she could think to stop herself.
“Of course I have,” she retorted. And then to be safe, she added, “And my apologies. I didn’t mean to be staring. I was just surprised at how young you are.”
The lanky, tan-complexioned boy on the ship’s deck stood up straighter. “I’m older than I look!”
Ruelle brushed wind-blown dark curls back from her face and frowned. “How old are you?”
“I’m fourteen!”
“That’s how old you look,” Ruelle told him matter-of-factly.
“Oh.” He seemed a little underwhelmed and suddenly unsure what to do with his long limbs.
“Don’t worry, though,” Ruelle rushed to reassure him. “I didn’t mean you look like a child. I only meant that you’re much younger than most of the other men here.”
“So?” A defensive note edged his voice. “I can learn to fight just as well as any of the men here!”
“Of course!” Ruelle said. Why must she always seem to insult people when she did not mean to do so? “I wasn’t trying to say otherwise.”
An awkward silence fell between them. Each stared the other down uncertainly, the sea breezes blowing around them, until Ruelle broke the tension with the option that seemed safest.
“Well,” she said, straightening her skirt, “We should start over with a proper introduction. My name is Ruelle Eastwood, but my family calls me Rue. I come from Whispertide, the middle island.”
The youth’s face cleared visibly, and he extended his hand.
“I’m Gaius Aldhelm – and my father says I have a very fitting surname because I can be just as hard-headed as an old helmet. So you can call me either Gaius or just Aldhelm.” He grinned, and added, “We come from Blue Fog.”
“That’s the smaller island just to the North of Whispertide,” Ruelle recalled.
“And the best of the Three, if I do say so myself,” Gaius commented with a dramatic wink. “I’m going to make sure Blue Fog gets the reputation it deserves before all this is over.”
“So,” Ruelle said cautiously, “You’re going to be a fighter?”
“I hope so! That’s what we’re all going to the mainland for, right? Well, probably most of us, anyway. What about you?”
“I want to be a fighter, too,” Ruelle said. She felt herself standing taller and prouder even as she spoke the words. “I don’t know what my chances are, though, being a girl, and only fifteen – but I am still hoping.”
“Well! Fifteen? That probably makes you the youngest of the women here, just like I’m the youngest of the men here, so we have a common woe!”
Gaius’ wide grin was so silly and yet so sincere that Ruelle could not help but smile in return. As if on cue, they both turned to face the horizon where the twilight was just beginning to rise.
“I can’t wait to get there,” Gaius sighed “And to think – we should arrive tomorrow!”
“It almost feels like a far-off dream that will just disappear if I wake up,” Ruelle said. “I’ve never left Whispertide in my life before now. I’m pretty sure I don’t even have one recollection of meeting anyone other than a Human in my entire life – though my father tells me there were some Gnomes that passed through our town once or twice when I was small.”
“Mine is the same story,” Gaius agreed. “I doubt an Elf or Dwarf or Faerie or anything has ever graced Blue Fog with its presence for a hundred years! And there’ve definitely never been anything like orcs or ogres or trolls to disrupt the peace with their ugly faces.”
Ruelle laughed. In all the long hours of being on this ship, she had neither spoken nor connected much with anyone else, but now, oddly enough, she felt at ease with Gaius. She was even enjoying herself.
“My knowledge of the world outside of Whispertide mainly comes from my father’s tales,” she agreed. “Or the scattered tales of someone who was part of a past Tribute and actually came back to the Islands. A place like mainland Paxaria is practically a faerieland to me!”
“It is a faerieland,” Gaius enthused. “I mean, there are literal faerie there, or so they say, but not many people see them often. They’re very evasive. And merfolk! Can you believe people near the coasts have actually interacted with merfolk?” His eyes sparkled with childlike enthusiasm. “What’s the first thing you hope to see in Paxaria?”
Ruelle gazed out over the water thoughtfully for a moment. For years she had weighed this very question in her own mind. What else could she do, when she had grown up in the Three Islands, where every three years seventy-five people from their all-human population were sent as a Tribute to the multicultural mainland? The stories that came back with anyone who returned to their humble home were filled with marvels of people, places, and events Ruelle could only imagine but would almost certainly never see on Whispertide. She had tried all her life to decide which would be the most fascinating to behold, but she’d struggled to settle on just one.
