As you can see from crits this story wasn't original or exciting. I decided to make a whole new story. check it out
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
I agree with Cheeky Coconut on this one. But I like some of it too. Keep up the good work
Fearful winds screamed as dark energy concentrated onto into the palm of shady figure. Twirling his hands, he forced the energy into crowds of helpless villagers who were burnt, frozen, or electrocuted. Bringing terror to the innocent, he moved from village to village leaving each in flames. He Summoning fierce tornadoes or other natural disasters.
Sorry in advance for lack of showing here, the forum rejected my word processor form of strike through and other changes. However, on to the critique.
As an editor, I feel that you are able to do a little better on your check through, a lot of adverbs and adjectives (baggage) filled this piece. Another heavy note was the lack of active writing, you were far too passive even in your opening paragraph which I modified as an example. Please watch your use of tenses as well, this was caught by Sleeping Valor, but I can give several other examples which tense switches were done.
As for the actual substance of the story, it was not really original to be honest, and the use of the dream cliche to start was not original in the least, but its your story. Use it as say, a vision or some other means of connecting this idea to your character to make it original and give depth to it at the same time.
Much larger note, let's strike all the inner thoughts and telling aspect and break down the story structure itself. We are lacking a lot of description about who the character is and what makes him an individual that we could relate to or at least feel emotion for him based on our own judgements.
I think its a clear, everyone would be much happier witnessing these events then you (the author) telling us outright. After all, it shows who he is rather then 'what' he is.
I might suggest you do this in italic, since it's a dream. Unless you really don't want people to know it's a dream, but it might confuse them.
I am very tired, so lemme know if you want me to do the rest of what you've got like I've done here.
*hugs!* Great work! You've improved your story quite a lot since the first version. ^_^ There's quite a lot less telling and much more showing and you've added description and given it a true 'story' feel as opposed to a 'resume' feel. It's great to see how dedicated you are to improving this. Keep it up!
^_^ Keek!
Hmm very good.
I like the fact that this is from a bad guys point of viw, a nice change.
However.
I don't like the opening sentence, it can be more powerful compared to rast of the writing which is really good. You need to realy hit the readers with some powerful description.
Overall, this is lacking in descrpition and relation to characters involved. No emotions are mentioned, thoughts?
Other than that, really liked, keep it up =D
x
i will take these into consideration
Quite a few grammar issues, but I'll fix that in a moment.
It has great potential, but I agree with the others (Show don't tell). The story has a great plot and great potential, but It seems to me you sat down at your desk, glanced at your watch, realized, "Crud, I have thirty minutes to write the entire thing" and slapped it down on paper. I don't see any thought process at all. I'm not saying there wasn't, I just don't see it. Spend a lot more time on it.
My suggestion is to rewrite. I know, it's an ugly word--that word has chased me into nightmares many, many times--but it's something we all have to do. It seems like a fun thing to write, though; maybe it won't be so bad.
You do tell more than you show, as Valor pointed out. Instead of even showing it the way she suggested, perhaps you could actually take us through Severis's (answer honestly: was that taken from HP?) young life. Give him flash-backs (where we get to hear about exactly what he did - narrate it for us) or even just begin the story earlier, so we can watch him grow up and watch his evil father train him.
Remember to review other people. Keep the ratio 2 reviews:1 post if you can. It helps everyone in the community. Welcome to YWS.
~GryphonFledgling
Yeah, I agree that you used too much "straight-out fact". And some of your sentences are... long and confusing.
One that stood out was: "His father, also a sorcerer, trained a raised him to be a merciless sorcerer who brutalized whoever stepped in his way to greatness."
Here's what I would suggest: "His father, also a sorcerer, had trained Severis to be merciless--one who brutalized anyone who stepped in his path to greatness."
Teh Wozzinator
Ok. Many different points here.
Good luck!
1) You have an interesting plot here. It has a lot of potential.
2) You are telling, not showing. This isn't a good thing. It kind of reads like a synopsis, or one of those resume's you read on the back/inside cover of a book. People will find this boring. ex: "Young sorcerer Severis had evil roots in his family tree." This could become something like...
"Severis set down his spell book and sighed, looking about him. The hall where he studied was a monument to his family; symbols of domination and past sins mounted on the walls like trophies." (Don't use this, it sucks. =P) This is showing. We see he is a sorcerer because he has a spell book and we see his family has a dark past because his eyes show us his world. This is what readers will eat up. They like to live the story, not be told what they missed. =P
3) Spacing. I'd maybe space your story out more--maybe split it into two paragraphs. It will make it easier to read.
^_^ No further comments. Hope that helps a little. This looks very interesting, it just needs a little more show and a little less tell.
^_^ Keek!