But in this moment, a single thing arose swiftly to the forefront of her mind.
“I want to see Wonders,” she said decidedly.
“Ah, yes, the Wonders of the world!” Gaius beamed. “Do you suppose they truly exist outside of the tales we’ve heard? Humans can do no Wonders, of course, so perhaps it’s all just made up by returning Tribute members who want to sound important for what they’ve seen.”
“No, I think they are real,” Ruelle said. “They’ve got to be at least as real as King Alroy’s castle or the Gnomes and their little shops, or anything else we’ve heard about. Besides,” she continued, “Why would proud Tribute members who want to show off come back and boast about something they themselves cannot do?”
“You’re right. I never thought of that,” Gaius agreed. “There really would be nothing in it for them. After all, do you know how lousy it must feel to see the Wonders of all the different people and yet have nothing of the like to show for your race?”
Ruelle did know, or at least she had an estimation of how terrible it would feel. As thrilling as it was to think she’d likely soon be able to see people perform legendary Wonders, it had been bothering her the last few days in nearly as much measure as it had been bringing excitement.
“Well,” she said, raising her chin determinedly, “You don’t need to be able to do Wonders to be a fighter for your land. That’s what you and I are probably going to be. We will make a name for ourselves and our Islands, Wonders or no.”
Again, Gaius smiled broadly. “I like that spirit,” he said.
___
Although Ruelle knew the ship was not expected to reach the mainland until the next morning, she found it hard not to stand on the deck as often as she could, gazing out across the water, imagining she could see the form of land taking shape on the horizon. Even after the stars were out that night, she still stood at the post she had taken to frequenting. It felt a little silly and immature to indulge in the thought that she was journeying to the land of her childhood faerie tales, but nonetheless, it was a reality. Ruelle felt as if some tiny, magical, winged creatures were dancing within her very heart.
The sound of footsteps behind her caught her attention. There were not many other people out on the ship’s deck at this time of night.
“I heard you talking to that young boy earlier,” a low female voice drifted to Ruelle’s ear from close behind her. Ruelle turned, but found she did not know the name of the young woman standing there.
“You mean Gaius?” Ruelle asked. She suddenly felt uncomfortable at the idea that someone had been eavesdropping.
“Yes, I believe that’s his name.” The other girl was at Ruelle’s side now, close enough that Ruelle could see the moon’s glint off her dark irises.
“Well, what about it?”
“He seems very enthusiastic,” she mused. “You don’t really think you’re going to the mainland to be trained as fighters, do you?”
Ruelle backed a step away. The closeness of this stranger felt prickly. “Why not?
One of the young woman’s shoulders rose in a half shrug, and a soft half laugh escaped her lips.
“Just like the boy,” she said, almost more to herself than to Ruelle. “You think that just because Tribute members are usually trained for the military that all of us on this ship are destined for the same.”
“Well, what about it?” Ruelle said, neither admitting nor denying the stranger’s words.
“Nothing.” The young woman mirrored Ruelle’s crossed arms. “I just think your expectations are misplaced if that’s what you think is going to happen. And from your conversation earlier, I gathered that you and the boy are both under that impression.”
The heat of rising annoyance burned in Ruelle’s chest.
“You had not right to be eavesdropping on other people’s conversation, you know,” she accused.
“It wasn’t eavesdropping, only overhearing. And I am simply telling you because I want to set your expectations right.”
“What are you talking about?” Ruelle demanded.
The young woman quirked an eyebrow. When she spoke, she drew out her words slowly, as if to a child.
“If you need it in so many words, I am telling you that you should not expect to gain the warrior’s glory you talked about. Neither you nor that Gaius boy should expect to be taken to be trained as fighters. Do you think that because there are reports of unrest in Etelka and Bexley in the East that Paxaria is desperate enough to recruit people so young for their military forces? Do you think that simply because there are one hundred and twenty-five of us in this Tribute instead of just seventy-five that they’re taking us all to train us with sword and spear? I would not set my heart on that, Ruelle Eastwood.”
Ruelle felt more uneasy than ever, but she dared not show it to this unfamiliar woman. More than that, she despised the thought of displaying her discomfort.
“So,” she said, trying to keep her voice cool and even. “What exactly do you presume they have in mind for us?”
Another soft sound resembling a snort came from the other woman.
“Nothing so fanciful as all that. Many of us will likely be scattered here and there, placed in whatever inglorious roles they deem we will be most useful.”
Ruelle squinted her eyes, looking the stranger up and down, trying to discern what she was on about and how much she should believe her. In any case, Ruelle wanted to be away from this woman.
“Well, your words are duly noted,” Ruelle said stiffly. She straightened her shoulders and her skirts, and pushed away from the railing. “We will see how things fall out tomorrow. Good night.”
With that, she stalked away to her quarters.
Still, the other woman’s words were a very rough pillow for Ruelle’s head all through the night.
Was she right? The more Ruelle pondered it, the more sense she saw in what the strange young woman had said, regardless of how desperately she wanted to push it away.
Was it true that Paxaria was not as in need of warrior trainees as Ruelle had been led to believe? Were the rumored threats of war truly as far away still as Etelka and Bexley? What kind of mundane duties might she be allotted after all? Ruelle tried not to entertain ugly imaginations, but she still could not keep her mind from painting undesirable images of being a slave to an ugly old Dwarf who kept her in shabby living quarters. She pictured herself being assigned some ignoble responsibility such as sweeping streets in a slum somewhere while beautiful young Elves passed by and wrinkled up their noses at her or armies of strong men and women paraded past her on their way to exciting battles.
Suddenly, the wonderful faerieland images of Paxaria burst like a bubble pricked by an unsympathizing needle. Never in all her life would Ruelle have anticipated that she could have possibly felt such a foreboding sense of gloom as the shores of Paxaria drew nearer. Never would she have imagined that she would actually dread arriving there.
And yet as the dawn broke the sleepless night, Ruelle felt for the first time on that entire journey that she wanted to turn around the ship bound to faerieland and go back home.
End of chapter
Continue to next chapter To Paxaria: part 2.0Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Hey! Ages ago you asked me to check out this story in my review thread. I would still like to honor this ask, so I’ll be chipping my way through this story!
It seems we start out in media res, after these characters have all boarded a ship to go to the mainland
⟡ Recommendations ⟡
I have no specific recommendations, but I feel like the beginning of this story could be a little stronger? When I’m beginning to read, I usually want to know who we are following, what world we are in, and why are we following who we are following?
I believe you succeed in this, but seeing the introductions and brief conversations at the beginning here left me confused for a second. I feel like it would be better to focus on descriptions and really zero in on Rue’s personality and goals. Of course, this is figured out later, but the conversation that we see at the beginning didn’t really add much to me. It was just sorta word salad. I could be wrong, this is just a recommendation!
𔓘 Writing Commentary 𔓘
Despite my previous recommendations, I feel like I could tell Ruelle was our main character here. I think she’s pretty interesting thus far!
Something like [i]this[/] is why I think she is interesting. We get a clear picture of what her goal here is and we also learn a bit of her backstory. I like that she seems interested in seeing the wonders. Like she is more interested in seeing the world than truly becoming a warrior.
I also LOVE that you end this off with a bunch of questions that shake Rue’s resolve. It makes me want to read on and also leaves me wondering what the truth of the mainland is.
❀ Closer ❀
Sorry this is sort of brief, I’m a little tired today. But I will persist and read on!
Hmm, looks like Ruelle is in quite the dilemma here! Going to an entirely new land and suddenly feeling like you don't know what to expect there is really frightening. This setting seems interesting - I wonder what sort of history Paxaria has that it has ended up being a sort of multicultural hub (whereas the Three Islands seemingly only have Humans?). I'm planning to hop over and give some of the chapters of this story in the Green Room a review, so I guess I'll soon find out c:
Hello Hello I hope you dont mind me popping in with a quick review. I must thank you for requesting one and being patient. With this in mind, I do want to warn you that this might focus more on feedback than highlights as this has a few reviews already and I want my reviews to be as helpful as they can be. Let's get into it, shall we?
Overall this is a promising start albeit I do have some thoughts but that's for later. You seem to have a grasp on the world and the hints we do get are interesting for sure. This feels like it has the chance to start quite the journey and that's always fun when it comes to fantasy. I cant wait to see how all these races interact later on.
I found this a fun little bit of prose it does make me wonder what fairies are actually like if common descriptions are used like butterflies in someone's stomach. Regardless this does give the world some texture as well as the prose I would love to see more touches like this.
Now I want to move on to feedback as I have a few big thoughts rather than line-level critiques. Do keep in mind I'm not a professional nor do you need to use anything I say. You are the author after all.
This first one might just be my taste but the characters don't feel grounded. What I mean is the characters don't interact with the setting nor is it described with the prose. This is important when it comes to starting a novel but doubly when comes to high fantasy since the world is often wildly different. Settings can inform the tone and possibly themes, but it can be tricky to make it feel alive. However, I feel it's needed here to settle the reader into this world.
Now it doesn't have to be anything sweeping but I think slipping in small details between dialogue would help. For example, the battered floor creaking, the smell of salt against rocking waves, or the cast losing their balance and bumping into rickety handrails. This would immerse the reader in the story more and that's key when it comes to first chapters. Remember to use the senses to make prose vivid.
The second thing I want to bring up could also be a matter of my taste but the start feels abrupt. Sure the opening line is a great hook but to me, it feels like the start of a second chapter that jumps into a pre-established sence. This gets compounded by the exchange later on where the wonders, tributes, orcs and so on are introduced. It feels like a lot to dump on the readers with no explanation to the point I thought I missed a prologue or something.
However, this has an easy fix but would require changing the setup a bit. I would recommend starting the chapter with the tributes visiting to promote themselves here we could explain what they are and what they do. Furthermore, they could tell their battle stories and this is how we get introduced to the wonders and what they do. You could also slip in things like the dwarfs or orcs through that as well. As for how they get on the ship Ruelle could impulsively stow away and bump
into Gaius who did the same. This could also raise the stakes and open conflict.
Lastly, You tell when I feel body language could get the same type of emotion across. For example, I want to pinpoint a line.
I feel to convey this without telling the readers point blank you could lean into the movements she might be doing without thinking. For example, you could describe her jaw tightening and her posture being more closed off. Another sign could be her weight shifting or her fingers twitching. Small details like this can deepen character and feel more natural I would keep this in mind the next time you want to state how a character might be feeling. The Emotion Thesaurus is a great resource for this stuff and there's a free but limited blog version as well.
Regardless this could be a great start with a bit of polish. I wouldn't mind checking out the rest and if time allows review. However, If you have any questions please ask and I would be happy to answer.
As always, keep writing and remember to drink water!
Thanks for the review!
I'll get to this sometime tomorrow or at the end of the week. Dont worry!
Hi! Kay is here with review
(I was writing review as I was writing so you probably will see my real emotions about this amazingly-looking-first-chapter)
Amazing first line. We do not know literally anything about the world yet...but first thing we find out is that there are some other species than humans and that our (for now) nameless main character probably isn´t one of them.
Okay, I love how this dialogue goes. It is pretty natural and reader can imagine it very easily.
I really enjoy the way how you put worldbuilding bits nad pieces into your story. You do not infodump, which is amazing. But we still slowly learn a lot of small important details about world, so we can understan what is going on.
I just really enjoyed reading these little description. Maybe it looks like just some paragraph, but htere are so many tiny details which sets the atmosphere of leaving your home to place who until now existed only in fairytales for Ruelle. I like the little description of how she feels about both being on ship and feeling about journey ahead.
Oooh, okay...I was really intrigued from the moment stranger came in, but after this part, I just wanted to yell: ,,WAIT, I NEED EXPLANATIONS!"
Another interesting worldbuilding details! I know I probably already mentioned it, but your way how to put informations which reader needs to know is amazing and pretty sophisticated!
I also like how Ruelle reacts later. How she slowly realises that the fact, that she does not like the truth doesn´t make the truth less...real. Her thinking trail is written pretty well.
Great ending - not a cliffhanger, which would not really even fit in the absolute beggining of this story, but still making reader wonder, what comes next. And lucky me can go right to next chapter!
Have a nice rest of day/night/whatever since timezones are weird and stay safe!
*screechhhhhhh* I made it. A little late, but I'm here. Let's get into it, shall we? I review as I go. Let's go!
that's a great opener right there. At first I expected fantasy but then I realized that the remark was a little sarcastic which instantly added depth to your character. I will say capitalizing "human" brought what I felt like was a bit too much emphasis on the word like Human is one race of creatures and there's all these other creatures too. But that may just be personal preference.I have to say I absolutely loved this interaction. The characters feel so real. I love that.
And I thought THAT was numerous. This line almost had me laugh out loud. this adds a touch of personality and physical description along with humour all in one! Nicely done!!
Im kind of doubtful about what he says about it being the best of the three (which I wasn't entirely sure why that was capitalized in the dialogue but maybe that's how they do it in your world?) Either way, I suspect the boy is being just a bit too proud of his birth country.
That first line, xD! So perfect. I am getting the feeling that the two won't be so far off from becoming good acquaintances as maybe those first few lines of the narrative maybe suggested. I will say that you should probably skip a period after "sighed."
Okay now I understand why Human was capitalized but a question...Why isnt orc, troll, or any of the other bad creatures capitalized? I feel like it might be more uniform to either capitalize them all or none of them.
I think maybe you should pluralize "faerie."
Now this magical land they are going to visit... It does seem like a fairytale...almost like a government convention. I fear that there is something very very dark about this place and given the young ages of these two characters, I fear even more. Maybe I'm adding a dark twist, but it's still a thought. Gaius even sounds a tiny bit skeptical about this...
I really liked that detail about her imagining the land in the distance. This goes a long way to show how excited she is about this trip and I do not really sense any unease in her except to try to catch herself from being told childish in her thoughts. You captured a great picture of this girl and her age. It is very important to not be seen as childish in that age. Nicely done! I also loved the detail about her feeling that there's a magical beast inside her dancing. I take that to mean her heart beat but said in a very whimsical and childlike enthusiastic way. She is not scared. She is excited and that's why you chose that metaphor which ties into the narrative super well!
Now a few thoughts on the woman's conversation...It did definitely bring out a sense of foreboding. And I thought it extra creepy that she used Ruelle's full name. Clearly, she was listening way too well to what was being said. I do expect this to not be what Ruelle expects. And I personally expect this to be a tragedy. We'll just have to see.
Overall, this is a pretty good opening. I already pointed out the little polishing needed on grammer, but I also want to say that this pair of shoes seems to have a slight case of the trailing shoelace toward the end. I felt that the conversation between Ruelle and the woman could be shortened to make it better. I also want to know why the woman approached her. I feel like if the woman had an actual purpose to be out that late like if say she happened to pass Ruelle and stopped to talk for a bit on her way to do something else then maybe you could more cleverly hide the fact that you are introducing a new element to the storyline. As it is written, the latter part of the piece feels a bit forced and unnatural. If you could somehow present another purpose for the woman to have then I feel like the storyline would be a little more realistic and opportunistic. Also, sometimes the less that is said, the more mysterious the whole thing would be. Like maybe cut the explanations and just have the woman say something like "I wouldn't be so optimistic as you are." Or something like that. What you don't want to do is reveal all the secrets tol earlier and in a case like this, I feel like the less said in that scene, the faster it will go, and the more mysterious it will sound.
That aside, nice pair of dancing shoes! I even see some faeries etched at the toes:D
Hope this helps!
-Kaia
Thanks so much for the insightful review!
You're welcome!!
The opening line is so good! It immediately tells a lot about the world we are in! Asking if Ruelle has ever seen a human boy implies there are other creatures around that are also common to see. Immediately you know that there’s some fantasy aspects to this!
I also think all the names, of characters and places, are SO COOL! Im very curious what kind of place blue fog is, and what the different islands are. Also love the choice spelling of Faerie!
I think you start this off really strong with a good opening, a natural introduction to the characters, establishing the MC goal and already having conflict with achieving it. I cant wait until they dock at Paxaria and see what it’s like.
It’s a short review but I think you did really well and cant wait to see what happens next!!
-taithoes <3
First off, thanks for the review! Also, there are more parts to this story up now if you're interested in it or if you want to review it for the points.